46 Best Italian Restaurants near Sagamore Hills

“The Tuscan Vine is a restaurant that offers a variety of Italian dishes, including fresh pasta, homemade focaccia bread, and Tiramisu. The pasta Carbonara and bolognese are particularly popular choices. The restaurant has been praised for its attentive and helpful service, with servers like Jamie going the extra mile to make customers feel welcome. However, there have been some inconsistencies in food quality and service. Some customers have reported issues with burnt chicken and small portion sizes, while others have praised the generous portions and excellent quality of the pizzas and salads. The restaurant is generally considered to be kid-friendly, with kids enjoying the buttered noodles and Alfredo sauce in particular. The Tuscan Vine is a great option for those looking for a taste of Italy, but the experience may vary depending on the day and time of visit.“

“Lockkeepers is a welcoming restaurant with excellent service. The chef is accommodating, preparing special meals for guests with food allergies. The food is delicious, with standouts like the Halibut (Dinner Catch) special and Heritage Pork entrees. The patio is beautiful, and custom drinks and homemade desserts add to the experience.“

“Jim Alesci's Place is a large Italian restaurant and bakery that offers a wide range of homemade Italian specialties, including bread, bakery items, to-go meals, gelato, and even ingredients for DIY homemade pizza. The bakery items and catering options, such as their renowned cannolis, are known for their exceptional quality, although some regular grocery items may be priced higher. Overall, the restaurant is considered a great destination for authentic Italian cuisine and baked goods.“

“Geraci's Restaurant in Pepper Pike offers a delightful dining experience with mouthwatering dishes and fabulous service. The restaurant is perfect for special events, offering a party room where they take care of everything, even ordering the cake. Customers praise the friendly and efficient servers like Ashley and Lesley B, who ensure a terrific experience. Don't miss out on their excellent pepperoni pizza, a crowd favorite.“

“D'Agnese's is a restaurant that consistently delivers outstanding food and service. The menu offers a variety of options, including gluten-free dishes, which are expertly prepared and presented. The lamb appetizer is a popular choice, and the pasta dishes are a highlight, with gluten-free options that are surprisingly good. With knowledgeable servers and impeccable timing, every meal is a pleasant experience.“

“Valenti’s Ristorante offers a surprising and fantastic dining experience with a variety of delicious dishes like grilled salmon salad, spaghetti with meatballs, and fettuccine alfredo. The attentive staff, including server Curtis, adds to the warm and hospitable ambiance that makes diners feel like family. The innovative pop-up experiences at the bar enhance the dining adventure, creating a memorable and enriching experience. Whether enjoying a meal or listening to live music like the Traveling Johnson's, Valenti’s is a place to return to for a great night out.“

“Casa D'Angelo Italian is a popular restaurant serving delicious Italian food. The menu offers a variety of options, including pick three, fettuccine, and veal dishes, as well as vegetarian and gluten-free choices. Diners can expect huge portions and reasonable prices, making it a great value compared to other restaurants. The service is excellent, with friendly and attentive staff. The restaurant also offers a full bar with a selection of wine and cocktails. Vegetarians and those with dietary restrictions will find many options to accommodate their needs, including fresh salads and gluten-free breaded chicken and pasta. With its convenient parking and welcoming atmosphere, Casa D'Angelo Italian is a great choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Giovanni's is an exceptional dining experience with fabulous food, elegant atmosphere, and superb service. The restaurant's intimate setting is enhanced by perfect music volume, making it a wonderful spot for a special evening. The menu features dishes such as lobster bisque, Veal Scallopini, halibut, and lamb soup, all of which are expertly prepared and presented. While serving sizes may be larger than needed, the quality of the food and service makes it well worth the price. With its consistent excellence, Giovanni's stands out as a top choice in the Cleveland area, thanks to the leadership of its management team.“

