22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Prospect

“Great quality service every time.“

“I remember as a kid growing up in Prospect. We would ride our bicycles down to sportys to hang out with our brothers. Sometimes we would not make it because of the pouring down rain or whatever was going on. But I would drink rootbeer floats 2x a week at max. 3 scoops of ice cream.“

“We brought our entire 14U softball team and families and the pizza and atmosphere was absolutely amazing! We all tried so many different pizzas and they were ALL equally amazing! Such a hidden gem! Definitely a MUST try! Not to mention the top notch friendly service! #supportsmallbiz“

“i love the garbage subs and friendly service and that it supports our vets“

“I love hubby's, I live in Flordia and visit everytime I'm home.This was the only time my order was incorrect. I ask for 2 ham and cheese subs no sauce and both had sauce so my kids wouldn't eat them. Pizza was prefect as always.“

“had the eatery for the first time today. it was amazing! I will definitely be back in the very near future!!“

“Had date night here last night. The pizza and drinks were amazing, and the staff is super kind! The bartender was super busy but was very attentive to everyone. Prices are extremely affordable too! Highly recommend“

“Wonderful menu & service. Appreciate the great staff & family like atmosphere with my daughter working there.“

“Got my pizza served for carry out piping hot and ready to eat. Stuffed crust with the double pepperoni you know what’s up! There was one employee working the entire pizza shop and he was super nice when greeting me! Nice worker, can’t remember his name but he was working alone Monday night, June 8th. Will definitely need to come back.

Parking: Ton of parking“

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..“

“The menu here has an excellent variety, beautifully crafted cocktails, and a great selection of liquor brands to select from – as one of the brands on their shelf, Buckeye Vodka is proud to sit among this company of brands. This is the perfect spot to catch up with a group of friends but also appropriate ambiance for any occasion.“

“Update: I ordered a medium thin crust with pepperoni, onions, and green peppers. It was the best pizza I've had in this town. The traditional wings are amazing. They had lots of meat on them. They might not do good on stuff crust or subs....but the thin crust is my favorite so far. I will try all the crusts eventually. And the wings..yummmmmmmm! Had to give 5 stars for this order. Didn't get pictures food was to good to stop eating.

I didn't even know we had an East of Chicago in Marion. I found out by receiving coupons in the mail. One of the coupons was a a 3 topping pizza with pepperoni and cheese stuffed crust. Sounded great. So I ordered my pizza and decided to try a ham and cheese sub. The pizza looked great, until you get toward the stuffed crust part...where the dough all connects it was still very raw. Not very pleasing. The sub was also a disappointment. The bread wasn't very toasted, the cheese wasn't even melted...almost seemed like it was microwaved or something. Not what I like my subs to look like. I know every place does something different..but I was not a fan. When I picked up my order the lady was very kind, I think she was the only one working from what I could tell. The guy in front of me must really like the subs because he ordered 6 or 8. Which might be why my order was under cooked due to one person doing all the work. I will probably try this place one more time...but that's all you get is one more chance...I'm in search of the best pizza in Marion. So far It ain't here.“

“Good food , decent prices and has rewards club“

“Ordered pizza and subs for our dinner today. Food was great, and our delivery driver was awesome. Thank you Donatos, keep up the great work!!!“

“Best pizza in Marion as far as I'm concerned. Get a BLT foldover and tell me it isn't delicious. I don't even particularly like bacon but the BLT foldover is amazing. Gyro is too, actually. Greasy as hell, but that comes with eating lamb, so it's sort of complaining about a pool being too wet.“

“My husband loves their Italian sub, and I love the fisherman's platter. Who'd think the best fish dinner I've ever had would come from a pizza drive-through? For carb conscious folks, the flounder in the Fisherman's Platter is thick and tasty and you can easily get the breading off all the different items. No need to season the bare fish -- they do something to give it flavor. Unfortunately, their walleye is too thin to peel the breading off. Salads are also generous and yummy.“

“Ordered a veggie pizza for delivery on a Saturday after 5pm. The pizza showed up in about 30-40 minutes and was loaded with toppings(picture included). It tasted great and the crust was perfect. I ordered a four cheese pizza last week( just as good), meatball sub( decent but on the small side) and 2 cookies(okay). Delivery is just $4.00(plus your tip), they do not do online ordering or use Doordash( I do not use this service either). Overall, I am impressed with Delco pizza and this is my new go to pizza in Delaware, OH.“

“We have been ordering out a lot because of home improvement. Payne’s has been the best place to order from. Great food and awesome customer service.“

“Love LOVE love the Rueben and Nashville Hot Steak specialty pizza!!!! AND the crust is delicious! Great staff!“

“where do I begin? we ordered two pizzas, only to show up after the app said they were ready. then to be told, "they're being cut". 30 minutes later we had to leave to be at an event (this is what the pizzas were for) I'm guessing they gave our pizzas to someone else and were attempting to quickly make more. so we demand a refund and leave empty handed with mo pizzas. Then we ordered 6 pizzas for my kids birthday online the night before selecting the following day. Their site made them defaulted for 12 midnight the night of the request instead of 12 noon the following day as we wanted. this was our fault. but they never called us to tell us our pizzas we were charged for were there, they didn't offer free replacements or a refund the following day either when we stopped in before the kids birthday party. I'm guessing they took them home and ate them at our expense...... avoid this poor excuse of a pizza establishment at all costs.“

“Great food, great vibes. Definitely a family favorite of ours!“

“Needed a place to watch the game with my son....this place was great....a bar but still a restaurant feel where I definitely felt comfortable taking my son. The food was great, we got a pizza and a burger. The service was amazing. The place was packed and service was still amazing. I will definitely be coming back regularly....keep up the amazing work scoreboard“