50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Wickliffe

“Great Food And Great People!“

“Been in business 60 years, that in itself is more of a recommendation than I could ever give.“

“Just ordered today. Ready on time and nice n hot!! Pizza is always delicious.“

“The pizza was wonderful and the service with a smile was even better.“

“Pretty solid pizza and real cannolis can’t beat it“

“Best Chicago deep dish I’ve ever had! My husband and I were very impressed. My own complaint is that I live nearly 3hours away so I won’t be able to have this amazing pizza as often as I’d like. 10/10, definitely recommend!“

“The best pizza in Ohio!“

“Guido’s is the best. The end.“

“Everything we have tried at pie cafe has been amazing! Today my daughter was overjoyed with her white chocolate mocha freeze. Tastiest coffee drink she has ever had! Thanks Pie cafe! I hope you stick around for a long time and that others find out how delicious this little cafe really is.“

“Great pizza! Reminds me of Lucio's at Eckley's Corners from years ago.“

“We had the best day watching The Buckeyes at The Wild Goose! One of our sons lives in Willoughby & the other son & his wife live in Shaker Heights. Fav spot for our kids but our first time. The pizzas, onion rings & buffalo dip were amazing! Outstanding selection of beers. Loved the atmosphere. Charming but lots of TVs as well. Can’t say enough about the staff!!! Outstanding service & so friendly! Cant wait to come back!“

“10 out of 10 pizza, recommend NYC style“

“Simply the best pizza I've ever had. Superior toppings, great crust and consistent excellence for decades now. I find it unreasonable for me to go anywhere else.“

“Great food An experience.“

“I don't leave reviews however I'm going out of my way to show this owner some love !!! From Youngstown and just passing through on some work and mamma Mia 😘👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻 Just what I was wanting and the best sandwich I've had in awhile The meataballas were delicious as well Well done and best of luck in your business 👊🏻 Ordered the Nonna 😎 added some hot peppers and mayo“

“We don’t get carry out from anywhere else in mentor. 10/10“

“Ordered a pizza, double lobster with spinach (well done) on Thursday evening and absolutely loved it. Delivery was on time and pizza was warm despite the cold weather. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We got a coupon to try a free pizza for the first time. I was surprised at how big it was. Got the Mediterranean and loved it. The woman at the window was also friendly. Loved the crust!“

“I usually love this place but tonight's curbside order was an hour and a half wait (usually curbside pickup is a half hour)! They now also have signed up with other delivery services so they are super busy. Our food wasn't ready when it was promised. I went in and there were about 3-4 empty tables! You'd think that with the long wait the tables would be backed up too. I mentioned to the manage that if I had known there were tables available I would have dined in instead of take out. She said they try to get their dine-in customers their food before the take out. 🤦 Really Dewey's, what customer wants to know that their service is not as important as another customer? If I had known that I wouldn't have waited an hour and a half (plus) at home, and would have gone in, placed my order then changed my mind and taken it to go!“

“100% clears any pizza I’ve ever had.“

“Great pizza and desserts!“

“The pizza was hot and fresh, the wings were nice and crispy and the fried dough was the perfect tasty treat to complete the meal“

“We come almost every Sunday to see Stella. She’s amazing and the foods great too.“

“My fiancé and I want to thank the entire staff at Vero for an AMAZING experience! The pizza is by far some of the best pizza I have ever had in 40+ years! I will gladly come back from NJ to eat here again! My compliments to the Chef and the staff. We now have a home away from home. As we Italians say GRAZIE TANTE! 🇮🇹🙏“

“Fantastic place! Highly recommended!“

“This plus it's been exceptional except the last three times we got delivery it's an hour and a half late“

“Great food. Friendly staff. Good prices too. Everything I've tried so far has been great.“

“Best pizza around... Love the medium thin crust!!!!!“

“We drive from Madison to visit this Geraci's location. The staff is always friendly and the food is amazing. The homemade Geraci's sauce with pasta and a slice of pizza is always my go to. The price is very reasonable, especially compared other Italian restaurants.“

