50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Brooklin

“I like Papa John's Pizza. I like how the pizza taste and how the toppings on the pizza is presented. I like how it comes with their signature jalapeno pepper on the side along with their buttery garlic dipping sauce. Mmmm delicious. Just be careful when ordering on the app. Make sure you to check the store location that you would like to order from. I accidentally order pizza that I previously purchased at another store location and it sent my order over there. Luckily I had relatives that live near that store location and they enjoy a free meal on me. Too bad the app can't notify me that my current location is not anywhere near the Papa John's Store closest to me or letting me know that my pickup location needs my attention.“

“Had an awesome experience here! I ordered a gluten-free, dairy-free pizza and it tasted absolutely great—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made. I loved that they prepared it right in front of me, and the whole process took less than 10 minutes. The staff were really friendly and the ambience was warm and welcoming. Definitely coming back!“

“Heather was our waitress and we couldn’t have had a better person serving us. She is very happy and knows how to treat customers. You are very lucky to have her. Believe me as we eat out quite often and it’s hit and miss as to getting a great server or not!“

“On Thursday, September 18, 2025, at 12:30 pm, after a mix-up with our reservation at a nearby restaurant, we decided to try Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria. At first, it didn’t seem particularly remarkable, but we were pleasantly surprised. Our waitress, whom I believe was named Lianne, was incredibly friendly and took the time to carefully explain the various menu options to us. The pizza was outstanding and truly reminiscent of what you’d find in southern Italy. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone seeking excellent service and an authentic Italian pizza experience.“

“Best Pizza ever!!“

“We had an amazing lunch, the service was excellent and the food was delicious. we'll definitely be back.“

“Mancini's is the best place for pizza in Whitby 'Hands Down'...changed from other places that took half the weight out of their product, like we wouldn't notice! We changed to Mancini's and won't go back!! Very clean and lovely family business, Thank you Mancini's !! Susan and Bruce Whitby“

“Brutal, service rather lack of, is absolutely horrible. Do not go unless you have a few hours! So poor.“

“Amazing pizza & Wings. Very Nice staff, i will definitely be supporting this business in the future. thank you Krave, for the amazing dinner“

“I had a fabulous experience here. I had been trying all afternoon to get a Pizza Pizza gift card and this was the only location that had one available. The person who looked after my request was very kind and apologetic that I had been to multiple locations that day. I decided to get a slice of veggie pizza as well while I was there. It was loaded with fresh veggies, the crust was excellent and it was delicious! Excellent food and customer service! Thank you again for your help!“

“Fresh Cooked Mouth Watering Pizza, Wings Broast and Burgers.“

“I visit about once a week, and the difference is obvious. The service is consistently warm, the food quality is always on point, and the team genuinely cares about hospitality. For a franchise, it has a rare small-business feel—people who take pride in what they do. We’re lucky to have them in our town“

“Head and shoulders above the alternative. Excellent restaurant, the fish and chips was amazing, taste and texture and presentation was excellent. $135 for 4 adults (soft drinks). Our waiter was perfectly attentive. Clientele were happy and friendly. Will definitely go back. Washrooms spotless, family/single washroom.“

“First time trying Benedict’s Pizzeria and it definitely won’t be our last.

We ordered the XL Greek Pizza and the XL Sweet Heat Pizza, and both were an easy 10/10. The quality of the ingredients, the flavour, and the amount of toppings were outstanding. Every slice was loaded, and you can tell they don’t cheap out.

We already knew there was going to be a bit of a wait, so we have zero complaints there. If you’re planning on going during a busy time though, I’d definitely recommend calling ahead.

Also, when the guy on the phone tells you the XL is a big pizza… listen to him. 😂 I thought, “How big could it really be?” These pizzas were absolutely massive. We definitely should’ve gone with the large because two XLs were way more food than we expected.

The prices are on the higher side at first glance, but once you actually see the size and quality, it makes a lot more sense. For comparison, if we went to Pizza Hut and bought enough pizza to equal what we got here, it would’ve been around four XL pizzas, which works out to about the same price for the same amount of pizza. You’re paying for quality and portion size, and in our opinion it’s absolutely worth it.

Highly recommend Benedict’s if you’re looking for amazing pizza. We’ll definitely be back!

