50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sheffield Lake

“I just want to shout out Doughboy's Pizza & Wings for the catering for my daughter’s party. If you’re looking to have a really good pizza party & then some, go there. I got 3 whole sheet pizzas, 100 wings, a party pan of salad & rigatoni/meatballs with silverware & plates for $286 plus tip. It was ready on time & fresh. They have such a great menu to choose from. 🩷Everyone loved the food 🍕🍗🥗🍝 There was about 30 kids & 15-20 adults & I still had food leftover.“

“Ordered 3 pizzas today; they were scrumptiously delicious. Thank you for the gr8 employees and being so convenient and very reasonable prices.“

“Heard about Forte Pi from friend about great chicken tenders and fresh, organic food. We ordered carry out "make your own" pepperoni pizza with mushrooms, chicken tenders and salad shaker. Everything was superb! Two tenders is enough for four people. Pizza crust amazing, thin and light. Lemon salad dressing fresh and light. Shared feast with view of Lake Erie. Friendly service with explanation of all menu options. Will definitely be back.“

“Came to the lake from out of town and wanted a budget friendly meal for our family of 7. We ordered 2 meat lovers and an order of the cheesey bread. Everything was delicious. We took our pizza to go and ate on the beach. We will be back. God bless!“

“I don’t usually write restaurant reviews, but In Forno is an exception — because I genuinely believe they serve the best Neapolitan pizzas in Cleveland. I’ve been a loyal patron of this little gem in Avon for nearly a decade, and every single visit has left me with a full stomach and a happy heart. For years, George and Elizabeth worked their magic behind the counter, crafting pizzas that transported you straight to Naples. This summer, they passed their beloved oven — and their legacy — to Chris and Nicki, the new owners, as they embarked on new culinary adventures. When I dined there this week for the first time under the new ownership, I’ll admit, I was curious (and a bit nervous) to see if anything had changed. I’m thrilled to report that Chris and Nicki have beautifully carried the torch forward. The menu and recipes remain intact, and the pies are every bit as divine as ever. My go-tos are the Celeste, Burrata, and Picante Quattro Formaggi — each a masterpiece in its own right. But here’s a secret: the best pizza isn’t even on the menu. Do yourself a favor — grab a seat by the chef's table, order a drink, and ask him to surprise you with something special. Watching that wood-fired oven at work while your pizza takes shape is pure culinary theatre. I often joke that if I had to choose my last meal on earth, it would be at In Forno. Judging by the smiles and overheard conversations from other diners, I’m not the only one who feels that way. Chris and Nicki have done more than take over — they’ve honored what George and Elizabeth built, ensuring that every bite still tastes like tradition, passion, and perfection. So gather your friends and family, and head to In Forno for a slice of joy, a dash of nostalgia, and the best wood-fired pizza you’ll find anywhere in town.“

“This place is awesome! I live in Columbus but I get to the area often and I love going here. It has a really cool diner atmosphere, diner level pricing but super upscale level food. Every single thing I’ve ever had there is amazing, and there are some unique recipes that are great. Staff is always super friendly. Highly recommended!“

“If you love wood-fired pizza, you need to try Lorenzo’s Pizzeria. Their sourdough crust is hands down my favorite around. It has that perfect wood-fired flavor with crispy edges, a little chew in the center, and just the right amount of char.

The Margherita is my go-to every time. Simple, fresh, and ridiculously good. The fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and parmesan all work so well together.

We also had the Five Cheese and the Americana. The Five Cheese was rich, creamy, and packed with flavor, and the Americana was outstanding. The cupped pepperoni gets crispy around the edges, and the hot honey adds the perfect sweet and spicy kick.

Every time we’ve gone, the service has been great too. Friendly staff, great atmosphere, and consistently amazing pizza.

And it’s not just the wood-fired pizza. They have a full menu with regular pizza, appetizers, sandwiches, pasta, and more. Everything we’ve tried has been consistently good. I honestly just have a hard time ordering anything besides the wood-fired pizzas because they’re that good.

Highly recommend!“

“Tonight was a very busy night when I stopped in to pick up pizza for my family. Despite how hectic it was, the general manager was personally helping customers and handling everything with patience and professionalism. It almost seemed like some customers were ordering for the first time, but she remained extremely friendly and took the time to assist everyone.
The food was amazing as always. We ordered the mac & cheese pizza along with cheesy bread, and everything was fresh and delicious.
We’ll definitely continue coming back. We also really appreciate receiving the coupons in the mail—it’s a great bonus for loyal customers!“

“Cameos is the rising hot spot. The pickle bread is unique and very good! I also love their burgers and hot honey pizza - honestly everything is phenomenal!! Angelina, and Johnny always take great care of us, and always pay attention to our allergies. Were here often, come check it out.“

