“Wow! We're from the Cleveland area and I have to say this deluxe topper pizza is freaking amazing. It's probably a good thing it's not local for me. Seriously the best crust. Absolutely love it!The wings weren't a traditional hot Buffalo, more BBQ Buffalo-ey but very good.“
“Great local pizza with a friendly caring staff! An experience in itself. An absolute Sugarcreek institution.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust options that are tasty!Parking: Spacious dedicated parkingKid-friendliness: Great family friendly restaurantWheelchair accessibility: Wheel chair ramp into front door. No steps inside. Plenty of tables with chairs that can be moved for a wheelchair to be at the table.“
“this one of a kind pizza is a favorite for my entire family and I think most of Tuscarawas county. with grandma's not being available anymore, a trip to Dover is always welcome!Thank you for keeping this tradition alive for our family and I hope many more years of business are to come!also, for those of you that do not know, you are able to order your pizza unbaked for those who travel a distance before arriving home and prefer it to be fresh!“
“We had stopped for the buffet, but they had shut it down early for lack of customers. So we ordered in and was promptly served. The food and services are what we've come to expect from East of Chicago.If it wasn't for all the other local establishments to eat, this place would be on our short list of places to eat when in the area. Most of the locals close early, and it was later in the day is why we ate here this day.“
“We only ever get take out so don't know how it is in the restaurant but it's in my top 3 for cheese pizza. Homemade pasta is also very good and the service at the back pick up has always been great. The cheese sticks are fantastic, I always eat more than I should.“
“We only had 1 complaint about the food. The pizza dog had a little to much liquid, like water when we cut it open. But the flavor was excellent. We enjoyed talking to the owner and workers on Oct. 27 late. We will definitely stop again the next time we're in the area!“
“Ordered the food online. A new service they provide. It was so fast and easy to do the ordering and the pick up process went very smoothly. I do believe there is a small fee of .99 cents to order online... not a big deal…..it is convenient….The pizza was superb. When you want toppings on your pizza, they give ‘em to ya. You get what ya want! Unlike other pizza places around here.The food tonight was DELICIOUS ?the parking area to pick up isn’t very accessible, especially when it’s busy around the area.Only concern was the Jojos were more like the thin cuts. Skinny and little. We ordered the regular ones. Oh well, they were good either way. ??♀️“
“It's great, if you like very light sauce. The last time we said hey, we have been getting like missing sauce, just dough. So they asked if we wanted extra sauce. We said no just normal, but more than missing big blank dough spots lol. Well apparently we have to ask for extra sauce. it's weird, don't have this problem anywhere else....their salads are not typical pizza place salad, leaves a little to be desired, very small and priced like a medium salad, few toppings. Subs are great! Homemade taste!“
“Awesome place to get pizza and wings. Probably best round I would say. Sometimes it's a wait when they are busy but well worth the wait. They ladies here take there time to get y ok ur order perfect and at a great price. If I could eat here everyday I would. Some of the best cheeses that just melt in your mouth along with great sauce and bread emm just THE BEST.Parking: Plenty of spaceKid-friendliness: They love kids.“
“Finally….We moved near the area (20 mins) away in the Canton area. We have tried countless Canton favorites as far as pizza goes and we dislike them ALL.When you come from NE PA (Pizza Heaven) you are spoiled with tons of delicious pizza spots.We recently tried Bolivar Pizza and were very pleased with the entire experience.The pizza sauce is only a little sweet, but so delicious, the wings are delicious, the cheesy jojos are delicious, the pizza crust is delicious, the mozzarella sticks are SO SO GOOD!!!We called our order in and I believe it’s pick up only. The customer service here is second to none. Extremely polite, friendly and kind.We accidentally ordered the “Family” size pizza and it’s MASSIVE!!!This is our new pizza spot from now on.Don’t change a thing about this place!!! Ever.“
“This is still one of my favorite pizza places to frequent even after not living in New Philadelphia for almost 20 years.Cash or check only. Every pizza establishment I’ve been to with those options have been top tier good and Mary Zifer’s is in the the top tier of that top tier. I miss it already!“
“Great wood fired pizza with good flavorGot 3 of the wood fired specialtyVeg,4 cheese and buffalo chicken.Veg was nicely loaded with lots of veggiesThe 4 cheese had good blend of cheese one didn't overpower the othersThe buffalo chicken was just great tho. It's not your typical flooded in franks and blue cheese that I like and that im used to. It was more subtle for a buffalo chicken pizza but a great flavor profile all of its own. Will get it again ????“
“I feel like I gotta say. The lady who took my order was friendly. I paid over the phone. Was able to add a tip. My pizza and wings showed up hot and fast. The delivery driver was friendly. And honestly it's 10pm on a Saturday night in dover Ohio. Nothing else is open. Greatly appreciated. Thanks guys!“
“After hearing the price of a single full sub, I almost decided to cancel my order. Thankfully I didn't. After paying for my order, they handed me my sub and I went from thinking I was over paying, to thinking, this is no 'Subway' sub. The thing had to weigh at least 3 lbs. It was two, rather large, meals. And could've easily been 3. Unfortunately it was so delicious, I ended up over eating and only got 2 meals out of it. I could complain about the service but I won't be so picky. It was a fairly young crew and I understand that there is a labor shortage. While they may not have been real personable, thankfully I was looking for food, not a friend. Plus, they make one heck of a sub!“
“We went here last Friday and had a great experience. The blonde brownie dessert we had was outstanding and I don’t usually eat that kind of stuff. It was busy but not too bad and we didn’t have to wait. I got a burger and it was juicy and really good. My wife got a pizza and they have a wood fired oven and she really liked it. We also got these really good cheese sticks that my kids also liked and they’re usually hard to please at restaurants. This will be our new spot when going down 77.“
“What a hidden gem! We stumbled across Penso's after a family day out and will absolutely be back again. They were so friendly and welcoming. The food was fantastic and very well priced for a small restaurant. I just wish we lived closer to get it more often. The cheesy bread was my kids favorite!“