“Ciao Pizzeria Cerino is a restaurant located in Southern Cuyahoga County, known for its excellent pizza and free delivery. The staff is friendly and runs the place efficiently, creating a smooth operation. The family meal option includes meatballs, Italian sausage, rigatoni, salad, and bread, with particularly excellent meatballs and a delicious Pizzeria salad. The bread is also highly praised, as are the assortment of cookies for dessert. Ciao's pastas and entrees are highly rated, with their meatballs being a standout. While not inexpensive, the portions are generous, making it a solid value. The tiramisu is particularly notable, being the best some have had anywhere in the country. The employees, including the delivery drivers, are polite and professional. Overall, Ciao Pizzeria Cerino is a great choice for high-quality food and easy takeout.“

“Northfield Inn Restaurant & Lounge offers a friendly and relaxed atmosphere with excellent home-cooked meals. Customers praise the chicken Alfredo for its perfect texture and delicious sauce, made from scratch. Known for consistent quality for over 50 years, their chicken or veal parm dishes are always a hit. The chicken piccatta is delicate and delicious, making it a top choice for Italian cuisine at a reasonable price.“

“Russo's offers fantastic food, drinks, and service with a great variety on their menus. The atmosphere is great, and the fried chicken is a must-try, considered the best. The calamari and cocktails are recommended, and the steak, smoked Mac, and Navajo Tacos were all amazing. Even with a slight confusion in finding the host stand, the experience was enjoyable, especially with the lovely oysters and tasty chicken salad. The cranberry aperol spritz was a delightful cocktail choice. A highly recommended restaurant for a great dining experience.“

“Corleone's Ristorante & Bar is a hidden gem that belies its unassuming strip mall location. Upon entering, guests are transported to a cozy, low-key atmosphere that invites dressing up or down. The patio, secluded behind high shrubbery, offers a private retreat. The restaurant serves great food, with highlights including bruschetta, chicken carbonara, and grouper. Portion sizes are generous, and service is attentive. Desserts, such as Oreo cake with chocolate mousse, are also a treat. Overall, Corleone's is a must-visit for its welcoming ambiance, delicious cuisine, and excellent service.“

“Ken Stewart's Tre Belle is a great choice for any special event, with excellent service and management always ensuring your satisfaction. The food is outstanding, with adjustments made to meals when requested. While the bar area can be a bit noisy and the AC strong, the staff is accommodating. Dining on the patio is usually enjoyable, although the proximity to the smoking area can sometimes impact the atmosphere. Overall, a nice dining experience that won't break the bank.“

“Au Jus is a restaurant that offers delicious and high-quality food, with friendly staff and a clean environment. The portions are generous and the fried pickles, Italian beef sandwich, and Italian beef eggrolls are highly recommended. The kitchen is sparkling clean and the au jus is exceptional. The owners are dedicated to providing a great dining experience.“

“CocoBella's Italian Grille offers an intimate, romantic atmosphere. Customers have enjoyed a variety of dishes, including mussels, ancini, chicken marsala, chicken piccatta, salmon, and Parmesan. The service is described as excellent, with attentive and helpful waitstaff providing great recommendations and accommodations. The food is consistently delicious, with highlights such as the garlic rolls and salad. Overall, CocoBella's provides a great dining experience that customers highly recommend.“

“Flour - Italian Kitchen offers a delightful dining experience with its excellent food and attentive service. The restaurant's menu showcases a range of Italian specialties, from the flavorful lamb ragu to the delectable funghi pizza, which customers have praised as fresh and piping hot. The staff is noted for their kindness and professionalism, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable atmosphere. While the atmosphere may not be as refined as the menu suggests, the restaurant's commitment to quality ingredients and creative presentation shines through. Diners have particularly enjoyed the unique sensory experience of the blindfolded dinner service, where the team at Flour expertly guided them through a series of surprising and delightful courses. Despite a few minor hiccups, such as a slightly overpriced drink menu and some cold appetizers, the overall consensus is that Flour - Italian Kitchen is a must-visit destination for those seeking a memorable Italian dining experience. The restaurant's dedication to exceptional food and service makes it a reliable choice for both casual gatherings and special occasions.“