“I just love their pizzas“

“First of all you guys have amazing pizza! You are also great people! Thank you so much for providing the Westlake library with sandwiches and pretzels! It is much appreciated! Whatever seasoning you put on pretzels is so tasty!“

“Excellent small pepperoni pizza“

“We ordered the Tropical BBQ Chicken pizza from Jilliano’s for lunch today, and I can say, the flavor blew us away! It was a new taste experience with plenty of toppings including the grilled chicken breast & crumbled bacon, a tasty BBQ sauce, and a hint of cinnamon that made it a brand new experience. I would highly recommend you give it a try!“

“Have ordered uncle als plenty over the past few years, granted ive only ever got the foldovers... but can you blame me? Always fresh tasting and delicious! Service always on point for me, well worth the price tag you pay that is very fair I think aswell.“

“My three year old daughter and myself attended a princess scavenger hunt through out downtown Amherst that D’Tutanelli’s Pizza was apart of. Not only were they so kind during the scavenger hunt, but we came back late for pizza for lunch with the coupon they included and we had the best experience! Pizza was fresh and delicious and the staff was absolutely phenomenal, especially towards my daughter. We would highly recommend and will absolutely be back, thank you for a wonderful afternoon!“

“Rude customer service from the guy with the ponytail. He needs an attitude adjustment.“

“The Best sauce and crust! Instantly a favorite ❤️ 🍕“

“We ordered a large Extreme Supreme. The toppings were fresh, the crust was melt in your mouth cooked to perfection, and the extra cheese was just right. We usually order extra sauce at other places but decided not to at Master P and glad we didn’t. The amount of ingredients to crust ratio was on point. We took our leftovers home and ate them cold and the pizza was still bangin’ 😎. It was my first time enjoying a Master P pizza and I will most definitely be back.“

“good food awesome employees“

“Buckeye Community Bank loved this pizza!!!“

“We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, first time since the change in management, and were very pleased with the generous cheese and toppings and delicious crunchy crust - overall delicious 😋 - however, we found very little sauce and the sauce we tasted was different 😢“

“Thank for making Bowie’s 3 pizza!!! He loved it 3️⃣🥳🧁“

“Best pizzas and meatballs in my city.“

“Went there for the first time last Saturday after the JV football WIN against Buckeye and Ghost Tree did not disappoint! Drinks were delicious and brought out quickly despite how busy they were. And the pizza?! My son said it’s the only place he’s ever getting his chicken bacon ranch from now on. Highly recommend the Florentine pizza as well - it was fantastic. And you can’t go wrong with any of their carnivore options. Came back the next morning for breakfast/brunch and it was absolutely on point! Make sure you’re hungry for whatever you order (I recommend the chicken and waffles and the breakfast pizza as that’s what our table got). And thanks to the bartender for the hefty glass (and pour) on my mimosas! Will for sure be back and so happy that something worth eating at finally went in here. I was starting to worry that nothing would be able to top Church Street!“

“Hop Brothers quickly became my favorite local spot after opening. The pizza is the best around! The dog friendly paw-tio is perfect for getting a bite with my little poodle.“

“Fantastic Atmosphere. It's a local Gem Hiding in Elyria. I Have not encountered any poor visits. Food is always good. They will hook you up with their seasonal beverages and entrée's. Tell them Sashi reccomended it.“

“We ordered online and picked up at Sheffield location we used the on-line coupon great deals and we get points for using it . Everything was very yummy . We will be returning. Thank you to Everyone at that location. Your doing a amazing job😃“

“Disappointed in meatballs. Recipe not same as before. Too much filler maybe breadcrumbs and lesss meat!!! Go back to original recipe. Miss Miller Lite also!“

“We ordered a lg stuffed crust pepperoni pizza, cheesy bread and a chopped salad. 10 out of 10 on every level. The pizza sauce was seasoned well, there was an ample amount of cheese and toppings. The salad was excellent, perfect amount of toppings. The cheesy bread was also very good. Wish i could of got pictures but it was almost gone b4 i could get it on the table. Great job guys. We will definitely order again.“

“Mouth watering and friendly service 🤤🍕“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Great Food and Great Service“

“I ordered angel hair pasta with marinara sauce & shrimp. The sauce was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. I had take out & could smell its deliciousness before even opening the container. I could eat a vat of the sauce. This was my first visit & it won't be my last. I highly recommend this hidden gem.“

“First time using the app and didn’t double check my address- it autofilled incorrectly. When I realized what happened and called the store they did something pretty amazing and remade the order for delivery. Food tastes awesome and excellent service!!!“

