50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sheffield Lake

“Ordered the popper pizza and wings for my employees and everyone loved it!“

“Ordered 3 pizzas today; they were scrumptiously delicious. Thank you for the gr8 employees and being so convenient and very reasonable prices.“

“Delicious pizza & friendly people!“

“Delicious! Definitely will be back!“

“Delicious and authentic Neapolitan pizza! Yummy!“

“Great food. Great atmosphere. Great service. This place is hard to beat. Family dining atmosphere but the food is really great! Awesome menu with things you won't find anywhere else. Attached ice cream parlor is also a big hit with the kids!“

“We stayed in Elyria 4 The night & The motel worker recommended this pizza place 2 us. I am so glad she did , cuz The pizza was amazing. Very delicious. & Very friendly delivery, right 2 e room . If ur In the area & Looking 4 a good pizza , I would highly recommend u Ordering from here . When we’re in the area again, we will definitely get another pizza . Delicious“

“We had a party of 17 for lunch. Everyone loved it!! The food was delicious, it was very clean and comfortable, and the service was excellent! Highly recommend! Everyone in our group wants to come back. Thank you for the great meal and making our family get together a great one!!“

“Fantastic pizza! Both the white and red sauce are great, the crust is a hearty style with a little chew to it and has never come out undercooked (as opposed to several chains that run in Elyria.) Good amount of evenly distributed toppings. Locally owned and run, the owner has been working there each time we've ordered. Support good local food!“

“Excellent small pepperoni pizza“

“We ordered the Tropical BBQ Chicken pizza from Jilliano’s for lunch today, and I can say, the flavor blew us away! It was a new taste experience with plenty of toppings including the grilled chicken breast & crumbled bacon, a tasty BBQ sauce, and a hint of cinnamon that made it a brand new experience. I would highly recommend you give it a try!“

“First of all you guys have amazing pizza! You are also great people! Thank you so much for providing the Westlake library with sandwiches and pretzels! It is much appreciated! Whatever seasoning you put on pretzels is so tasty!“

“I stopped by WB Pizza yesterday during lunch I ordered a large meat lovers pizza, pan crust, which is their thick crust. I had a few questions. The manager answered them, she was very polite and took time to take care of me. I was very pleased with my choice. The food was amazing. I will be returning.“

“I just love their pizzas“

“We came upon this place traveling through town. We always like to stop at the small family owed business to eat. Pizza was really good! And the mozzarella was also good huge triangles of she's in house battered.
Definately will stop again the next time we go through town.“

“good food awesome employees“

“8/2/24 - Had to come back and update my review from 8 years ago. Still enjoy their food! Today, however, they went above and beyond by donating 12 half sheet pizzas to a worthy cause. Thank you for being an important member of the community!

5/31/16 - First time eating here. I ordered a personal pizza with pepperoni and sausage as well as some Sriracha wings and garlic parm wings. Took it to go, but ordered at the counter so had time to chat with the employees. Very friendly people and professional.

The food was great! The wings were fall-off-the-bone tender and had good flavor. Love that they are baked and not deep fried! The pizza was good, too. It reminded me of Angelo's in Lakewood a bit.

Their menu has appetizers, salads, about 20 specialty pizzas, pastas and subs. They do pizza "by the slice" from 11 AM - 3 PM weekdays, I believe.

It's a new business in Avon, but they've been around since 1955, starting on Mayfield Road in Cleveland.“

“Food was wonderful and portions are huge! Great desserts and salads are amazing. Excellent service! Will be back.“

“Rude customer service from the guy with the ponytail. He needs an attitude adjustment.“

“great food and craft beers.“

“We get dominos frequently as my husband lives on cheesy bread and we just had a baby- takeout is nice so I don't have to cook. It's usually very good, sometimes it's sup-par, but never awful! Wish it was more consistently good, however we will continue to be faithful customers!“

“A friend of mine suggested this place, and it was worth the trip. There is no dine in. Pick up, I'm not sure about the delivery. The pricing is odd. A medium pizza was approximately twenty-five dollars? It would be hard to put a price for individuals. The pizza was excellent. The sandwiches were excellent, The food over all I will give a ten.“

“We had Marco's pizza for the first time in a while on Tuesday this week and it was Very good!!! It outshone the last Marco's pizza we had and really impressed my husband, who is a pizza snob. Good Job this week Marcos!!! And Thank you also for supporting your community as well as Camp Imagine!!! ❣“

“Used to order Pizza Cutter years ago and it was always amazing. Just ordered this evening and it is even better than I remember. Plenty of toppings and o so good!!!“

“I really don’t write a view but I had to usually don’t eat Little Caesar pizza that much. Because of their dough too hard and never seem to be fresh like cardboard but this first order I got from Little Caesars in North Ridgeville hits different The Dough was so fresh and fluffy tasty I will definitely be ordering from now on my kids loved it so much and said first time ordering pizza this good

Kid-friendliness: The lady was so sweet and had manners“

“Very accessible. The food was hot and fresh. Even the pizza ? sauce had spices. Really impressive! I asked for my pie to have cheese to the edge - done. Let's top it off that your pie is sitting on parchment paper!!! Not cardboard. I'll gladly return and pay for these extras.“