“Danspot, tucked away near a convenience store, is a hidden gem offering a delightful dining experience. Known for its top-notch pasta, the vodka sauce dish is described as out of this world. The menu has something for everyone, and the shrimp with lemon sauce and Mac cheese Alfredo with chicken are must-tries. The service is commendable, the atmosphere is inviting, and the prices are reasonable for the five-star quality food. Portions are generously large, making it an excellent value.“

“Carpe Raci Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar is an outstanding new Italian destination. The bar service is excellent, with friendly and knowledgeable staff. The restaurant service is also excellent. The food is exceptional, with delicious and creative dishes like spaghettini puttanesca, gnocchi, spaghetti with mascarpone meatballs, and branzino (sea bass). The restaurant offers generous servings and an extensive wine list, making for a thoroughly enjoyable dining experience.“

“Elle Restaurant & Lounge offers a delightful dining experience with a variety of tasty dishes. The Eggplant fritters and calamari appetizers were quick to arrive and highly recommended. The Salmon dish was described as delicious and refreshing. The restaurant is also praised for its amazing calamari and mussels, with a perfectly made old fashioned cocktail. The chicken dish with delicious potatoes was enjoyed, although the swordfish was noted to be overly salty. Despite this, the attentive service from the staff was appreciated. Overall, Elle Restaurant & Lounge provides a memorable and special dining experience in Solon, OH.“

“Village Square Pizzeria is a cozy spot with a relaxed atmosphere, reminiscent of old-school pizza joints. While they're still working out some kinks, their pizzas are made with artisan dough and are very good. The portions are large, and the Everything Garlic Knots are a must-try. Service is attentive, and the ambiance is perfect for a night out with friends. The menu offers a variety of options, including pizzas, meatballs, and subs. While some dishes may be hit or miss, the overall experience is pleasant and convenient.“

“Concerto Italian Kitchen offers a varied menu, including a delicious chicken parmesan sandwich, decent pizza, and a salad. The gaming experience is fun, but the bartenders can be rude. Parking is plentiful, and the restaurant is wheelchair accessible. The staff is generally helpful, and the food, especially the pizza, is well-received.“

“Russo's Pizza offers some of the best pizza around with great service and a nostalgic atmosphere. Regulars appreciate the fresh and delicious crust, with memories that bring them back time and time again. Families have enjoyed the spot for years, with even young kids declaring it the best pizza place ever. First-timers are warmly welcomed and treated to customized orders, making it a worthwhile drive that guarantees a return visit.“

“Delmonico's Steakhouse offers a great vibe and good food, with options for both meat lovers and vegetarians. The restaurant is clean and fancy, perfect for any occasion. With friendly staff and wheelchair accessibility, it's a great spot for intimate dates, family gatherings, or celebrations. Plenty of parking available, just be aware it can get busy around the bar area.“

“Tomato Grill in Hudson is a charming downtown restaurant with a varied menu. Some dishes like the chicken penne and chicken piccata were a bit tough and lacked flavor, but overall, the meals were delicious and served hot. The attentive and helpful servers made the dining experience enjoyable. The portions were surprisingly large, and the dessert options were fantastic. Despite some minor hiccups, the overall experience was wonderful, and the reviewers are looking forward to returning.“

“Deanatella's is a hidden gem serving exceptional Italian-American cuisine. The hot stuffed banana pepper sub, chicken parmesan on a fresh hoagie style bun, and sausage and peppers with mozzarella on hoagie bun are standout dishes. Freshly baked bread, homemade sausage, and sauce with melted cheese are just a few highlights. The pizzas, including the fresh made white pizza, and the antipasto salad are also highly praised. With plentiful servings and a friendly staff, Deanatella's is well worth the drive, no matter the distance.“

“Molisana Italian Imported Foods is a restaurant that offers unique and niche Italian items, providing a dining experience that makes you feel like you're in a small Italian village bakery/market. The staff are friendly and happy to share their knowledge about the menu. Customers have praised the delicious pizza and sausage, with some comparing it to a cherished family recipe from Mazzones. The pizza panino is also a popular choice. Molisana is a must-visit restaurant for anyone looking for a special and memorable Italian dining experience.“