“An absolute HUGE shout-out to Marcos Pizza in Amherst for donating a pizza to us and delivering it to us Amherst Firefighters while we were on a car fire this afternoon! We seriously can't thank us enough for doing that when i was ready to pay for it. Thank you for being a huge supporter! 🇺🇲🚒🚒“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I wish I could figure out how to get my loyalty rewards. I don't know why they changed it. We order a lot from west ridge Marcos , maybe I will go where the help can actually help me“

“Its take out
We request the wings extra crispy and they do not disappoint.
The people who work there are always super nice no matter how busy they are.
I appreciate that kind d of service and quality food.
Shame on me for not remembering their names to give a shout out to them
Thank you“

“I’m a brand new mom of a 2 month old. He hates his car seat, so I have him out of it carrying him around as often as I can. I walked in to pick up my order with baby in hand when a young man with dark curly hair lit up at the sight of my baby and went above and beyond by opening the door for us, carrying my order out to my car, and putting it in the passenger seat for me. He wasn’t weird about it, was just very thoughtful and seemed genuinely excited to help a young mom. I was floored at this kind of service from a restaurant like Papa John’s (we have had less consideration at nicer restaurants) and even more so from a young man! Please consider him for a raise and promotion. The food was as expected, but we will be returning here just because of the kind employees.“

“We had Marco's pizza for the first time in a while on Tuesday this week and it was Very good!!! It outshone the last Marco's pizza we had and really impressed my husband, who is a pizza snob. Good Job this week Marcos!!! And Thank you also for supporting your community as well as Camp Imagine!!! ❣“

“Took a large group of youth cheerleaders and family in today for lunch and had an awesome experience!! food and service were both amazing!“

“I purchased a 4-corner, butter crust, Bacon + Pineapple pizza for delivery. I’m not a pizza snob - I get maybe a single pizza once every three months.

Taste: This is the part that blew me away, there were genuinely so many toppings on my pizza it felt like half the pizza would fall off once I picked up a slice. The corners and crust were perfectly singed for the detroit, cheesy experience. The crust dough itself was a bit dry, which I prefer, and complimented the pineapples. The cheese was melted into the sauce long enough so there was no cheese pull / pulling half the cheese off in a single bite. Sauce was sparing and leaned toward the sweeter side.

Experience: Delivery driver was punctual, followed delivery instructions perfectly which is nice as I live in a gated community on the 3rd floor. I had to call to make and adjustment to my order and the employee who answered could not have been friendlier / more accomodating if he tried.

Price: $15 for a two topping, 4 slice piza for me is fair. That’s 2 meals for me, so $7.50 per meal for food I enjoy in today’s market is a steal.

Overall: will definitely go back every other month, and can’t imagine any other pizza places being better. I’ve tried three other local places and none provided the service or quality / content of pizza and toppings compared to here.“

“We love East of Chicago! Yummy option for Friday night dinners!“

“Amazing! I’m gluten free and vegan and it’s so hard to find good tasting pizza. Master’s is the best I’ve found! 10/10 recommend!“

“Andy, his wife and Matt are always friendly and provide service with a smile and good conversation. The pizza is always delicious. It's nice to see the staff selling new items at the food counter. Thanks Andy and staff for providing great service at the best convenience store on the East Side. For the past year I've noticed the energy of the store has gotten better and better each day. Way more upbeat. Not that it was bad before it's just better having the employees that are there now. Keep up the great work!“

“My family and I were there for the soler eclipse, weekend. We walked in sat down at the bar, everyone was extremely friendly, kind, nice, polite, warm and welcoming. We had just come from another bar around the corner called SPEAK OF THE DEVIL they were rude unwelcoming talked about us eclipse people like really what are they doing here. Never went back there again. Back to Brass & Bronze we had the tacos the 1st night amazing. We went back the second night the kitchen had just closed so we had a drink then one of the owners came over and said I know how to make pizza I can make you pizza. So that is what we had for our 2nd night s dinner. We went back the next day for the eclipse for lunch about 1 again amazing. We meet the President of the city Council Joel Arredondo and his wife they sat outside with us and watched the eclipse. Again very welcoming, they had their daughter’s wedding at this restaurant. I recommend this place extremely high. We had the best weekend in a long time“

“Food is great and very friendly and accomodating owner.“

“The pizza here is always so good and i swear it’s even better than the other domino stores i’ve been to. The pizzas are always made perfectly with just the correct amount of ratio and cooked perfectly in the oven. The people on the phone are always so king and willing to help if needed. Will be a regular here from now on, thank you.“

“The great ranch and potato pizza was one of the best I’ve had from a franchised pizza place in years. The crust was perfectly cooked, soft and crunchy with a touch of sweetness, the sauce creamy and rich with the right balance of salt, and the crunch of the almonds very unique! Keep up the great work everyone.“