Also, I can’t remember his name. The guy behind the counter on Tuesday June 30 around 8:30pm. Honestly he’s such a sweet soul and he was super helpful. Everything about this place is amazing!!“

“This is probably the best location to come to Boston pizza (Boston pizza Ajax). The food was so tasty. The best part of this Boston pizza is the service. There are so many great servers but the one server that served us was amazing. His name was (Saj). Definitely recommend!!!“

“Honestly, one of the best customer service experiences I’ve had at Domino’s! I came in just to pick up my order, and Ahmed Ali was incredibly friendly, polite, and welcoming. His attitude genuinely made my experience so much better. You can tell when someone really cares about making customers feel welcome, and Ahmed definitely does. He deserves recognition for his excellent customer service. Thank you, Ahmed!“

“pizzas are always fresh , vegetables are fresh their wings are cooked perfect , I recommend this place 💯.“

“Amazing food in whitby. Try steak on fries ,philly cheese steak Wings or pizza .“

“Caleb was an absolute sweetheart. I have a multitude of food allergies and he made the ordering process seamless. He went out of his way to ensure that none of my allergens were present and was quick about it too!
In general, excellent friendly service!“

“Just wanted to send a note of thanks. I ordered 12 pizzas last Friday for my husband's team at work. The pizzas were hot and delicious and you kept to our arranged pick up time. I was able to deliver the pizzas to the hungry group. I wasn't surprised by your exceptional product as we order from you for home all the time. Today some of them asked for the name of your business. Expect some new customers! -- Thanks again“

“Have been ordering from there since they opened and have never been disappointed. Best pizza hands down“

“I was graciously greeted with a warm smile and was treated with utmost respect during my visit. The food is delicious and delivered more quickly than expected. I cannot express my gratitude enough for the experience here at Pizzaville. They treat everyone as if they're part of the team“

“Fantastic pizza! Seriously so yummy. I had this with my girlfriends for a girls’ night and we all went back for seconds. The garlic cheese bread was amazing, and I loved the crust to dip in the sauce options. The portions and toppings were spot-on. Definitely recommend this place.“

“Wow amazing pizza and wings first time going here the wife and I were in the area and wanted to try a family run pizza place with all the good reviews we decided to try Comino's pizza and wings. the girl at the front welcomed us in with a big smile very nice we got a large pizza and wings so delicious so glad we stopped to try it definitely will be our go to place for pizza and wings. Very fast service.
Well came back again and they were closed he said dont worry he will make me the wings nothing but amazing service thanks again for staying open late definitely highly recommend this place“

“Drove all the way from Lakeland, FL to eat this pizza! My boyfriend, who is Canadian, said it's the best on the planet. He was right!!! Best I've ever had!! Even better than New York! 😍😎 Thank you so much for the amazing experience!😁“

“Great Service by Mukul!!!!

Tried the shawarma pizza, panzo roti, and poutine, and everything was delicious! Great flavour, generous portions, and everything tasted fresh and satisfying. Definitely a great spot for a tasty and filling meal. Will order again!“

“I’ve been coming here regularly, and it’s always a great experience. The staff are consistently friendly and greet you with a smile, the restaurant is always clean, and the pizza is always fresh and delicious. Highly recommend!“

“This spot is such a hidden gem! Easily some of the best Italian pizza in Oshawa — can’t believe more people aren’t raving about it.“

“I don’t usually write reviews, but after several visits to the Pizza Pizza location in Whitby, I genuinely felt this team deserved one. In a time when great customer service is becoming harder to find, this restaurant consistently delivers an experience that goes far beyond expectations.

First and foremost, the pizza is simply outstanding. Every order has been incredibly fresh, perfectly baked, and full of flavor. The crust strikes the ideal balance between crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, while the cheese is always generously layered and melts beautifully. The sauce has a rich, well-balanced taste that complements the toppings instead of overpowering them. Whether it’s a classic pepperoni, deluxe, veggie, or one of their specialty pizzas, every bite tastes like it was made with genuine care and attention.

What impressed me even more is the consistency. Many restaurants can make a great pizza once, but this location does it every single time. The quality never seems to fluctuate. The ingredients are always fresh, vegetables are crisp, meats are flavorful, and everything is evenly distributed across the pizza. It’s clear that the staff take pride in their work rather than simply rushing orders out the door.

The customer service is truly exceptional. Every staff member I’ve interacted with has been warm, friendly, patient, and professional. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with genuine smiles and positive attitudes. They take the time to answer questions, offer recommendations, and make sure every order is prepared exactly as requested. Even during busy hours, they remain calm, organized, and courteous to every customer.

