50 Best American Restaurants near Sheffield

“The food is fantastic. We ordered Thanksgiving meals and everything was wonderful.“

“We have been members of Cooper’s hawk for almost a year now. we come every single month to have dinner before we go do our wine tastings and select which bottles we liked to take home. I have never had a bad meal here. the servers that supply the wine tasting are always incredible.

Tonight we had the pleasure of having Steve B as our server at dinner. he made our experience the best yet in our year of membership here. He is an incredible asset to the Cooper’s Hawk family.

For everyone who is looking to join the membership here I HIGHLY recommend doing it. my whole family uses this time as a monthly get together and it’s the absolute best!“

“We had my mom’s 90th birthday party with 28 guests at the Westlake location this morning. Because we are regulars there, Nick the manager bent the rules a wee bit to allow us to have the back area, near the bar for our party right at opening time on a Saturday. The service by wait staff Mary and Lauren was fabulous, every one of us LOVED our food and your hospitality was off the charts! Thank you again for allowing us to have this 90th in the best of all places for our youngest family member (age one) and all the way up! Love, love, love Kitchen Social. Ps. My pimento burger and ceasar salad were ‘da bomb’!“

“Delicious and flavorful food, every time!“

“Was so surprised how good my fish was super fresh and tasted amazing it was so busy and we got a 4 person table in less than 10 minutes and got our food in less than 30“

“Great food!! Ashley is an awesome server. She is so attentive to our needs. She remembers our order every week.“

“Mutt & Jeff's restaurant and pub in Lorain, Ohio is the perfect balance of a friendly, neighborhood type bar and a restaurant with great food. There is plenty of seating, the staff is attentive, and there is a lot of variety on the menu. My last visit I had this monster cheeseburger with house made chips and dipping sauce. They have great hot wings as well, daily specials, and very good perch and walleye sandwhich. The prices are reasonable and it is a nice, friendly place to hang out.“

“This was my first time visiting and my experience was quite pleasant. It is a weekday so there was no wait. The place is clean and you don't feel like your sharing your table with strangers. The food was good, nice sized portions with a fair price, and the service was on point. I will definitely go again“

“Just visited here with my boyfriend tonight and we were the only people in the front dining room! The food was great and very great value. Feel like they are getting screwed because of the construction right there. Would have went past it myself if my boyfriend hasn’t been there before and pointed it out. Very much recommend. Will be back very soon. :)“

“Great place to meet friends“

“The pizza of the month was the best thing I’ve ever had here. It was amazing!“

“Pizza was good! Nice addition to their menu.“

“First time there, would definitely go back. Food and service was great.“

“I have eaten here a couple times and always great food. great service I definitely will be back.“

“Great atmosphere and a perfect party room for private events!“

“1st time visiting and the food was awesome as well as the service. Highly recommend!!!“

“Love everything about this place.“

“Went for my Birthday! Excellent experience! Great food and staff! Highly recommend!!“

“We love their fresh salads from locally grown produce. I had the 1833 salad and it was delicious!“

“Might just be one of the best burgers from a fast food joint that I have ever eaten. The Pretzel Bits were almost as good as the burger. I could eat those all day long. Service was very good and the tables were clean.
I highly recommend Culver's for my overall positive experience and a sublime burger! Will definitely be back.
5 Stars.“

“Great food and attentive bar godesses“

“My first time there but it was my mom and cousins 2nd or 3rd time. I was a little weary at first because it’s very small and quiet, but it had just opened for the day when we got there but once people settled in, it definitely didn’t feel like we had to whisper. We had the absolute best waitress Helen and 100% would request her if you go there! We got scallops, ribeye with blue cheese butter, and the chicken pasta and all 3 were great portions for the price and tasted absolutely delicious. Not one complaint on the food at all. The drinks were also amazing, the waiters and waitresses actually make each drink their self opposed to a bartender doing all the drinks which I think is really cool and personal! They also bring them to you so chalk full you can barely take a sip without spilling it - not a bad thing! Definitely delicious blue cheese stuffed olives for a classic dirty martini, cosmo was great and the espresso martini was also amazing. To top it off my mom got the crème brûlée and said it was also good. My mom also accidentally spilled her drink everywhere and they were so sweet about it, getting napkins to cover the huge wet spot on the table and replacing her drink with no questions asked. Would highly recommend this place to anyone.“

“I was highly impressed with the food. I ordered the Voodoo pasta and it was amazing. Highly recommend. I was passing through Ohio enroute to Colorado and this meal will have me wanting to come back. On top of the meal being delicious the presentation was immaculate. Good job Chef!“

“Elyria Rotary Club just brought in a group of 15 and we had the best time. Delicious food and really AWESOME service from Remy! 🤩5 Stars!! Thanks for taking such great care of us!“

“The food was good. Limited menu. But I was disappointed in my Lobster Flat Bread. The pic and what I got were nowhere close. I barely had any lobster, most pieces of flat bread didn’t have any lobster at all. The Calamari was tender and well-seasoned but not crispy. The breading seemed as if it had been sitting for a while. The drinks were good but pricey. The service was poor. Except the Sous chef, she was excellent. But the others were a bunch of young kids who all seemed to be brand new, unorganized, and not what i would expect in a place so expensive. The marinated Ahi Tuna was excellent. All of that being said, we enjoyed our time there, but $156 later, I doubt we will go back.“

