17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pickerington

“This is quite possibly the best meatball sub I have ever had! The flavors were bold, the extra cheese delivered. And the meatballs were well seasoned, tender and very tasty. The only reason I’m giving this restaurant a four is because my order through Uber eats only came with the sandwich not the cake or my beverage. But I can definitely look past that and will be ordering again for my next cheat meal.“

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

“Mod Pizza on Hill Road in Pickerington is a great place to eat, it is wonderful to get what you order the way you order it with a friendly staff. You are greeted when you enter the restaurant and when you leave. A very enjoyable staff and eating out experience.“

“Good food Good service Pizza was awesome!! I would highly recommend!!“

“We ordered a monster sub and the meatballs with cheese yesterday about 730pm. We were next door for pool league, she told me 25 min for a sub and meatballs, I figured they were backed up for 25 min, I set timer and walked down 2 min before it went off, food was on rack, it obviously was sitting there for some time as the sub meat was COLD. My husband was so upset lol. The meatballs were the size of spaghettiO’s meatballs. The taste was there but the toddler size meatballs were shameful. We’ve gotten these a few times before and never ever were they this tiny To charge $9’for 6 of these is sinful lol Def turned off for awhile , be back at a much later date I sent a message last night before writing this. It’s still unanswered“

“Nene and Ezekiel were awesome with the service they provided! It was a miscommunication of my order and they were so polite and respectful. I was amazed . They even gave me the pizza that I didn’t order for free ! I thank you guys for being so patient and respectful. The little things go so far. I’ll be back soon. And again thank you guys“

“We have eaten at a few others and you are up there with the best . Certainly much better than Lewis Center.“

“My husband and I have eaten take out here several times. The food is fantastic!! Great pizza, Stromboli, pasta dishes. We used to live in Brooklyn, Ny, and Il Forno’s food is as good as the best pizza place that we ever ate at in NY. Il Forno is the best pizza in town by far!“

“We moved into the area. I was looking for a great pizza place. We don't like too many chain pizza places. But I can tell you that we absolutely love this locations, pizzas and sandwiches. We got there close to closing. And treated us like we were their first customers“

“This is really a takeout or delivery business only in Pickerington Ohio. Everyone has their own favorite type of pizza taste. Strangely enough my favorite pizza is just to the east of the capital of Iceland. My destiny United States is MOD Pizza which is similar with a thinner crust and high quality fresh ingredients with a very friendly staff. But if I'm looking at what we consider we regularly find as pizza then Romeo's Pizza certainly is my favorite by far. The combination of crust taste and thickness as well as the overall flavor profile simply hits me as much more desirable than the other types I have tasted. Since this is decidedly a bit different the best thing to do is try it out and see what you think because you're still going to enjoy a meal and you might find something that you want to come back to often.“

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

“I had been looking for a great pizza place since moving back to Ohio 11 years ago. I had settled on Marcos because when they 1st opened, it was wonderful. I guess they’ve become complacent, or they have so much turnover, that they can’t provide good service anymore. I don’t know what has happened to this place. I have stopped patronizing the restaurant because of messed up orders, pizza boxes stuck to the toppings, and just a general lack of attention to detail. The app is way too unreliable, and you miss out on half of your rewards. When I did order, it was always for delivery. I’m my wife’s caregiver, and we don’t go out much anymore.“

“I have celiac disease and have hard a time finding food that isn’t contaminated, especially pizza. The staff reassured me that they checked with kitchen multiple times to make sure nothing was being contaminated. It was by far the most delicious gluten free pizza I’ve had so far !“

“I've been ordering online and I have to say that the service has been wonderful and the delivery time much better as well as the quality of food. ..“

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

“If you are looking for a fancy place with a big menu full or fine dining foods and pinkies-out cocktails, this is not it.If you are looking for a corner bar where everyone knows each other by name, plays pool and darts together, shares pizza, and does shots until closing time, Twins is definitely worth checking out.“

“Jet's pizza by far is my favorite pizza to eat. I'm staying in Pickerington and was excited there was one close. After a long day of work and driving from Lou,Ky. I aced an order for a salad and a pizza. There was no where to ask for extra ranch dressing so I called. The gentleman that answered the phone had great customer service. He made sure to add my ranch to my delivery and my coke zero. They arrived before the schedule delivery time. When I got back to my room I noticed my drink wasn't zero sugar. Normally something small wouldn't be any issue only problem is I'm a type 2 diabetic. I called the restaurant back in hopes to just get them to apply it to my account. Right away the gentleman that answered again asked for the address. Then immediately apologized and said they would get someone right over. You don't receive customer service like this everyday. This type of customer service has been lost and I'm glad I found it miles away from home! Thanks so much for going above and beyond you have a customer for life!!!!“