11 Best Bakeries in Westerville

Just Pies Inc Bakery • $
736 Northfield Rd # 1, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Triple Berry and Lemon Meringue
Uncooked Sugar-Free Apple
Apple and Apple Crumb
Strawberry - Rhubarb
Strawberry Rhubarb
Apple Crumb Pie
Red Raspberry
Boston Cream
Butterscotch
Key Lime Pie

“So far I've had a banana cream pie and peach pie, as well as a chicken pot pie.
Both desert pies were excellent. Instead of the typical coin slices of bananas you typically see in a banana cream, this had long, thick slices of banana, ensuring plenty of just the right amount of ripeness. The cream was light, fluffy and flavorful.
The peach pie was loaded with ripe, but not mushy, peaches in a filling that was sweet, but not overwhelming. The crust was crisp and flakes with no hint of a soggy bottom.
The chicken pot pie had plenty of nice chunks of chicken and plenty of vegetables in a thick, but not pasty, gravy.
The only issue I had was that the bake time for the pot pie was insufficient for my oven. While the top crust was a little browned, the bottom and sides crust was just raw dough.
I did buy another pot pie and will try to adjust my baking time to see.if I can get it right.
Service was wonderful. Both times that I've been in, the employees were pleasant and friendly.
I will definitely be trying out their other pies in the future.“

4.7 Superb107 Reviews
Schneider's Bakery Bakery • $
6 S State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Just a Little Taste of Heaven
Blueberry Turnovers
Custom Birthday Cake
Round Glazed Donut
Apple Puff Pastry
Apple Fritter
Sugar Twists
5 Berry Pie
Cream Horn
Iced Cake

“The donuts and rolls are great and they recognize my hubby as a regular!“

4.7 Superb67 Reviews
Crumbl - New Albany Bakery • $$
6326 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Cotton Candy Sugar Cookie
Chocolate Crunch Cookie
Oatmeal- Iced and Warm
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Milk Chocolate Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
6 Pack of Cookies
Apple Pie Cookie
Cornbread Cookie
Churro Cookie

“The food was quality, but could have more flavor. The service was friendly, but could have a bit more forwardness by welcoming you as you come in the door and asking if you have ever been there and offering assistance with how everything works, rather than the customer feeling confused and having to ask. The atmosphere is clean and seems well managed, it just needs to be a bit more polished. It is a bit pricey, however, in the correct demographics it will do well. If the flavors of the week were posted in the window with a large bold font, so it can be seen while driving by it would bring more traffic through their doors.“

4.5 Superb160 Reviews
Sweet CLE-'bus! Bakery •
447 Lazelle Rd, Westerville

“I'd been looking forward to visiting this very specialized pierogi 🥟 place for a long time, and was so happy to finally be able to on a trip our family went on. Never any way for us to be able to try all the wonderful rotating flavors, and unfortunately missed a couple of the specialized flavors for her birthday week, but was thankful for what I could try. All amazing 😍. Very well combined ingredients, obviously created with love and devotion. Not to mention the fact that they are near well the size of the average palm of your hand. Well worth everything. And Lizz is just a sweet as the title. 🙂 If pierogi 🥟 are one of your favorite things in the world, then never miss this Sweet Columbus Ohio gem!“

5 Superb15 Reviews
Nanak Bakery Bakery • $$
5460 Westerville Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Ganache
Birthday Cake
Black Forest
Wedding Cake

“Her bakery is simply outstanding! I have been ordering for several years, and every time, the cakes and pastries are a showstopper at our parties. The quality, taste, and presentation are always top-notch. Beyond the delicious treats, the customer service is exceptional—friendly, professional, and always reliable. Highly recommend for anyone looking“

4.8 Superb22 Reviews
Cheesecake Connection Bakery Bakery • $
1234 Colston Dr, Westerville

“For my wife’s birthday this month I wanted to get her a cheesecake that wasn’t off the shelf. The cheese cake was amazing to the point my wife said it’s best she’s ever had. Will be going back.“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Great Harvest Bread Co. Bakery • $
445 S State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Cream Cheese Scones
Jalapeno Cheddar Garlic
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
Honey Whole Wheat Bread
Cranberry Orange
Cranberry Walnut
Cinnamon Raisin
Cinnamon Rolls
Sourdough Bread
Pepperoni Roll

“The Dakota bread is my favorite! I drive 16 miles to purchase it. I often get a pepperoni roll and some other seasonal bread. It freezes well in addition to making wonderful toast and sandwiches. The owners a friendly and will happily describe any of the breads. On the fall they have a wonderful pumpkin roll which is much fresher and tastier than the those from the grocery.“

4.3 Superb51 Reviews
Espresso Air Coffee Terminal Coffee Shops • $
25 N State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Turkish Delight Pomegranate Flavor
Pistachio Pinwheel Baklava
Spinach and Feta Flatbread
Coffee Beans Whole
Turkish Bagel ACMA
Spinach Flat Bread
Spinach Flatbread
Turkish Baklava
Cold Brew Blend
Nutella Cookie

“Highest quality coffee in Columbus,“

4.8 Superb133 Reviews
Le Gateau LLC Bakery • $$$
7978 OH-605, Westerville

“Sue at Le Gateau is absolutely phenomenal at making and designing wedding cakes. She incorporated our style and suggestions into the design and it was more beautiful than I could have ever imagined. She is a true professional who takes pride in her work, understands the importance of quality and ensures that every last detail is perfect and delicious. I am so thankful that my friend, who hired Sue for her wedding, recommended her business to us. For our wedding cake, it served 230 people (4 tiers) with Italian cream cake with strawberry filling, orange cake with chocolate ganache filling, and chocolate cake with raspberry filling covered in iced buttercream frosting...might I add, all made from SCRATCH. We received so many compliments from our guests about how excellent our cake was!“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Kroger Bakery Bakery • $$
89 Westerville Plaza, Westerville

“tastes very good emplloyments are nice“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Cheryl's Bakery • $$
646 McCorkle Blvd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Cheryl's Signature Classic Frosted Cutout Assortment Box
Cheryl's Signature Create Your Own Assortment Box
Assorted Cookies
Chocolate Chip

“Great experience with Maddie. Highly recommend this place. 10/10“

4.2 Good46 Reviews