50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sheffield Lake

“I just want to shout out Doughboy's Pizza & Wings for the catering for my daughter’s party. If you’re looking to have a really good pizza party & then some, go there. I got 3 whole sheet pizzas, 100 wings, a party pan of salad & rigatoni/meatballs with silverware & plates for $286 plus tip. It was ready on time & fresh. They have such a great menu to choose from. 🩷Everyone loved the food 🍕🍗🥗🍝 There was about 30 kids & 15-20 adults & I still had food leftover.“

“Ordered 3 pizzas today; they were scrumptiously delicious. Thank you for the gr8 employees and being so convenient and very reasonable prices.“

“Dirte Pi never disappoints. Everything from their pizzas to their Korean fried chicken is always fresh and full of flavor. I highly recommend!“

“Delicious pizza & friendly people!“

“Delicious and authentic Neapolitan pizza! Yummy!“

“I suggest the peanut butter and jelly burger. 10/10. Great atmospheres great people. Coming back soon“

“Love this place. Has been a regular weekly staple for my family since we moved. First pizza we tried in the area, which we discovered nothing really compares. Any issues were promptly handled by Danielle the manager who recently took over. 10/10“

“We had a party of 17 for lunch. Everyone loved it!! The food was delicious, it was very clean and comfortable, and the service was excellent! Highly recommend! Everyone in our group wants to come back. Thank you for the great meal and making our family get together a great one!!“

“Excellent small pepperoni pizza“

“good food awesome employees“

“I heard yesterday that Uncle Al’s was under new management, so I decided I would try it again to see if it was different. One good thing I should note is that this Uncle Al’s offers it’s own delivery service, along with door dash, where as the old Uncle Al’s forced customers to use door dash ONLY if they desired delivery. I got a family sized pizza with banana peppers and pepperoni, a large cheesy bread, and an order of boneless buffalo wings. Everything was good with no complaints. The price was reasonable and the size of the pizzas was quite large. If you like your pizza to be cheesy, you will certainly not be disappointed. The default amount of cheese here is equal to what you might get if you ordered extra cheese at some other pizza parlors. Lastly, they seemed to be a little busy when I picked my order up, but the order was ready in about 20 minutes from when I called. It was nice that I didn’t have to wait very long.“

“First of all you guys have amazing pizza! You are also great people! Thank you so much for providing the Westlake library with sandwiches and pretzels! It is much appreciated! Whatever seasoning you put on pretzels is so tasty!“

“Waitress was super sweet:)“

“Our go to when ordering pizza! Their pizza has the perfect flavor and amount of toppings! My family raves for it every Friday!“

“We ordered the Tropical BBQ Chicken pizza from Jilliano’s for lunch today, and I can say, the flavor blew us away! It was a new taste experience with plenty of toppings including the grilled chicken breast & crumbled bacon, a tasty BBQ sauce, and a hint of cinnamon that made it a brand new experience. I would highly recommend you give it a try!“

“I stopped by WB Pizza yesterday during lunch I ordered a large meat lovers pizza, pan crust, which is their thick crust. I had a few questions. The manager answered them, she was very polite and took time to take care of me. I was very pleased with my choice. The food was amazing. I will be returning.“

“Food was wonderful and portions are huge! Great desserts and salads are amazing. Excellent service! Will be back.“

“A friend of mine suggested this place, and it was worth the trip. There is no dine in. Pick up, I'm not sure about the delivery. The pricing is odd. A medium pizza was approximately twenty-five dollars? It would be hard to put a price for individuals. The pizza was excellent. The sandwiches were excellent, The food over all I will give a ten.“

“I just love their pizzas“

“We get dominos frequently as my husband lives on cheesy bread and we just had a baby- takeout is nice so I don't have to cook. It's usually very good, sometimes it's sup-par, but never awful! Wish it was more consistently good, however we will continue to be faithful customers!“

“Great food and great service“

“We ordered a large Extreme Supreme. The toppings were fresh, the crust was melt in your mouth cooked to perfection, and the extra cheese was just right. We usually order extra sauce at other places but decided not to at Master P and glad we didn’t. The amount of ingredients to crust ratio was on point. We took our leftovers home and ate them cold and the pizza was still bangin’ 😎. It was my first time enjoying a Master P pizza and I will most definitely be back.“

“We had Marco's pizza for the first time in a while on Tuesday this week and it was Very good!!! It outshone the last Marco's pizza we had and really impressed my husband, who is a pizza snob. Good Job this week Marcos!!! And Thank you also for supporting your community as well as Camp Imagine!!! ❣“

“Rude customer service from the guy with the ponytail. He needs an attitude adjustment.“

“An absolute HUGE shout-out to Marcos Pizza in Amherst for donating a pizza to us and delivering it to us Amherst Firefighters while we were on a car fire this afternoon! We seriously can't thank us enough for doing that when i was ready to pay for it. Thank you for being a huge supporter! 🇺🇲🚒🚒“

“Great food nice list of beers and the bartenders always are friendly and very helpful with drink ideas“

“Definitely a Lorain classic here. Service was phenomenal the two girls working the phones ringing off the hook while taking care of the customers delivered great satisfaction on their service. Parking is a little on the rougher side but it is what it is. The pizza gets a solid 8/10 not the best around but not the worst for some reason my pie came out a little burnt on the crust but nothing to cry over. Overall, great pizza with great service for the price you can’t beat it!“

