13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shiloh

“Would like to give a shout out to slice of heaven's pizza in Shiloh. Very impressed pizza was very good. The service was very good.If you have not got to eat here yet. Please try it.Good luck and hope you get more business. Got.To meet the owners too very nice people.Thank youMike pollock“

“Wonderful place to bowl with plenty of XL balls for easy use for peeps with big hands. Staff is helpful and friendly. Brent who helps with bowling ball fitting and drilling is very knowledgeable. Recommend it wholeheartedly. Nobel Romans isn’t pretty good too!“

“Order online it was a little weird wouldn't let me pick my sauce for the wings I called they fixed it for me. Picking up was a great experience such a nice staff and the food was even better probably the best pizza in town. Wings were great and that cheesy bread was out of this world.“

“Great location. Very cool venue. Food and service is great (even by Columbus standards, and that's saying something!). We only get back to Shelby once or twice a year, and this has become a 'go to' spot to meet up with friends. Great menu selection, the bar area is excellent to help if you want nice glass of wine or a well made craft cocktail, or low and behold a damn beer! Ha! Something for everyone here, but it has a nice vibe and always fun.“

“Originally from Cle. Kinda grew up in pizza shops. Shared an Italian sub it was very very good. Ordered a Supreme minus onion. There's a lot to be said for places that cut up their own veggies. People said they were pricey. Having worked in the chain shops that claim fresh veggies they are bagged and precut and you know have extra preservatives. There was no denying the green peppers were fresh hand cut. Everything tasted as good as I remember a really good fresh pizza and sub being from yrs ago. You don't get that very often anymore. Thanks for the love in you food!“

“I’m a trucker and I’ve traveled through many different states and tried many different pizzas. If you want the top of the line stop at East of Chicago Pizza and you won’t be disappointed with anyone you stop at. Food is awesome and service is great. Thank you East of Chicago Pizza!!!~ Mark Matlock~“

“Was in town visiting the family they bought pizza here. I was really impressed. The overall quality of the pepperoni and sauce was awesome! I'll definitely keep JJ's in mind next time in town visiting for supper! 10/10 stars for you guys!“

“I love the owner of east of Chicago in Greenwich, she and her crew always do a great job of getting my orders right and always done at the time they say it will be done. I will always go to east of Chicago when I feel the need for a pizza, they have the best pepperoni, sausage and onion pizza on earth in my opinion.“

“East of Chicago has always been our go to pizza joint. Fast delivery, food is always superb, friendly staff. Cory the delivery driver is awesome! There's another great delivery driver I don't know his name though I've tried many items on their menu and I've never tried anything that wasn't top notch amazing.“

“We love Gionino’s in Shelby! Worth the extra money compared to competitors. The ingredients they use are way better than pizza chains. The Meat lovers pizza is so good! Been wanting to try their chicken and jojo’s, but hard to not order what we know. My kids loved the pineapple pizza! Don’t forget about the cheesy bread too! Last order we had a deluxe sub and it was very good as well. Keep doing what your doing and thank you for making great comfort food!“

“This is not only convenient as far as the location to my house but this is the ultimate best dominos I have ever eaten at in my 36 years of life. I am glad I decided to hear my hubby out and try it because there isn't not one thing that I wouldn't eat on there menu. Thanks guys keep being so prompt accurate as well as always delicious ? && the best.“

“Have always loved Shelby, Ohio's Domino's. The pizza I got for lunch today was the worst pizza I've ever had. Tasted like cardboard. No sauce. Was horrible sorry to say! Hope your Domino's doesn't resort to being like the others. I have always been pleased. But not today!!☹️“

“We stopped rather unexpectedly with a large crowd and the varsity club stepped up and said no problem. That being said, they handled our order with ease. The wait staff and the kitchen did an incredible job. I will say if you get a chance order the Cameo 419 Pizza. It is “