“Farinacci Pizza serves excellent pizza and salads, with a focus on fresh and flavorful ingredients. This carry-out only spot offers fast and friendly service, with great prices to match. Expect generous toppings on a thin crust, and a warm welcome from the staff. While there's no dine-in atmosphere, the homemade sauce and crust make it a must-try for pizza lovers.“

“Romito's Pizza West in Independence serves amazing food, including family ribs, salads, mushrooms, and chicken strips, all of which are delicious. Their pizza is exceptional, with a fantastic crust, and their cheese sticks are a hit. The restaurant provides great courtesy and exceptional service, making it stand out from other locations with the same name. With a hometown atmosphere, Romito's Pizza West is a must-try for pizza lovers, offering leftovers that are just as tasty as the initial meal.“

“Eddie's Pizzeria Cerino offers an exceptional dining experience. The modern and inviting decor, along with its spotless cleanliness, create a welcoming atmosphere. The menu boasts outstanding Italian fare, including delectable bread and olive oil, a hearty bowl of soup, fantastic pizza, and the popular Rigatoni D. Customers praise the exceptional quality and generous portions, making it a breath of fresh air in an era of rising prices and shrinking servings. With a friendly staff and a nice ambiance, this restaurant is a hidden gem that delivers excellent Italian cuisine at a reasonable price.“

“Olive Garden Italian Restaurant is a great place for a date night or a family dinner. The waitstaff, including Dee and Maurice, are known for their attentive and pleasant service. The food is delicious, particularly the chicken and gnocchi, which comes with a variety of lettuce, olives, and tomatoes in a tasty dressing. The breadsticks, while lacking in garlic butter on some occasions, are still a popular item. Prices for entrees with proteins can be high, but the soup and salad option, which includes plenty of olives, tomatoes, and different kinds of lettuce, can be a good value, especially before 3 pm. Overall, Olive Garden Italian Restaurant offers a satisfying dining experience with tasty food and good service.“

“Danny Boys Italian Eatery offers a delightful dining experience with its reasonably priced, high-quality food and pleasant service. The menu features a wide variety of options, including salads, pizza, subs, and calzones. Customers have praised the Backstage Classic Woogie, a rolled calzone with pepperoni, sausage, yellow peppers, and a blend of five cheeses, as well as the tasty pepperoni pizza and the Italian Cobb salad. The restaurant's welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff have also been noted, making it a popular lunchtime destination for those in the area.“

“Rosa's Pizza is a satisfying spot for a delicious meal. Their pepperoni pizza and buffalo ranch wings are fan favorites, and their salads feature fresh vegetables. The thin crust pizzas are made with homemade dough and offer great value. The staff is very nice, and the restaurant has a wonderful atmosphere. Vegetarian options abound, including fabulous eggplant and artichokes.“

“Gionino's Pizzeria serves exceptional pizza, with some considering it among the best they've ever had. The menu offers a range of options, including large pepperoni extra cheese and medium pepperoni and extra cheese. While some find the sauce a bit sweet, others enjoy it. The restaurant is a great spot for pizza, fried chicken, and jojo's, with many customers highly recommending it.“

“Zeppe's Bistro & Pizzeria consistently provides good food and service. They go above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, even resolving issues not their own. This welcoming restaurant accommodates large groups and offers a great atmosphere. Their 6-cut deluxe pizza with traditional crust is a popular choice, and they cater well to customers with disabilities.“

“A Touch of Italy offers tasty hot wings and cheese fries, but there have been issues with order accuracy. One customer received the wrong noodles with their spaghetti and meat sauce, while another experienced a delayed and poorly prepared lunch. The service and food quality are inconsistent, which may lead some customers to seek out other Italian restaurants. It is unclear if the dinner menu provides a better experience.“

“Master Pizza is a well-liked establishment, offering a variety of pizza options such as deep dish, gluten-free Sicilian Detroit Style, and old school pizzas. Customers appreciate the fresh toppings, friendly service, and easy online ordering. The restaurant is clean and the prices are reasonable. It is a great alternative to chain pizza places, reminiscent of the classic pizza experience.“