“Romeos has the best pizza! I really need to meet the person who decided to put potatoes and seasoned almonds on pizza - absolutely delicious! This is our go-to without a doubt! The only thing missing (according to my husband) is the option of adding anchovies. Keep up the great work!!!“

“We were in from out of town and tried a local restaurant. I ordered the reuben gyro and it was amazing! Some of the best corned beef I've ever had. The coleslaw was also yummy! The staff was so friendly and we would definitely return!“

“Buckeye Community Bank loved this pizza!!!“

“Disappointed in meatballs. Recipe not same as before. Too much filler maybe breadcrumbs and lesss meat!!! Go back to original recipe. Miss Miller Lite also!“

“My family and I were there for the soler eclipse, weekend. We walked in sat down at the bar, everyone was extremely friendly, kind, nice, polite, warm and welcoming. We had just come from another bar around the corner called SPEAK OF THE DEVIL they were rude unwelcoming talked about us eclipse people like really what are they doing here. Never went back there again. Back to Brass & Bronze we had the tacos the 1st night amazing. We went back the second night the kitchen had just closed so we had a drink then one of the owners came over and said I know how to make pizza I can make you pizza. So that is what we had for our 2nd night s dinner. We went back the next day for the eclipse for lunch about 1 again amazing. We meet the President of the city Council Joel Arredondo and his wife they sat outside with us and watched the eclipse. Again very welcoming, they had their daughter’s wedding at this restaurant. I recommend this place extremely high. We had the best weekend in a long time“

“I rate an Italian restaurant on a few different factors: marinara, meatballs, cheese pizza and tiramisu...Angelina's hit every mark with solid 5/5 stars in all categories! Quality ingredients and recipes to match! I'm glad we tried this little gem and will be back soon!“

“I wish I could figure out how to get my loyalty rewards. I don't know why they changed it. We order a lot from west ridge Marcos , maybe I will go where the help can actually help me“

“Great food and awsome service friendly staff that go the extra mile everytime i go im always laughing out the door. Janelle is awsome she know my order and has ready to go for me when i arrive. Thank u guys for the awsome service and food keep up the good work“

“So I'm a regular here I'd say 🤣 I order a good amount of times, never an issue. Yesterday I ordered on the app and put pay in store, I was gonna use a debit card, their machines were down everywhere, they took my name and number and trusted me, I didn't get a call before I went up there today to pay what was owed. The manager I usually see everytime was going to just give me the food but I respected what they did and paid it. They are all really great, friendly ppl. Download the app if you love their pizza like me!“

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..“

“Wow. Total nostalgia when I found out yall were still in existence.

The pizza? Deliciouso ??
Service? Professional and the shorter fella who helped me when I picked up 9/12/24 was very frickin cute lol and very frickin nice.
Atmosphere? The place smelled like heaven in a shop. And very clean too.

Will be back very soon.“

“Great food nice list of beers and the bartenders always are friendly and very helpful with drink ideas“

“great service, clean! food was good.“

“Staff was very friendly,courteous
and patient with my 5 million questions while ordering. Got home ,our 1 pizza wasn't right.
I called them,explained it wasn't what I ordered, they remade it, no problem,and again very pleasant and helpful.“

“This location for Marcos pizza is on of the better ones that I’ve had. My ONLY complaint is that the toppings could have been spread out more even instead of center of pizza only or else I would have given 5 stars. I usually go to the Sheffield village location but on accident, ordered the wrong Marcos in Elyria. Overall perfect amount of cheese and sauce. :)“

“We made a mistake on our order, but our driver saw me wave her down and was kind enough to come back and point out our mistake and was super sweet about it. So much for the husband getting new glasses to help him see today ? on a side note, pickle and alfredo is actually pretty darn good!“

“Ordered a large pepperoni and sausage. I thought that the pepperoni was supposed to be edge to edge, but it was only half covered. Really disappointed. I lived in Columbus for 33 years and was always satisfied with their pizza. I guess Avon doesn't care.“

“We love it here, so much we ate here twice this week. The pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had and the customer service is fantastic. I can’t recommend this place enough. We will be frequenting Olde Town Pizza often!“

“Great Food and Great Service“

“best sauce around!! always a great deal on Tuesdays. buy one get one 50 percent off.“

“Went there for personal pan pizza to go. Place wasn't busy and clerk and I had the best conversation. In fact I took my family (10) there for our Xmas get together. Best pizzas ever, service and server outstanding. Recommend this place highly

Vegetarian options: 3 of my family are vegetarians. They had many options available and loved there food“

“I've been going on and off to Selenti's since I was a teenager. Yeah a long time, I know. For the most part I have been pretty good as far as the food that I had prepared for me and my family. Now there was a time or two I did get my orders a little bit well done. But yeah I would still recommend this place to anyone. And yes I'm going to continue myself going there for lunches and dinners. I just wish that they would broaden there menu or just change it up a bit

Parking: The business is on a corner, no parking lot. But the street is free and plenty of street for most everyone“