8 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tarlton

Pap's Pizza Pizza • $
30 Harrison St, Tarlton

“Amazing pizza! All the food I've had there was amazing actually. Great folks running the place as well. My landscape shop is only a block away and I can order, pickup, and get back to the shop with a hot and fresh pizza in 20 minutes or less. They're quick about it! I definitely recommend pap's if you're in the area. If you're not, it's worth the drive!“

4.5 Superb13 Reviews
Laurelville Pizza Pizza • $
16074 Pike St, Laurelville - 6.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Garlic Cheese Bread
Fried Chicken Salad
Sweet Potato Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Ham and Cheese Sub
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Tenders
All Meat Pizza

“The pizza was excellent and the service was even better. Mel was our server and she was lovely to talk to. A real asset to their company“

4.8 Superb93 Reviews
Steve's Pizza Pizza • $
11850 Walnut St, Adelphi - 6.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Keto Cookie Dough Cheesecake
Keto Strawberry Shortcake
Keto Peanutbutter Pie
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Lover
Loaded Pizza
Cheesy Bread
Cheeseburger
Meat Lover
Pizza Sub

“I just ate the Smothered Burger. BEST BURGER EVER!!!!“

4.7 Superb31 Reviews
Kingston Giovanni's Pizza Pizza • $
7 N Main St, Kingston - 9.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub with Extra Onion
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cheese Breadsticks
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Chef Salad
Pizza

“Great food and cold beer friendly atmosphere“

4.2 Good51 Reviews
Tommy Wayne's Pizza Pizza • $
5805 Chillicothe Lancaster Rd SW, Amanda - 6.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom and Pep Pizza
All the Way Pizza

“I tried the cauliflower pizza, their everything one. I didn’t get the name. The crust was crunchier than most, which I loved! A lot of times they tend to be soft/soggy. It used to be a sit down restaurant, but it’s now a drive through. The way it’s roped off is confusing at first. The sign has a Bible verse “man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word of God” Luke 4:4. Lol“

4.2 Good25 Reviews
L & J's Ice Cream & Pizza Ice Cream Shop • $
16072 Main St, Laurelville - 6.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Pepperoni & Cheese
Black Raspberry
Cheese Sticks
Cheesy Bread
Cheeseburger
Cheese Curds
Pizza

“Stopped by here during our day trip around Ohio. They make fried pies to order. I ordered an apple fried pie and it was delicious. My husband got a milkshake and I tried some chocolate hand dipped as they was out of chocolate soft serve. Very good sweets and awesome service.“

4.1 Good54 Reviews
Dairy Shed Too & Ramrod's Pizza Ice Cream Shop • $
21 N Main St, Kingston - 9.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Bologna Sandwich
lb Bacon Cheeseburger
Brownie Bowl Sundae

“Get ready to elevate your taste buds at Ramrods pizza (dairy shed too)! If you haven't tried it yet, you're missing out on a truly transformative experience! And, be sure to indulge in their heavenly desserts in Kingston. Or, cozy up with a hot apple cider made with the best cider from Laurelville. Additionally, their sublime pickle fries will leave you in a state of culinary nirvana! I give this ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Dairy Shed Too & Ramrod's Pizza“

4.1 Good35 Reviews
Cristy's Pizza Pizza • $
145 E Main St, Amanda - 6.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cristy's Famous Cheesy Breadstix
Build Your Own X Large Pizza
Build Your Own Small Pizza
Parmesan Cheese Pack
Large House Salad
Cristy's Classic
Salad Your Way
Italian Sub
Chef Salad
Veggie Sub

“I have always loved Cristy's Pizza since I was a kid growing up in Lancaster. Their pizza is always amazing and quality very consistent and great. I'm super cheap though and sometimes they're just a little out of my range especially without deals or coupons, but I highly recommend for a great pizza!

Vegetarian options: They even offer a cauliflower crust pizza for vegans or gluten free option“

3.1 Average22 Reviews

You May Also Like