“Disappointed in meatballs. Recipe not same as before. Too much filler maybe breadcrumbs and lesss meat!!! Go back to original recipe. Miss Miller Lite also!“

“Pizza Cutter is the best pizza place in the area! The food is great and the staff is very friendly and helpful.“

“We were in from out of town and tried a local restaurant. I ordered the reuben gyro and it was amazing! Some of the best corned beef I've ever had. The coleslaw was also yummy! The staff was so friendly and we would definitely return!“

“Great Food and Great Service“

“My family and I were there for the soler eclipse, weekend. We walked in sat down at the bar, everyone was extremely friendly, kind, nice, polite, warm and welcoming. We had just come from another bar around the corner called SPEAK OF THE DEVIL they were rude unwelcoming talked about us eclipse people like really what are they doing here. Never went back there again. Back to Brass & Bronze we had the tacos the 1st night amazing. We went back the second night the kitchen had just closed so we had a drink then one of the owners came over and said I know how to make pizza I can make you pizza. So that is what we had for our 2nd night s dinner. We went back the next day for the eclipse for lunch about 1 again amazing. We meet the President of the city Council Joel Arredondo and his wife they sat outside with us and watched the eclipse. Again very welcoming, they had their daughter’s wedding at this restaurant. I recommend this place extremely high. We had the best weekend in a long time“

“This location for Marcos pizza is on of the better ones that I’ve had. My ONLY complaint is that the toppings could have been spread out more even instead of center of pizza only or else I would have given 5 stars. I usually go to the Sheffield village location but on accident, ordered the wrong Marcos in Elyria. Overall perfect amount of cheese and sauce. :)“

“Lawrence and Peter were just so kind and nice. I was gonna give a lower score based upon the computer Messing up my order. But they were super nice with smiles and asked me how my day was and said to have a good evening. The customer service was worth it. That’s the stuffed crust pizza and the little bites are delicious.“

“ordered our first pizza. got wings and 2 pizzas, $32. felt the wings were small and didn't get many. flavor was good for spicy one. pizza was more like a medium sized but tasted good not greasy. ingredient amount was awesome. Will get again. loved how you express your love for God on box.“

“I wish I could figure out how to get my loyalty rewards. I don't know why they changed it. We order a lot from west ridge Marcos , maybe I will go where the help can actually help me“

“Wow. Total nostalgia when I found out yall were still in existence.

The pizza? Deliciouso ??
Service? Professional and the shorter fella who helped me when I picked up 9/12/24 was very frickin cute lol and very frickin nice.
Atmosphere? The place smelled like heaven in a shop. And very clean too.

Will be back very soon.“

“Great food and awsome service friendly staff that go the extra mile everytime i go im always laughing out the door. Janelle is awsome she know my order and has ready to go for me when i arrive. Thank u guys for the awsome service and food keep up the good work“

“My friend and I were recommended this place by a local thrift shop. I ordered the meatball Woogie bear to eat there and their beef and mushroom soup to go with two breadsticks. Their food is AMAZING!!! Highly recommend and I will be going back again.“

“ordered our first pizza. got wings and 2 pizzas, $32. felt the wings were small and didn't get many. flavor was good for spicy one. pizza was more like a medium sized but tasted good not greasy. ingredient amount was awesome. Will get again. loved how you express your love for God on box.“

“Buckeye Community Bank loved this pizza!!!“

“Great pizza and dessert. We ordered a BYO large pepperoni and mushroom with the three cheese blend along with a slice of NY cheesecake and piece of cookie crumble cake. The pizza was delivered and held up during delivery and was made perfectly. Cheesy and delicious. The crust was nice and crunchy and chewy which is how I like it. The flavors are good and I appreciate the nicely made pie. The NY cheesecake was light and fluffy and tasted perfectly sweet and fresh. The cookie crumble cake was not for me but my daughter said it was good warmed up with a scoop of vanilla ice cream added to it. The delivery was made from the store and was estimated to take 45 minutes but arrived in around 30ish minutes and we appreciated that. Definitely a nice first time experience here with Angelina’s Pizza and we will definitely order from this establishment again.“

“It’s great pizza & the people on the Reviews who Complain About Customer Service & how they feel like they are not treated kindly or get What they want , like refund etc….or how the phone is answered
Cut it out good God your ordering a Pizza , get over yourselves!!!!!!“

“Late night stop-food was fresh service was great. Will definitely come back. Support Lorain business!“

“Staff was very friendly,courteous
and patient with my 5 million questions while ordering. Got home ,our 1 pizza wasn't right.
I called them,explained it wasn't what I ordered, they remade it, no problem,and again very pleasant and helpful.“

“best sauce around!! always a great deal on Tuesdays. buy one get one 50 percent off.“

“Ordered a pizza from Lear Rd Pizza Hut and apparently they’re using DoorDash to deliver. All I had was a $50 bill on me and they had no change so I called up the Pizza Hut to pay by credit card but they were nasty and hung up on me. I felt bad for the people delivering to me and gave them the money and told them to take the pizza and shove it! I would never order from them again, ever!“

“Ordered a large pepperoni and sausage. I thought that the pepperoni was supposed to be edge to edge, but it was only half covered. Really disappointed. I lived in Columbus for 33 years and was always satisfied with their pizza. I guess Avon doesn't care.“