7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pataskala

“Great Pizza and the Chicken Mo Mo is delicious! Highly recommend!“

“We just ordered takeout pizza from our hometown Mama Linda's! I swear it's the best I've had in almost 2 years, when I was in New York City! They have that chewy inside cracker outside crust & it was perfectly cooked. And those square cut pie pieces - totally on brand for Ohio! I love Mama Linda's, if you're ever in Pataskala definitely stop by for some of that pie!“

“Love this place! Great pizza at a great price and locally owned!“

“We kind of discovered Elliot's through pure serendipity. We were in the downtown Newark area looking for a new place to eat and my wife was not having much luck finding anything on her phone. I just randomly pulled into a vacant parking slot so that I could take a shot and when I looked up Elliot's was right in front of us. We decided it was fate and walked in. We were met with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and prompt service. Although they specialize in pizza, we are not the types that order pizza when we go out, so I opted for the street tacos (two fish and two shrimp) while my wife ordered the Philly sandwich. The beer selection was amazing and we walked out feeling like we had lucked into a gem of a dining experience. Since then, we have been to the locations in Pataskala and New Albany on several occasions and so far we have not been disappointed. Lately, I have been going with the Steakhouse Salad which is totally delicious. Price is commiserate with the overall dining experience. If you haven't tried Elliot's yet I strongly encourage you to do so.“

“The signature pizza is hands-down the best there is. People who quibble over curb appeal and cinnamon sticks are delusional. Pizza is not made from cauliflower-go eat a broccoli salad if this is your thing! Masseys pizza is the only place where the advertisement uses the actual product, and not some fake staged version. If you want the best, pay a few bucks more and don't whine about them being busy.“

“This was genuinely one of the BEST pizzas I’ve had! The sauce is robust and not at all acidic. The pepperoni and cheese were top quality as well as the crust. I will absolutely be back! Would recommend to anyone!“

“Our family just had an amazing experience with our local Donatos in Pataskala. While food order has been on point and deliveries on time - this experience really went above and beyond. With long work days and endless things to deal with …we ordered delivery and elected to pay cash. Paid for our order and tip, didn’t think anything of it. While we were enjoying our sub and salad we get a phone call from the store. Turns out that an extra $50 bill ended up hiding in the pile of cash given to our driver. They called to let us know and the driver brought it back - we did throw in additional tip. I can’t express my gratitude enough and am beyond impressed with the level of honesty we just experienced. I would recommend this location over and over! Thank you“