19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pickering

“Best Pizza ever!!“

“Honestly, one of the best customer service experiences I’ve had at Domino’s! I came in just to pick up my order, and Ahmed Ali was incredibly friendly, polite, and welcoming. His attitude genuinely made my experience so much better. You can tell when someone really cares about making customers feel welcome, and Ahmed definitely does. He deserves recognition for his excellent customer service. Thank you, Ahmed!“

“I found that the quality of the food here, has deteriorated. The food was too salty and the thin crust pizza dough tasted like pita.

Update: The manager did right by me and rectified the issue. Best pizza in Pickering. Thank you Domino's.“

“Amazing delicious pizza and staff is so friendly and welcoming . It’s made perfect with all the toppings. Thanks to make it perfect every time. Reason for me to go from Markham to Pickering for yummy pizza .“

“5 star They have affordable pizza with great taste. Highly recommended. cheap option is medium pepperoni pizza for $5 only. (All halal.)“

“Best spot to get pizza! Always fresh and delicious 🍕🍕“

“This Little caesars never dissapoints! Had an amazing freshly made veggie and pepperoni just now! lovveeeeddddd it! The service was really good! The manager was very polite and welcoming and helped me choose the best options available! <3 will definitely come back! great job!“

“Night or day, I am always treated very kindly. Highly recommended - not just for highway truckers. Everyone is welcome. Under new management now with a lovely staff, I give them a top rating. Thanks for all that you do folks!“

“I’m going to give some serious love to the potato bacon soup at East Side Mario’s because this one deserves it. It is extremely good. Rich, creamy, hearty and packed with that smoky bacon flavour, it’s exactly the kind of soup you want when you’re looking for something comforting and satisfying.

I’m a big fan of their soups in general, but the potato bacon is one I could very easily make a meal out of. Add the salad and bread, and you’ve got a pretty fantastic lunch without spending a ridiculous amount of money.

East Side Mario’s may be a chain, but they really do know how to make a good soup.“

“I have to give a huge shoutout to Dave at the Pickering Pizza Hut. He was absolutely fantastic.

I came in not really knowing what I wanted, and Dave was so patient and helpful. He made recommendations and even suggested some add-ons and specials, but what I really appreciated was that it never felt like he was trying to push a sale. It genuinely felt like he was trying to help me figure out what I would actually like. He really went above and beyond!

He has such a great attitude and is just really pleasant to deal with. He took the time to explain the different specials, including the ones available online, and was happy to walk me through everything. He was smiling, enthusiastic, and just genuinely seemed happy to be helping.

Even though I am closer to the Bowmanville location, the Pickering location has always been a consistently better experience!

Thank you Dave & team!“

“First off, Raj is consistently amazing. He makes my day, always treating me with the same friendliness and care. I never feel neglected with his service and always leave feeling satisfied with both the service and what I’ve ordered. The pizza is always INCREDIBLE!!!!! No matter what types of pizza I order, gourmet, meat lovers, Asiago chicken, chicken pesto, you name it, the quality always turns out better than I expected. This location has set the definitive high bar for me of all the other locations. Thank you so much Raj and the team!!!!!!!!!“

“We had just been saying last week that Pickering did not have good pizza options, well that all changed tonight! We ordered from Vis à Vis and boy was it good! Thin crust, wood oven pizza with delicious toppings. This will be our new regular for sure! Hope they continue to do well and will make sure my friends know about this place to make sure it stays open. Yum!“

“Amazing service.Siva and Harshad are very friendly and kind to the customers.They deserve recognition for their work and a raise too for their kindness.They actually made me believe humanity still exists in this worlf with their kindness and humbleness.I would definitely keep on visiting caesars and would higly recommend my friends about the pickering location“

“lovely establishment one of the best pizza novas I have visited, I am a loyal customer of many years with a great love for not just the delicious food but the great attitude from the staff particularly Joe great guy, great additude and vibes check this place out its worth the try.“

“Great location! Always will come back“

“Always a great experience at this location. The food is fresh,hot and prepared exactly how we ordered it. The staff is incredibly friendly,efficient,and the service is always fast. Easily one of the cleanest and most reliable spots around. Highly recommended!“

“I recently ordered this amazing pizza from Papa John’s, and it definitely hit the spot!

I tried a half-and-half pizza with two different toppings. One side had classic pepperoni and jalapeños — the perfect combo if you love a bit of spicy kick with your savory, cheesy bites. The other side had beef with green peppers and onions, giving it a more hearty, almost “steak and cheese” flavor that was super satisfying.

The crust was golden and had a nice chew, and the cheese was perfectly melted and stretchy. The toppings were fresh, generously spread, and full of flavor.

I also appreciated the signature pepperoncini on the side — a fun, zesty bonus that I always look forward to with Papa John’s pizzas.

Service was quick, and the pizza arrived hot and ready to eat. Overall, it made for a perfect comfort food night.

✅ Fresh, flavorful toppings
✅ Perfectly baked crust
✅ Quick, reliable service

If you’re craving a classic pizza experience with bold flavors and great quality, I definitely recommend giving Papa John’s a try. Can’t wait to order again and explore more combinations!“

“Ordered Bigfoot giant Pizza for a party. Pepperoni and veggie. Both were amazing. Much cheaper than the other pizza stores and they don’t even have giant pizzas like square boy pizza. Employees are friendly and polite. Enjoyed the pizzas. Definitely recommend others.“

“Here’s a sample review for Pizza Pizza:

“I recently tried Pizza Pizza, and it was a pretty satisfying experience overall. The pizza options are extensive, with a variety of toppings, crusts, and styles to choose from. I appreciate that they cater to different dietary needs with gluten-free, keto, and plant-based options. The crust was nice and crispy, and the toppings tasted fresh, which is always a plus.

The delivery was fairly quick, and my order arrived hot. However, I did feel that the sauce could use a bit more flavor; it was a bit bland for my taste. Also, the prices are reasonable for standard pizzas, though the specialty options can add up quickly.

Overall, I’d say Pizza Pizza is a solid choice if you’re looking for reliable pizza with plenty of options to customize. It’s“