23 Best Italian Restaurants near Caledon

“Best pizza! Wonderful staff!!!“

“Excellent food, excellent service! I would love to go back again to try the regular menu. I went on Valentine’s Day and it was a set menu.
While I’m giving them 5 stars for the quality, I was very taken aback that it was a set menu with no notice on their website or by email when I made my reservations. I never would have come if I had known as I don’t eat any seafood and the menu for the night was surf n turf, and it was also very much out of my price range.“

“Great food. Great view. Jamie the Canadian Brad Pitt is an excellent server. Quite a sense of humour“

“Pleasantly surprised at the great experience at East Side Mario’s tonight. Shout out to our server Skye who was incredible! She was friendly, attentive, fast, proactive and overall amazing. She was on point with our starters, drinks and our meals were served quickly. She had our refills to our drinks even before we asked. The food was also on point. Portions were good, food was perfectly seasoned and temperature was great. Overall really great time! Well done!“

“The food was delicious and the service was excellent! We had a table of 15 people, and everyone was very happy with their food, the service and the attention given to us by our servers. I would recommend Caledon Inn for any occasion you and your family would be celebrating!“

“I’ve been a few times and the food is ALWAYS fantastic! My critique is on the cleanliness of the restaurant. First off the table cloth was dirty this last time but whatever. The worst was when I was standing outside the restroom waiting my turn, I was looking at my surroundings and the wall that backs on to the kitchen was filthy and the sliding door for the kitchen had dust webs hanging above there. While in the restroom, right in front of the toilet in the corner was the garbage can and a very dusty & dirty looking fake flower arrangement. But then u look down and it is so dirty and dusty on the floor all around the flowers and garbage can. I couldn’t believe that it was so dirty. I can’t help but wonder now how clean is the kitchen?? Still love the food but I don’t think I’d eat in there anymore, just do takeout! I really hope they take the care to clean up a bit.“

“It takes a lot to completely satisfy me in any type of dining. I was however truly satisfied with my entire experience tonight at gustos ! Can’t wait to go again“

“It's been our favorite weekly stop for lunch for the past 20 years. Also their catering is the best. Wonderful service always with a smile.“

“I’ve ordered from Pizza Pizza multiple times, and it’s one of those places that you keep going back to because it just does the job right every time. It’s not just about the pizza—it’s the overall convenience, consistency, and value that make it stand out.What I like most is how simple and smooth the whole process is, whether you’re ordering online or in-store. The menu is easy to navigate, and there are plenty of options to choose from. You can go for a classic slice, build your own pizza, or try different sides depending on your mood. It’s perfect when you’re ordering for a group because everyone can find something they like.The pizza itself is always satisfying. The crust has a nice texture, not too thick or too thin, and the toppings are evenly spread. You can actually taste the freshness, and it doesn’t feel overly greasy like some other places. Their dipping sauces, especially the garlic one, really take the flavor to another level. also noticed that the staff handle things pretty professionally. Even when it’s busy, they stay organized and make sure orders are moving quickly. That kind of efficiency really matters, especially when you’re in a hurry or ordering late at night.
Delivery has been reliable too. Orders usually arrive on time, still hot, and properly packed. That consistency is a big reason why I trust this place more than others nearby.
Pricing is another big advantage. With all the deals and combo offers, it’s easy to get a good meal without spending too much. For students or anyone on a budget, it’s definitely a great option. Store is very neat and clean
Overall, Pizza Pizza may not be a fancy place, but it delivers exactly what it promises—good food, fast service, and great value. That’s what keeps me coming back.“

“It's a pretty good little spot for a quick slice. Especially their veggie.
Not usually where I go for a full order but if craving a quick slice to hold you over or just to fill a craving then it's pretty reliable.
Staff are always friendly. Place is small, more for takeout, but always seems pretty clean.“

“Wonderful experience! Got excellent service from SIMRAN. Staff are welcoming and friendly . Recommend me veggie pizza and it absolutely worth the money.
The place is nice and clean. Everything is well organized.
Definately come back!😊😊“

“We had an amazing time and absolutely fabulously tasty food. The staff were welcoming and friendly, and did I mention the food was terrific? We had slow braised lamb shank, lobster ravioli, veal parmigiana and a rigatoni. Omg so good! Can’t wait to try some of the other stuff on the menu.“

“I Recently visited and had a incredible experience. Tasty food and great service.“

“Ordered two xl pizzas last night, 1 butter chicken and 1 tandoori paneer.
Requested Regie to be generous with the toppings because some locations like to skimp out on them.
But to our delight, everything was great. Our family loved the pizzas. Will definitely be ordering from here everytime.“

“I have tried so many pizzas in this area but none compare to the quality and taste of Pizza Pizza. (especially this location). There’s a girl named Vipan, she helped me to create a cutomized Veggie Pizza which I have never tried before. The pizza was cooked to perfection and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Now, every weekend I order pizza from this location. Highly recommend!“

“Very good restaurant. Varied menu. Food is always hot whether you are able eat inside or pick up. Staff is very friendly. Service is quick.“

“The food the staff the experience is top notch. A true taste of Italy in Bolton village. The hot table has incredible selection with good portions and the upmost care to taste and freshness. The coffe and sweets also are fabulous no matter what your taste is they have you covered. A staple anytime I am in town.“

“The customer service was top-notch at Sandalwood location . The staff were friendly and attentive, and my order was ready right on time. The delivery service was equally impressive, with my pizza arriving hot and exactly as I ordered.

Overall, Pizza Hut continues to be my go-to spot for pizza night. Great food, great service, and always a satisfying experience!“

“Had a very pleasant experience, a big thanks for pizza attendant NAVDEEP at store. She was very kind and looked very hard working. It always nice to see someone working so hard and treat customers with such respect. Thanks for the wonderful service.“

“We recently ordered from them for our school graduation ceremony and the service was outstanding! The food was fresh, appetizing and exactly as ordered. They exceeded our expectations. Will be a repeat customer for sure, well done!! We ordered from Giselle at the Bovaird and Torbram location and she was an absolute sweetheart to deal with and went above and beyond!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5-Star Review

Pizza Pizza never disappoints! The pizza is always hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings, and the crust has that perfect balance of crispy and chewy. Great value for the price, fast service, and lots of options to choose from—whether you’re craving something classic or a little different. It’s my go-to spot when I want reliable, tasty pizza. Highly recommend! 🍕“

“Everything … love the breads, the coffee and fresh vegetables“

“Best pizza pizza“