24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Broken Arrow

“Pretty good pizza. Selling by the slice is a plus. Wait times are fast. The whole pies are very good as well.“

“Visited for the first time and it was free garlic knots Wednesday! Can’t beat that. Vivian was our server and she did an outstanding job of explaining the menu choices. Will definitely be back.“

“I love it 🥰 it was the best pizza place“

“Ok Danny… Why did y’all take away the regular Italian salad dressing?? That is a Cicis staple. I had to get a salad bar refund today cause it wasn’t available. Can you please bring it back? We have been there several times but seem to always miss you. LOL. Thank you for all you’ve done for us and understanding my autistic son!“

“It is so good to have Papa Murphy’s in Broken Arrow! Fresh Pizza Baked at Home!

They are now in that old KFC across from QT at Kenosha and ELM. Look for the familiar KFC bucket shape sign you are there.

Order on line, pay on line and pick up your pizza at the drive through window in the back.
Today’s order, was two, large, create your own pizzas and a salad. The pizzas were a delicious combination Canadian Bacon, Giant Pepperoni, Ground Sausage, Italian Sausage, Salami, Black Olives, Jalapeños, Mixed Onions, Mushrooms, Herb & Cheese Blend all on original crust with red sauce and Mozzarella. It is a delicious artisan pizza designed by Spike and assembled by Papa Murphy’s!“

“Logan, Josh, Stormi did an awesome job tonight with my order. Great customer service“

“Go try out the Domino's Pizza on 39th and Garnet The customer service was amazing and the food the stuffed crust it's so good I know it's new to Domino's but wow we'll try it out it's remarkable better than all the rest The only thing I wish they had was pork sausage instead of the Italians not a fan but it's worth a try I tried it so you don't have to..... You got my approval now go get it!“

“We just love the Book-it program! Reading and pizza is the best!“

“My new favorite restaurant! I drove 20 minutes to meet a friend on The Rooftop. It was totally worth it! We sat outside in the sun, blocked from the wind. Elian was my waiter, and gave me superior service! They had good music playing in the back ground, while I enjoyed my wine! I had a fabulous Chicken Cesar Salad, with a homemade unique dressing. It was one of the best I have ever had! The next nice day, I will Happily drive the 20 minutes to enjoy their excellent food and Ambience on the Patio!!“

“Terrific food and great service.“

“Delicious pizza, fast delivery. Love this place. Highly recommend“

“Thank you Lyndsay and Corey, fantastic service and delicious pizza. We will be back“

“Just had a delicious pizza delivered and it got here pretty quick, the delivery driver also had great customer service! We've always loved this store because the quality of service. We're glad to have them near by, thanks everyone for the time and care you put into each order!“

“Nice job 😑😑😑no sauce at all.“

“Usually when we order from here it’s amazing, tonight not so good, the crust was thinner then normal, and harder as well (tasted stale) the pizza and breadsticks both as well as they were not cut right, breadsticks not at all and didn’t have the cheese on em when that’s what I ordered, I would still recommend this one but not sure what’s going on tonight everything was messed up tonight“

“The young man that took my order was great and helped me with my order , there was a situation with my order and it took longer than expected, for that I got some extra wings on the house!! I didn't expect that at all!! I love that customer service!! and if you know you!! But the wings here are pretty dogone good ,“

“I absolutely love this bar! If you are looking for a good vibe hangout with exceptional service. Rooski’s is the best bar in town! We came on a Friday night, there was an awesome singer that kept us entertained all night. We will be back soon! Thanks Rooski’s!!“

“Ordered 4 pizza's + 2 other items from website. DoorDash delivered 3 pizza's + the 2 other items,I told the driver and he said that was all they gave him. Driver contacted doordash and gave me a number to call. The person I call said they could not send the other pizza but would refund the missing pizza but that has not happened since the order on March 15 2025. If this store is so damn poor they can't refund my money because they screwed up I am telling everyone I know to stay away and why. (Yes,I called the location to talk to the manager and was put on hold 5 times,told to press 8 when the phone recording started and got the runaround and no manager.)“

“I don't get it 20 to 30 managers come and go from this pizza hut since 1985. I make one simple request every time. And for the longest time they managed to fulfill that request. And here lately it like you're talking to a wall when you speak to them at the window. I simply request undercooked Pizza, I buy multiple when I come. It simply makes it edible after being refrigerated several days. Papa John's who's only a mile from my house, get it right 90% of the time. I simply prefer Pizza Hut sauce. But if you can't eat it, that's irrelevant. Not only was this order not! Undercooked, I would have considered it overcooked and sent it back anyway. So I'll patiently wait a couple months till they hire another manager, who hires teenagers the care.“

“Papa John's is very good although their specialty pizzas have switched out a lot from the kind that I used to like all together though Pizza is like a 9.5 to a 10 out of 10 but it's the flavors that they have is why I rated it a 4“

“By far my favorite dominos to go to, I always order carry out and the food is always fresh and perfect, one time I went I either ordered wrong or didn’t get the extra pep like I wanted, didnt matter, as soon as I said something their manager whipped me up another one and it was perfect , best pizzas, best customer service , couldn’t ask for more“

“I read some of the other reviews and feel for these people. Pick up your pizza. The drive through is fast and the employees work hard to get your orders right. If you are lucky enough to deal with Susan on your trip to Mazzios, you will have a better day from that point on. The car you drive will get better gas mileage, and your clothes will retain an unrealistic luster for, at least, three and a half months.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust“

“We walked into Schlotzsky at 10:55 am. Ordered our meals went into dining room to find no clean tables, face and hand prints on glass, splash up on soda machine, trash and food on sticky floors. I did speak to manager on duty she said they were short staffed. I get that but the condition of the dining was unexceptable. This amount of filth doesn't happen overnight. Food was good but my stomach can not handle thought of how the kitchen might looked.“

“Sally was such a sweetheart taking our order over the phone. She took her time and didn't mind our baby crying in the background and told us that she used to actually Rock babies at the church nursery and it absolutely warmed my heart. I would definitely order from this place again 🫶“