“Zeppe's Tavern & Pizzeria serves great pizza, including the popular Double Down with added sausage, which is likely to be the best sausage on a pizza. The restaurant has shown an improvement in quality, offering a variety of dishes such as the Italian salad, which is bursting with fresh ingredients. The service is prompt and friendly, with courteous servers and competitive pricing. The location also offers ample parking and is wheelchair accessible, making it a great option for a night out or pickup order.“

“Teresa's Pizza is a restaurant with a mixed reputation. Some customers have been disappointed by their mozzarella sticks, which have a unique taste that may not be to everyone's liking, and their pizzas, which are likened to gas station fare. However, others have had a more positive experience, praising the friendly and helpful staff, excellent sandwiches, and aromatic pizzas. The restaurant is willing to accommodate customers with special needs, such as delivering pizzas to vehicles. Overall, Teresa's Pizza seems to be a decent option for a quick bite, but may not impress everyone.“

“Gionino's Pizzeria offers a delightful dining experience with its tasty pizza and friendly staff. Customers praise the great customer service, delicious meat pizza, and overall fantastic pizza. The restaurant is a popular choice for both regular visits and special occasions, such as a birthday party.“

“Piada Italian Street Food offers delicious food in a clean environment. While the staff may not be overly friendly or helpful, the food is very good. The restaurant's online ordering system has some issues, as pickup orders may be delayed by 30+ minutes. The menu allows for customization, making the price more worth it. The mini steak salad is a popular choice, and the sandwich is also a good option.“

“3 Palms Pizzeria offers a fantastic dining experience, with a variety of vegetarian options and a great ambiance. The pizza is reportedly delicious, though the interior can be quite loud. While the indoor dining area is beautiful, comfortable, and inviting, the outdoor patio area appears to be in need of some maintenance, with an unkempt and worn-out appearance. Overall, the food and staff are excellent, making this a top-notch Italian restaurant, especially for vegetarian fans of Italian cuisine.“

“Zeppe's Pizzeria offers tasty and reasonably priced pizza. Online ordering and pickup are convenient and hassle-free. While the atmosphere is not meant for dining in, the service is friendly, polite, and helpful. Vegetarian options are plentiful, and the pizza is a great value for the price. Note that food quality can vary, with some dishes, like wings, falling short of expectations.“

“Jet's Pizza offers a delightful dining experience with its wide range of pizza varieties, including the popular Detroit-style deep dish meat lovers pizza, as well as vegetarian options like the veggie pizza and Greek salad. The pizzas are consistently well-made, and the staff is friendly and professional, ensuring orders are accurate and ready on time. The restaurant's convenient location in a shopping mall with ample parking makes it an appealing choice for both dine-in and takeout customers.“

“Augie's Pizza is a popular spot for delicious pizza and exceptional customer service. Visitors from out of town were thrilled to discover this gem near the Cleveland Clinic, and locals make it a regular stop for lunch. The restaurant offers pizza by the slice, and the friendly staff go above and beyond to ensure a great experience. They even remember customers' preferences and accommodate their requests, making it a standout among other eateries. With its tasty pizzas and top-notch service, Augie's Pizza is a must-visit for anyone seeking a satisfying meal.“

“Salted Dough is a welcoming restaurant that serves delicious food made from scratch. The chef/owner is extremely friendly and provides exceptional service. The restaurant has a quaint atmosphere with a reasonable price menu and ample seating at the bar. The menu offers a variety of options, and the chef is passionate about ensuring that every dish is perfect. Even in the face of a minor mix-up, the chef personally corrected the issue, demonstrating professionalism and class. Overall, Salted Dough is a great spot for breakfast, lunch, dinner, or dessert, and is highly recommended.“

“Pizza Hut offers a satisfying dining experience with hot, delicious food and great service. The restaurant provides a variety of options, including vegetarian-friendly stuffed crust pizza. Customers appreciate the staff's attentiveness, particularly during busy holidays. While the service can be hit or miss, the quality of the food remains consistent.“