15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Crystal Beach

“Friendly owner. Delicious pizza.“

“Food was excellent and reasonably priced. Very nice staff! We had the blooming onion and it was very very good! We will be back!“

“First time there. My daughter had the Smokey Eggplant Curry and it was outstanding, I had the Smoked Salmon with Goat Cheese which was incredible. The service is out of this world, and the atmosphere is delightful! If there were ten stars to give, The Lighthouse would surely deserve that.“

“first time and I tell you the pizza was so good and the favor awesome wings were big and delicious ty seeya again“

“Had a couple of their beauties yesterday. The idea was to have a nibble on the way home and finish AT home - sons of b's were so fantastic we barely made it out of the lot before launching into the rest! Awesome job guys, we'll be back! we had the meat lovers and the margherita #sogood“

“We generally avoid chains/franchises, especially when it comes to pizza but we have to say that a recent pie from Domino's was excellent. Certainly not the best pizza we have ever had, but based on the friendly service and value for money, the experience was A+.“

“Ordering online is super easy and I am not a techy person! It was really neat that I could see my order every step of the way and know when it was on its way to be delivered. Loved the option that the pizza could be cooked extra no other restaurant app has this and adding the tip for the driver made things much easier as well when I paid online - loved this. Those lava cakes are so amazing we order them every time and we are obsessed with the spicy pineapple chicken bites. Such good food and the driver was such a nice guy.“

“Jay went above and beyond for me. I go to this location fairly often to order a personal cheese pizza for lunch. I parked my truck and took my time heading into the store. When I went to the counter to order, Jay had already prepared it and put it in the oven. I only waited for two minutes to receive my pizza. Great job being proactive, Jay. It's the little things that matter.“

“Good pizza...crust and sauce. Friendly staff.“

“A friend and I had an after church lunch at the Barrel this past Sunday The food as always was great Our server was patient and gracious. We who are older appreciate that kindness greatly.“

“I had an amazing experience at Papa’s Pizza and Subs. You can truly taste that the pizza is made with love, the crust was perfectly baked, the sauce had great flavor, the toppings were fresh and generous. Every bite felt like it was prepared with care and pride. Loved it!!

The chicken wings were just as impressive. Juicy on the inside and tossed in flavorful sauce that hit the spot. And the subs?!! Absolutely one-of-a-kind. You won’t find subs like these anywhere else. They’re packed with quality ingredients, made fresh, and built to satisfy.

What really makes this place stand out is the owner. He’s polite, respectful, and genuinely cares about his customers. You can tell he takes pride in his business and values the community he serves. Great customer service like that goes a long way.

If you’re looking for delicious food, generous portions, fair prices and a welcoming atmosphere, Papa’s Pizza and Subs is the place to go. Highly recommend supporting this local gem. I’ll definitely be coming back! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Bella’s in Crystal Beach is hands down one of the best local spots around. 🍕 The pizza is always fresh, loaded with toppings, and the crust is perfectly cooked every time.

And don’t even get me started on the wings and pastas, absolutely exceptional. Everything is made with care and you can really taste the quality.

A huge shoutout to my new bestie and owner, Peter, who makes everyone feel so welcome the second you walk in. You can tell how much pride he takes in the place, and it shows in both the food and the atmosphere.

Great pizza, amazing wings and pasta, great vibes, and even better people. If you’re anywhere near Crystal Beach, Bella’s is a must! 🙌“

“Good Meat Lovers Pizza!Good Tasting Honey Garlic Chicken Wingsand Medium WingsWorth a visit! Easy + Ready set Go Pizza made ahead or order to your style, tastes.Prompt + Affordable priceThey have a whole menu to suit your budget+delicious tasting crazy bread or stuffed with cheese your crust.Try it! You will like it!Takeout only

Vegetarian options: Gluten-free crust availableVeggie options for toppings

Parking: Plenty of free parkingWheel chair ♿ access

Kid-friendliness: Kid -friendly, it's a pizza placeReady set Go, Made ahead PizzaOr order to preference,taste.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible,lots of space to move“

“Absolutely amazing vegetarian pizza made by the old lady , had whole different taste from other pizza pizza , if u r in fort erie must visit, nd sides were also quite remarkable!!( cauliflower bites, onions rings , fries , jalapeños poppers ) must try yall !!!“

“first time and hands down, the best damn pizza in ft. erie!!! You now have a lifer for your food.“