“100% amazing!!! Hands down best burgers 😜“

“Wonderful food is a foregone conclusion at the Cabin Club. I’ve never had a bad meal there. Today’s lunch was lobster bisque and the steak salad. Highly recommend both. But what made my lunch a truly wonderful experience was the absolutely phenomenal service. I am a senior with mobility issues. It has been awhile since I was at the restaurant and I completely forgot the front steps. Only three, but still tough for me to climb solo. When another patron mentioned my difficulty to the hostess (SO sorry I didn’t get her name!) she came out and took me around to the side door, where it was much easier to get in. My lunch companion had to duck out early, so this awesome hostess not only helped me go out the side door, she walked me all the way to my car! This sort of kindness, sadly, is in short supply these days. Thank you, Cabin Club and your fantastic staff for going above and beyond!“

“Had to eat out due to power outage. Cracker Barrel was first choice for a good meal being without power for five days. Had the Country Chicken dinner and thoroughly enjoyed. Toof off some of the stress. Thank you..“

“Invited to brunch from my friends for the first time. We were greeted by a very friendly hostess. Once seated our bartender/ server, Darion K. readily welcomed us! He gave us the history of the restaurant, details on drinks and venue. Our food was served hot and with great presentation which was all prepared by an awesome chef! Sadly we forget the person behind the scene who does the preparation! I will return and spread the word! God bless them all!“

“The waiter Anthon was great at the Ruby Tuesday in Elyria,OHIO and the food was amazing.“

“Great fish and chips and turtle sundae“

“Great place for good old-fashioned comfort food! Everything on the menu is a winner!

Dietary restrictions: Just let your Server know

Kid-friendliness: Kids are welcome

Wheelchair accessibility: First floor“

“My husband and I had a looooong day moving. Our server Aaliyah was freaking awesome getting us our drinks and we had quite a few refills but she was on top of everything. Really cool person and we're definitely going back! Thanks girl!“

“Almost perfect every time!
Wonderful food and WARM CRUSTY BREAD.
Usually, we have to ask for cocktail napkins...lol...first world problems... otherwise, we love going there.
Veal Fratello and Shrimp Fratello are our favorites.
Also... the Calamari.“

“We are from NH just passing thru on a roadtrip. Enjoyed the food. Service and prices were great!“

“Back again at this Fantastic Diner. Yes i will travel from Akron any day to come here and get a quality meal and service“

“Our first visit to Wolfe's and we were quite impressed. Seated at a window table in the bar, very comfortable. Greeted by Eileen who was super nice. Went over the menu with us, took our drink order. Ordered a pepperoni & sausage calzone to start. DELICIOUS!!! Dave had a steak salad and I had grilled cheese sandwich with chips. We finished the afternoon off by ordering 2 specialty pizzas to go. I can't stress enough the excellent service Eileen gave us. We will definitely be back and ask for a table with Eileen. Thank you, Eileen! Carol and Dave“

“🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶 🎶 warden led a prisoner down the hallway to his doom I stood up to say goodbye like all the rest And I heard him tell the warden just before he reached my cell "Let my guitar playing friend do my request" Let him sing me back home with a song I used to hear Make my old memories come alive Take me away and turn back the year 🎶“

“Was looking for a spot to stop on our way to PA. Found this along the way but it was solid. I wouldn't say it was the best food I ever had but it was good and lots of variety for my family. We went with 2 young children and were easily able to appease their pickiness.

Since it was lunch I didn't try any cocktails but they sounded delicious.

Would recommend the stinky tator tots.“

“Yummy! Me and my hubby stopped in after our appointments today. Had a delicious breakfast. I got corned beef hash, sunny side up egg and he got chopped steak and eggs and we split some pancakes 🥞. Everything was cooked to perfection, flavorful and great price. Waitress was a sweetheart too! This is the type of place we both grew up eating at with our grandparents. Hope to bring our kids with us in the future one day. Happy customers!“

“I really like this place I always forget about them they have such a varied menu but everything is pretty good. The one thing I do not like is their Booth style tables for a larger group have absolutely no room the table is just too big you can barely get in and out of the seats unless you're a very small child or a small person. It is very uncomfortable.

Parking: The paid parking spots are closer to the restaurant than free parking spots free parking spots are quite a distance away“

“Everyone who can act like an adult is welcome here! Great food and support of Veterans!“

“Excellent food. Great friendly staff“

“Good service and appreciate the variety“

“Ate here on a whim on our way back from Columbus. We decided let’s choose a local restaurant instead of a big chain. Glad we did because the oh boy burger was awesome! That sauce is amazing!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I had an amazing experience at Applebee’s! The food was fresh, flavorful, and came out quickly. The menu has something for everyone, and the portions are generous for the price. Our server Jacob was super friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. The atmosphere was clean, welcoming, and perfect for both families and casual dining. I’ll definitely be coming back soon – highly recommend Applebee’s for a great meal and excellent service!“

“We've been to the Westlake Rosewood Grill several times and always leave Extremely Satisfied. The Managers, Servers & Staff are Always Very Professional, Friendly, Polite, Considerate and make our dining experience truly delightful. The food and portions the Chefs prepare are always consistently Generous, Delicious and Excellent! We Highly Recommend a dining experience at this location!“

“Delicious food, fast service, relaxing atmosphere. Not rushed. Definitely recommend! We will definitely be back!“

“If you miss nostalgia,and going back to simpler time, this is the place for you!! My wife was so excited because she remembered this place from her childhood in Chesterland. You couldn't wipe the smile off her face. And yes it didn't disappoint. Will definitely be bringing her back. Thank you!!!“

“Had breakfast here today and I loved the service and food. Have been looking for a restaurant like this since I moved out here. Happy to finally find a non chain restaurant that I want to dine at often.“