Bakeries near West Jefferson

Sweet Madeline's Vintage Bakery Bakery • $$
3 National Pike, West Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Salad Club Sandwich

“Fresh chicken and duck eggs, yes please!! I happened to discover this cute Cafe on my way to a friend's house, and so happy I stopped by! They have sweet treats, some brunch items, fresh eggs, and topped with their friendly and welcoming service! I would probably be here more often if it wasn't so far from me!“

4.9 Superb14 Reviews
Cake Creations Bakery • $$
46 W Town St, West Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

My Daughter's Birthday Cake
Signature Cake
Wedding Cake
Classic Cake
Gourmet Cake
Cupcakes
Brownies

“Cake Creations is located in a very unassuming building in West Jeff, and we were blown away with Beth's service. She is very flexible and laid back, and she guided us through all the decisions for deciding which cake we wanted as well as the design options for our wedding cake. We would recommend Cake Creations to anyone looking for a high quality cake for a really great price.“

3.7 Good6 Reviews
Qamaria Yemeni Coffee Co. Coffee Shops • $$
3221 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard - 7.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Honeycomb with Honey and Cheese
Honeycomb Pistachio Milk Cake
Pistachio Coffee and Cake
Valley Juben - Ground
Caramel Milk Cake
Tres Leches Cake
Pistachio Cake
Iced Mufawaar
Coconut Cake
Coffee Cake

“Adam's Yemeni tea spot offers a remarkable experience, blending authentic Yemeni tea with a captivating atmosphere. Visitors are drawn in by the inviting ambiance and Adam's personal touch, ensuring each cup is brewed to perfection. It's a must-visit for anyone looking to immerse themselves in Yemeni culture through the simple pleasure of a great cup of tea in all of Columbus.“

4.9 Superb151 Reviews
Hilliard Station Baking Co. Bakery • $
4036 Main St, Hilliard - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Supreme
Peanut Butter Cup
Daily Flavors
Cinnamon Roll
Cookie Dough
Cupcakes

“Oh my goodness! I had been craving a warm, gooey and delicious cinnamon roll for months. This place was recommended to me by a friend since my partner and I would be passing by Hilliard on a trip. I called ahead and they set a cinnamon roll back for us. They were super sweet people and absolutely pleasant! When I picked up my roll they gave me directions on how to reheat it if I wanted to enjoy it warm and oh my. This hit the spot. So good, perfectly gooey, not to sweet. Just wonderful. ❤️“

4.9 Superb53 Reviews
Crumbl - Hilliard Bakery • $
5466 Westpointe Plaza Drive, Columbus - 6.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cereal Flavored Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Banana Cream Cookie
New York Cheesecake
Cookie Variety
Pumpkin Cookie
Doughnut

“If you really like or even love cookies, this place is a really good option. The choices are few, but I'm partial to chocolate chip so I'm always covered. However, I've tried a few of the others, and they're not bad.The service at this location is pretty good. I've never had to wait more than 10 minutes for my order, even when they were busy. The ordering process is pretty simple. There are ordering kiosks available, or you can place an online order, which speeds thing up even more.My only issue is that you are forced to buy their massive cookies every time. They have smaller cookies, but they're only available with their catering. These should be available as purchase options as well.Other than that, I would recommend them if you're looking to satisfy that sweet craving.“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
Vanilla Cakes & pastries Bakery • $
2604 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard - 7.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Baklava

“Happened to find this place out of no where because I happened to be in the area. This is just such a gem! I got their savory cookie which was delicious, the baklava which is just so fresh, almond croissant that we all enjoyed (very rich), and milk cake. I mean, if you're looking for good desserts from an unpretentious place at a great price, this is it. So good. Completely fresh.“

4.9 Superb31 Reviews
Bakes by Lo Bakery • $
5354 Center St, Hilliard - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie with Sea Salt

