26 Best Pizza Restaurants in Broken Arrow

“Pretty good pizza. Selling by the slice is a plus. Wait times are fast. The whole pies are very good as well.“

“Visited for the first time and it was free garlic knots Wednesday! Can’t beat that. Vivian was our server and she did an outstanding job of explaining the menu choices. Will definitely be back.“

“I love it 🥰 it was the best pizza place“

“Well for Wednesday night date night,

I convinced my better half that we should try Tobies instead of our uncles place.
So we strolled over and we're taken by surprise.
1. You seat yourself.
2. It was game night.
3. How warm the staff was.
It was like a home away from home. Great vibes, freshly made food, and great options from the menu.
We didn't dive in like we normally do, but from the fresh loaf of bread and garlic oil, to the dinner salad, and the pizza was delicious as well. Plenty of toppings with a side of ranch, was absolutely good.
We'll definitely be back.“

“Ok Danny… Why did y’all take away the regular Italian salad dressing?? That is a Cicis staple. I had to get a salad bar refund today cause it wasn’t available. Can you please bring it back? We have been there several times but seem to always miss you. LOL. Thank you for all you’ve done for us and understanding my autistic son!“

“Fantastic experience. We love downtown BA. Just something quaint and nostalgic about it but with the modern, updated ambiance and vibe. The Rooftop food was great. I got a grilled ham & cheese and it was super fancy with the jam/jelly to dip it in (I'm a sucker for sweet and savory combo). Service was great, we had a day party so she tended to us but let us do our thing while she paid attention from afar. A little pricey but not bad for 4 people and bar service I think I got out of there for $205. Experience, rooftop vibe and ambiance paired with the excellent food and service made it a great value for a day occasion. Will definitely be going back!“

“It is so good to have Papa Murphy’s in Broken Arrow! Fresh Pizza Baked at Home!

They are now in that old KFC across from QT at Kenosha and ELM. Look for the familiar KFC bucket shape sign you are there.

Order on line, pay on line and pick up your pizza at the drive through window in the back.
Today’s order, was two, large, create your own pizzas and a salad. The pizzas were a delicious combination Canadian Bacon, Giant Pepperoni, Ground Sausage, Italian Sausage, Salami, Black Olives, Jalapeños, Mixed Onions, Mushrooms, Herb & Cheese Blend all on original crust with red sauce and Mozzarella. It is a delicious artisan pizza designed by Spike and assembled by Papa Murphy’s!“

“Logan, Josh, Stormi did an awesome job tonight with my order. Great customer service“

“We just love the Book-it program! Reading and pizza is the best!“

“Thank you Lyndsay and Corey, fantastic service and delicious pizza. We will be back“

“Every time I’ve ordered from the store it’s on point, so today was no different. I arrived a little early and saw multiple people carrying many pizzas out (5-8), but what I didn’t expect was the one dude workhorse running the entire store by himself. I’ve seen some pretty crazy food service in my life, including working at a certain chaotic breakfast chain myself, but this one takes the cake. The fact that this dude got my order out on time as well as all these others with no help is honestly baffling. I didn’t catch his name, and I hope he gets credit for this, but the lone dude with the garlic butter pop socket needs a promotion to market trainer. Thank you my guy. 🤌🏻“

“Nice job 😑😑😑no sauce at all.“

“Seriously impressed. We had a not so great experience a few months ago, and almost stopped going to Pizza Hut. At that time gave us a “credit” that was minimal, and an attitude that made me want to choke someone come someone and never eat at Pizza Hut again. Today the manager Joslyn completely made up for it, and saved our future dealing with their brand….and with 3 teenagers we eat A LOT of pizza. Pizza Hut needs to reward Joslyn for saving the day, and thousands of $ in future business. Thank you Joslyn!“

“Go try out the Domino's Pizza on 39th and Garnet The customer service was amazing and the food the stuffed crust it's so good I know it's new to Domino's but wow we'll try it out it's remarkable better than all the rest The only thing I wish they had was pork sausage instead of the Italians not a fan but it's worth a try I tried it so you don't have to..... You got my approval now go get it!“

“Delicious pizza, fast delivery. Love this place. Highly recommend“

“Today, my wife and I ventured out to Mr. Gatti's Pizza inside Walmart on S. Elm Pl in Broken Arrow. I was a previous Mr. Gatti's General Manager/Market Area Training Manager in the mid to late 1980s. My experience taught me it was all about the attention to detail. If you make a good product, people will buy it.

