18 Best Italian Restaurants near Wadsworth

“My husband and I stopped here for our anniversary! Greeted at the door. Got to pick our own table which was nice. The servers, Kenzie and Niko, were excellent. We ordered mussels for our appetizer and quite a few weren’t open. The broth was delicious. They offered to discount or make more. We chose to make more. So delicious. Very easily taken care of. I had the lemon orzo! Delicious and so was my husband’s Alfredo with shrimp. Complimentary Cannoli for our special day! Delicious! Our drinks were made properly and delicious! We will be back! Thank you for the great experience!“

“Hand wipes in pizza crust Manager knew about it told us we could eat the pizza ask for a refund would not give us one“

“Best Pizza EVER“

“Antonio’s did a great job feeding the Highland football team. Food was great, warm and very well priced. They even put the meals in individual servings for each player. Recommend for a good meal!“

“My husband and I come in usually Wednesdays and Fridays .We love your happy hour and meeting new friends . Melissa and Kristie are awesome servers and make us feel so welcome ! Great place to relax and unwind after work! So glad we discovered your place ! 💗 The food and drinks are incredible as well !“

“The food was delicious. We were seated right near the entrance and although the seats were comfortable (high-back chairs), people constantly walking by was distracting at times. Our server was attentive without being obtrusive, and very pleasant.“

“Had my husbands surprise 70th birthday party. The food was excellent, the staff was wonderful and everyone had a wonderful time.“

“Food and very good salads“

“This location delivered exactly what you hope for when you walk into an Olive Garden—comfort food done right, great atmosphere, and solid service. From the moment we sat down, everything felt relaxed and welcoming. The dining room had that warm, cozy Italian restaurant vibe without feeling crowded or chaotic.

The food absolutely hit the mark. The pasta dishes were rich, cheesy, and hot all the way through—exactly how it should be. The sauce was flavorful without being overpowering, and the portion size was generous enough that I definitely wasn’t leaving hungry. And of course, the breadsticks were fresh, warm, and addictive as always. Let’s be honest—those alone could justify the visit.

Service was prompt and attentive without being overbearing. Drinks stayed full, food came out quickly, and everything was brought out exactly as ordered. You could tell the staff cared about keeping things moving smoothly, even during a busy dinner rush.

Overall, this was one of those dinners where everything just worked—good food, good service, and a comfortable atmosphere that makes you want to stay a while. If you’re looking for a dependable spot for a sit-down meal where everyone can find something they like, this Olive Garden absolutely delivers. We'll definitely be back.“

“Went in with the whole family had great service I believe her name was Morgan she was friendly kind and made us feel at home. The food was great hot and came to the table in a timely manner.“

“I just celebrated my birthday here on Saturday in the Oakwood private room and want to thank you and you're amazing staff for doing such a great job with my birthday dinner. Everything was absolutely perfect. Hannah and Izzy did a phenomenal job. The food was great everything was hot we received everything quickly. Hannah and Izzy handled my large amount of guests so well. My guests even talked about how good of job they did and the reviews they will leave on Google. The space was perfect! I'm sooo thankful I was able to book my 32nd Birthday dinner with y'all. I'll definitely pass the word around about y'all excellent service! God bless each of y'all!!!🙏🏾🤗🎊🎉 Blessings, Brittany Young“

“I have been there a few times and it never disappoints. The homemade lasagna is to die for . The spaghetti was the proper proportion and just wonderful in taste and texture. I have been there for a couple breakfast and everything was really good. I do also want to add about the atmosphere, and the people that work there they are funny attentive to our needs and pleasant to everybody. This is a must go to restaurant.“

“First off, their small pizzas are only $10.And the food is subpar but it's good to go. The burgers and banging but the bread falls apart easy so it gets messy. Depending on who you get to serve you depends on the service, not all of them are nice. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting but there's no indoor seating service any longer.(i.e. takeout only)“

“My husband would go there for his lunch breaks when he would work that way. He would ALWAYS bring me home Baklava (which is always perfect and not from a freezer!!!). Now we drive 40 minutes just to get it!! The family who has ran this pizza shop for years, are so kind, especially the father and son!!! Our go tos are the cheese stromboli and a large pizza extra done!!! Big Star- Five Star ⭐“

“It's a pretty good place to eat. The atmosphere, service, and food are pretty good, but I see room for improvement in all of these areas.
The staff sat 3 tables for the same server at the same time in the bar area. We were one of those tables, and it was hard for the server to keep up with everyone needing the same thing at the same time. This is a situation that experience and training could have avoided.
The food was incredibly hot when the brought it and the ravioli was quite oven toasted crispy on top... not what I wanted or expected, but not inedible and something many others would like.“

“Really nice stop for lunch today. To tell you the truth, we were taken back by the small menu selections. The atmosphere is very nice...a wine bar feel. We sat out on the balcony. Again... very nice. The food came out quickly and fresh. It was..... very nice. Get it? It's a very nice place. Nothing outstanding or over and beyond what you'll get elsewhere, but they do things well and the food is good. The prices are maybe a bit high, but you can say that everywhere right now. I had the fish and chips ($25). Lake Erie Walleye with an herbal aoli. It was great, honestly. That walleye dish is an example of why lake erie walleye has such a great reputation. J got the corner smash burger ($19). A double patty cheeseburger with aged cheddar. It was very juicy. The cheese was great. Sauce was very good. A really, good burger. Fries were also pretty good. Coleslaw.... very, very light. The perfect coleslaw for a fish dinner. I'll be honest with you here. I don't like coleslaw. I've never eaten more than a small bite at one time in my life. This was the first coleslaw in my 50+ years that I actually ate and enjoyed the whole thing. Finished every bite. So there's that! Would I go back. Absolutely! We enjoyed it! Would I suggest it to an out of town friend looking for something great and different? Maybe not.“

“Very impressed with Master Pizza! 🍕 I ordered the Chicago Tavern pepperoni pizza crust with extra Parmesan! Overall, the pizza was great, but I hardly had any sauce after I requested double sauce, but after talking to the girl there they made it right going above and beyond definitely recommend this pizza to anyone in the area they do it right!“

“They provided us lunch today at Valley College. Very good pasta, pizza and salad! I will definitely order from here soon. Thank you!“