“So freaking good! I’ve had Bakes By Lo a few times while at Center Street. This year I ordered a birthday cake for my husband because he loves cookie cakes. The cookie was delicious and the frosting - omg! It was so good I could eat it by the spoonful. Will be ordering again for the next birthday!“

4.8 Superb32 Reviews
Créme de la Créme Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $
5311 Westpointe Plaza Drive, Columbus - 6.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Pistachio
Chocolate Eclair
Ferrero Rocher
Avocado Toast
Smoked Salmon
Carmel Tart
Croissant
Pelmeni

“After seeing pictures of their fully loaded pastry cases, I made plans to go right away. Crème de La Crème has a very European feel, from the efficient but not saccharine women at the counter, to the light classical music playing, to the warm, seemingly sparkling tea room-esqe interior. It was very pleasant and beautiful inside. I had a cappuccino (very good), avocado toast, which felt a little small but plated nicely and good, and 2 items from the case. Though I feel a bit of guilt saying it, for narrative integrity I will disclose that the pastries were not very good. The eclair had a white chocolate robing, which was waxy and flavorless, much like the filling. The fresh strawberry cake was not very light, and while soaked nicely in a syrup, also did not have much fresh cream lightness, or many strawberries to cut through the mouth-coating fat content of the whipped cream and custard. I'm sure they were made that day (right?) but had in my heart I sensed they had languished in the case too long somehow. All and all, I would absolutely go back! This would be a very cute experience to bring a friend to catch up, order too many beautiful treats, and have an overall elevated cafe experience. No hipsters in sight, A+“

4.3 Superb115 Reviews
Giant Eagle Bakery Bakery • $$
4001 Britton Pkwy, Hilliard - 9.46 miles

“This is a solid spot for grocery shopping. It's probably my favorite grocery store in the area. It's clean, tons of parking, carts are well maintained (and actually sanitized - they have people wiping carts), it has a Starbucks (always a plus), you can mix and match your own beer 6-pack (cool), stuff is always in stock, and they usually have the fancy cheeses that the other grocery stores don't have (major plus). Also, the layout of this giant Eagle just makes sense. Some of the other giant eagles in the area have a weird and nonsensical layout. This one is great.“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
Great American Cookies Bakery • $
5043 Tuttle Crossing Blvd #166, Dublin - 11.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Original Chocolate Chip with M&M's Cookie
M&M Cookies and Chocolate Cookies
Chewy Chocolate Supreme Cookies
Original Chocolate Chip Cookie
Frosted Chocolate Chip Cookie
Oatmeal Walnut Raisin Cookies
Chewy Pecan Supreme Cookies
Peanut Butter Cup Brownie
Big Bite Double Doozies
Birthday Cake Cookies

“It’s so rare these days to come across good customer service. But today I encountered INCREDIBLE customer service. To Serene and everyone at Great American Cookies: thank you so much for going out of your way to sort out my online order. You just earned a customer for life! EVERYONE: GO HERE! EAT THE COOKIES! IT WILL BE THE BEST DECISION OF YOUR LIFE!“

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
Bakle the Baker Bakery •
5516 Stockton Way, Dublin - 10.8 miles

“We came across Bakle the Baker at the farmers market. My kid absolutely loves well designed frosted cookies in fun shapes, and Bakle the Baker has become a favorite. We're always excited to see what kind of fun new designs she has on hand. We've gotten dinosaurs, cookies shaped like slices of pumpkin pie, Christmas lights, and more. Just browsing the pictures in her gallery on her website is amazing too. We were also excited to find out recently that Winan's carried some of her cookies, so we've been getting some there during the market off-season. The cookies are tasty in addition to looking good, and we were told that they will stay fresh 2-3 weeks in their packaging and can be frozen. Ours haven't lasted long enough to make it to the freezer though! The baker is very friendly and kind too.“

4.6 Superb9 Reviews

Enjoy Similar Cuisines In West Jefferson