We went inside Walmart and Mr. Gatti's is located inside to the left of the entrance. We ordered The Sampler and Dutch Apple Treat to go. I would have rated five stars if the wait was not so long. The cashier said it would be ready in 10 minutes, and it took 35 minutes. Reasonably, it should have been around 15 to 20 minutes. While waiting, there is a TV with a rotation of items offered for your indulgence. No music overhead other than what's on the Walmart speakers. Not a big deal.

I was so excited to try the pizza when we arrived home that I forgot to take a picture of it before eating. The Sampler lived up to my expectations by being well made and was very delicious. The Dutch Apple Treat was good as well, except it needed more streusel topping.

Now the question is whether I would return, most certainly. My experience today brought many good memories. I recommend you to give it a try.“

“The food was really great!“

“I absolutely love this bar! If you are looking for a good vibe hangout with exceptional service. Rooski’s is the best bar in town! We came on a Friday night, there was an awesome singer that kept us entertained all night. We will be back soon! Thanks Rooski’s!!“

“Usually when we order from here it’s amazing, tonight not so good, the crust was thinner then normal, and harder as well (tasted stale) the pizza and breadsticks both as well as they were not cut right, breadsticks not at all and didn’t have the cheese on em when that’s what I ordered, I would still recommend this one but not sure what’s going on tonight everything was messed up tonight“

“I LOVE Marco's!!! They always provide quality pizza. I went to pick up pizza tonight and as soon as I entered the store Matt and Bruce greeted me with a smile and had me checked out in less than five minutes. This is what I experience every time I come to this location and that is why I love them.“

“The young man that took my order was great and helped me with my order , there was a situation with my order and it took longer than expected, for that I got some extra wings on the house!! I didn't expect that at all!! I love that customer service!! and if you know you!! But the wings here are pretty dogone good ,“

“Just had a delicious pizza delivered and it got here pretty quick, the delivery driver also had great customer service! We've always loved this store because the quality of service. We're glad to have them near by, thanks everyone for the time and care you put into each order!“

“A Mediterranean gem in Broken Arrow!
The food at R&M Restaurant is absolutely delicious everything is fresh and full of authentic Mediterranean flavor. We tried several dishes and each one was even better than the last. The service was friendly and fast, and the atmosphere felt warm and inviting. You can really tell they cook with love and attention to detail.
Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to again and again. Highly recommended! 🌿🍽️“

“By far my favorite dominos to go to, I always order carry out and the food is always fresh and perfect, one time I went I either ordered wrong or didn’t get the extra pep like I wanted, didnt matter, as soon as I said something their manager whipped me up another one and it was perfect , best pizzas, best customer service , couldn’t ask for more“

“Ordered 4 pizza's + 2 other items from website. DoorDash delivered 3 pizza's + the 2 other items,I told the driver and he said that was all they gave him. Driver contacted doordash and gave me a number to call. The person I call said they could not send the other pizza but would refund the missing pizza but that has not happened since the order on March 15 2025. If this store is so damn poor they can't refund my money because they screwed up I am telling everyone I know to stay away and why. (Yes,I called the location to talk to the manager and was put on hold 5 times,told to press 8 when the phone recording started and got the runaround and no manager.)“

“Ken really messed up, but Mazzios reigns supreme. Wish they would stop playing and open up in Texas already. Ironically I go there for the salad bar, which they need to add matchstick carrots and kidney beans to, and I stay for the pizza.

Best French dressing on the whole planet.“