One thing that really stands out is how much they care about customer satisfaction. If you have any special requests or dietary preferences, they listen carefully and make every effort to accommodate.“

“I love that Sbarro is back near me, remind me of many a trip to the mall. I just came here to say the Valley Center KS location rules 💜“

“It's been almost 10 years since I was last at an East Side Mario's but let me tell you. The service we received last night from Wiktoria and her team was absolutely outstanding! There was 18 of us celebrating my granddaughters 9th birthday. We had Wiktoria running around all night with refills, lots more bread, soup and salads and she always did it with a smile and was extremely quick. The price when the bill came was surprisingly cheap. The Thursday night deal/combo for 2 adults was like $50 bucks and was very delicious! We will be back again soon and a special shout out to the Manager for taking the time to come by to ensure we were satisfied with everything. It's great to see that some restaurants still take pride in the importance of exceptional service. Job well done East Side Mario's!!!“

“I always order from this location. I remember, I left my wallet there by accident...i live 30mins away....and they were closing ....but they waitied for me to come back after they closed. Staff is so friendly!! My go to pizza hut after a long day at work“

“Food was amazing. Creative, very favourable. Crust was delicious. Delivery was suppose to be 45 minutes and it came in 30 minutes. Very pleased overall. 5 stars“

“We ordered 12 xl pizzas tonight and I am pretty disappointed. One of our volunteers called with the number of slices we needed and instead of being honest, your store did the math with 8 slices in an XL pizza when there should be 12 and added a 12% tip without confirming first. We are a not for profit organization and this cost us over and beyond what it should have.

I messaged the owner who normally takes our order and he responded within 30 minutes to fix the issue. Although I found the store worker to have poor integrity, the owner was the very opposite.

The pizza itself was hot and yummy.“

“5 star They have affordable pizza with great taste. Highly recommended. cheap option is medium pepperoni pizza for $5 only. (All halal.)“

“Had the Large unlimited topping pizza for 13.99 and it was delicious. Glad we ordered it well done as it had the perfect crunch to the crust and bottom but they forgot to put onions on it as ordered. other then that, pizza was good, ready early (but I arrived early so it was perfect and I got a timely notification when it was finished). I had at lease 6 toppings on the pizza so they did a great job cooking a pizza with so many toppings (minus forgetting a topping lol)“

“Amazing all around. The staff here are pleasant and friendly. Quality of food is excellent. Restaurant is very clean. There’s plenty of space to sit down comfortably and eat. Best dominos location in Durham. Never disappoints! I highly recommend“

“10/10 would recommend!!!!“

“We ordered out from Navona Pizzeria Oshawa and we were so pleased with the quality of food. They have a variety of food that is made fresh on site. We have used delivery for a few orders. Both drivers are so nice and super fast. We have also done pick up and the owners are so friendly. The employees are so kind and very helpful. Our pizza was so happy with the food quality. We love the pizza, wings, lasagna, breadsticks and cheesecake.“

“Absolutely amazing pizza and wonderful service. The people here are so friendly, and the staff is incredibly welcoming and professional. The pizza is always fresh, delicious, and full of flavor. Easily one of the best pizza places in the Durham Region.
Highly recommended definitely a must-try if you’re in Oshawa! 🙌“

“Best Pizza in town! Friendly staff and good tasting Pizza. What else can you ask for when ordering a Pizza?“

“Night or day, I am always treated very kindly. Highly recommended - not just for highway truckers. Everyone is welcome. Under new management now with a lovely staff, I give them a top rating. Thanks for all that you do folks!“

“Fresh pizza, friendly staff, quick service — always the best!“

“One of the better pizza pizza stores. Pizza was cooked perfectly, with generous amount of fresh toppings evenly spreaded. I went before the scheduled pick up time, and they very nicely apologized and asked my to wait for a few more minutes. Also the location is great. I bought the pizza and wings combo and walked across the street and ate in front of the lake.“

“Made to order, all fresh ingredients 😍 you gotta try it!!“

“I would say it’s one of the good piza in the neighbourhood and top of all is the service. Wanna mention the one at the front cashier name Steve is the best . Always treat you best and once you place the order , he makes everything ready for you without asking , very quick and efficient.“

“I ordered during a street festival that I was a vendor at - and not only did the Oshawa location call to give a heads up about the event, they even hand delivered it to my booth and then even followed up to ask how it was. The food was incredible and the customer service is unmatched. Highly recommend! Will definitely be back soon“

“We ordered a donair pizza and a Mexican pizza. Mexican was delicious but The Donair pizza was absolutely superb. Sweet, creamy and delicious. I will be ordering this specific pizza again , in the future... I definitely look forward to trying their other specialty pizzas.“

“The pizza is always fresh, the ingredients taste high quality, and the crust has the perfect balance of crispiness and softness. The staff are friendly, my order is consistently accurate, and the service is fast. Great value for the quality, and it’s become one of my favorite places for pizza. Highly recommended!“

“Sat at the bar and had a wonderful dinner. Joel, the charismatic bartender was friendly, courteous and a wonderful ambassador for this Italian restaurant. Great selections on the menu, a tad expensive but worth it for great quality and service. Our go to spot for a night out.“