“We love Master Pizza! My Son and I stopped in for a salad and pizza tonight after his baseball game and our entire experience was great! Every single staff member was incredibly friendly and the restaurant was immaculately clean. Our pizza was hot, loaded with toppings, and delicious. Our salad was fresh and crisp and of course we love the house-made Italian dressing. When we left, everybody thanked us for stopping in. We rarely dine in (we do take out) and we are glad we did. This may have to be a weekly outing for us after baseball!“

“Ordered pepperoni rolls and subs for the Super Bowl both amazing 10/10“

“Stopped by the Mentor location today for a slice, left with 2 slices & a can of pop for $7. Good stuff! She said pizza was fresh out the oven, it was pretty good! A little greasier than I’d like on the bottom but crust wasn’t too soggy and had good crunch with pepperoni too“

“9/24/2025: This place is a gem! The food and service was amazing! Our server Katina was very attentive and made sure everything was great throughout the night!! We also enjoyed talking with Moma and her daughter. Such an added bonus to the night to meet and hear their stories! Can't wait to go back---until then I will enjoy my left overs!!“

“The food is great, they should rethink the delivery provider though. It took 2 hours after we ordered our food to get it due to Noone coming to pick it up. Thankfully even though it wasnt 100% their fault. The manager owned it and delivered it himself and credited us.“

“I’ve been coming here since the late 90’s & Still enjoy the great pizza & atmosphere!!“

“Best pizza, friendly delivery staff, we order from them ALL the time, we’ve never been disappointed!“

“I am an out-of-towner visiting family. I am amazed at how good the pizza and calzones are! Huge portions, fantastic flavor, generous with toppings, and great service! I thought it was pricy until I got my food; WELL WORTH IT! Delivery was early, food was HOT. 10 out of 10 for me!“

“Great food.
The atmosphere is a little strange. You can still see the glue from where they tore up the carpet and there's these big weird curtains all over the place like your great aunt would have used to hide a part of a room. With no carpet and somewhat open floor plan the bar noise carries quite a bit.
Service was good.
Big drink list - looked interesting!“

“Awesome food and staff first time ordering there will Be back“

“So happy with the selection of pizzas that were purchased for a large, holiday, family gathering. From the Nashville Hot and Pineapple Cowboy to their plain cheese pizza, there was something for everyone--including gluten and dairy-free! We all agreed, it was delicious!“

“very busy....great service. awesome pizza and cheese sticks.“

“Simply the best pizza I've ever had. Superior toppings, great crust and consistent excellence for decades now. I find it unreasonable for me to go anywhere else.“

“I order some pizza for a party I was having and wow did Georgio's come through. Reasonably priced pizza and amazing taste. Everyone loved them! We are customers for life!! Also, you can't be $5 fresh and ready. Top notch customer service!“

“The menu offers a great variety of appetizers, salads, and entrees. Service and staff are efficient, professional, courteous, and just plain on top of their roles. It is a great atmosphere and extremely well managed! Great job, all who participated in serving a party of 16 on Sunday!“

“Food is amazing, service is excellent. Pranzo! does not disappoint.“

“The 2 gentlemen that were creating the food were very wonderful, and the counter staff person was very kind and polite. Wonderful service as always.

I absolutely love the pizza from Villa Pizza (as it tastes as delicious as my wonderful NY Sbarros pizza).
Very flavorful sauce, not too sweet, not too acidic, and you can taste the fresh ingredients too.
The Caesar salad is a very flavorful one as well.“

“Food and service were excellent. I recommend.“

“I ordered the meatbal pizza with jalapeños. Wonderful crust and very flavorful.“

“they have great food and great staff. also, just a side note. I got in a accident and the pizza still survived perfectly fine in the box, as well as the garlic knots.so their to go packaging is pretty good too 🤣 I promised a while ago I would write this publicly, so here it is haha. but yeah, I got in a accident head on and the pizza literally flew to the backseat and still survived, we ended up taking it to the ER with us hahaha“

“I can’t say enough amazing things about this Georgios! Everytime I call in, they know exactly what my family loves! The owner is always so friendly & food is always fresh! If you haven’t tried their stuffed crust pizza, you’re missing out! It’s our absolute FAVORITE! Thanks for always being so kind! This is what business is always about“