11 Best Italian Restaurants near West Jefferson

“This was our first experience and it exceeded every expectation. With all of the chains and commification I am always happier to find a place with local history. The options were hearty and excellent. Won't be a stranger to this restaurant!“

“A nice surprise. Found this place with a friend for lunch last week. I’ve been back for takeout twice already. Meatball sub has a hold on me! Service is great. Friendly and attentive. Great menu with lots of options. Great atmosphere. I would definitely recommendWheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp“

“Took my children for dinner last evening. The staff were EXTREMELY nice, and the gentleman who checked me/us out at register was very helpful with adding a gift card that was too old for their system to utilize, and he still gave me credit... came out to our table to check on us after we sat down... and the food: 3 o/o 3 of us enjoyed our pasta bowls. Nice work, Hilliard Piada!“

“Food is good; nothing exceptional. Service was a little slow considering it was not busy at all. 8 people eating was $160 not including tip. I would rather go to Texas roadhouse for that money. For the money, I won't willingly go back here for a meal.“

“Great pizza with the perfect amount of toppings! The staff is friendly, and the pizza comes out in a reasonable amount of time. Crooked Can, where this is located, is a great place to go as a group or an individual. They also have live music.“

“Today my husband and I ordered from Flyers in Hilliard, as we frequently do. Our front door didn’t close all the way after my husband got our pizza from the delivery driver, and the wind blew it open further. Our driver Autumn went out of her way to text me to let me know it hadn’t shut because she didn’t want our pups to get out. Though they are very good dogs and don’t typically run, I am so appreciative of her doing so! Also, with it being Super Bowl Sunday, I expected it to take a little longer than normal but we received our order very quickly with no issues! Thank you for the outstanding service!“

“Food has never been better, I prefer this over Olive Garden. The girls who work there are so nice and helpful, you know the food and service is good when you see they're of different race. Although that sounds wrong of me, I've been to other Fazoli's and this is THE best one and that's one of the differences I noticed. Everyone is so nice and understanding unlike other locations. The place is clean and fast regardless of the good amount of people in and out. Never had an issue with the service or the food. Shout out to the girl that recommended the chicken broccoli penne!“

“Really amazing service! Our youth hockey team dropped in basically unannounced this Sunday afternoon. One staff member in particular worked incredibly hard to ensure our orders were accurate and timely. And they were so friendly and helpful. Great experience!“

“We found zuko's pizza during covid, on a cold snowy winter night. When the idiots tried to shut everything down. We have been a regular customer sense. Joe the owner, and other family members d o a awesome job. Last night I was in the store. A delivery driver came in for an order. They asked what the customers name was, and the individual just held up their phone so the employee can look at the name. That's not there jobs! What kind of idiots are we hiring? It's everywhere we go now.“

“AHHHHMAZINGG!This is literally my FAVORITE pizza of all time. Sausage and pepperoni with their delicious RANCH. You won't go wrong!!! I pre ordered by calling on the phone. It was ready in time and kept warm. My go-to everytime I'm in Columbus or Michigan.“

“This might be our favorite pizza place, and this location is top notch! They are always fast and the pizza is always perfect. We also love grabbing a bottle of ranch with our order too. Not only the pizza is always perfect, but their boneless wings are also always fantastic!“