19 Best Italian Restaurants in Richmond Hill

“Absolutely fantastic experience. The food, service, and atmosphere were all top-notch. Highlights were the San Marzano Spaghetti, Margherita, Spinach & Artichoke Dip, and the Chocolate Panettone Bread Pudding. The Toscana Kale salad was very good, though I'd skip the mozzarella ball. Our server, Stang, was exceptional. One guest had a peanut allergy, and Stang went above and beyond to ensure everything was prepared safely, with the manager personally overseeing the pasta. The attention to detail and genuine care made the experience feel truly special. Excellent food, outstanding service, and a great vibe overall. Highly recommend.“

“Excellent service (Reza), exceptional food, lovely atmosphere. Soho martini - amazing!“

“Maria's Kitchen is one of the best best diners I have ever savored in Toronto. Going into the restaurant, the ambience is so cozy. The music volume was optimal. The service was good, friendly and comfortable. The food was amazing, in which the taste is so delicious; and the portion is reasonably large. My family has listed Maria's Kitchen as our regular dining.“

“Tried this for the first time and enjoyed their pizza. Will be back to try other menu items.“

“Great service friendly people Thank you“

“it was a good experience.“

“It’s rare to come across someone who truly cares about the customer experience the way Ali does. His professionalism and positive attitude made my visit even more enjoyable. I’ll definitely be coming back — and I hope to be served by Ali again!
Highly recommend this place, especially if you get the chance to have Ali as your server.“

“We had a large party in the Newmarket location recently and the service and food were excellent! The owner and staff were extremely accommodating to our needs, including being patient with the many children in our group. The food was plentiful and delicious. We will 💯 be back!!“

“This is my family's go to restaurant because it fits everyone's preferences. They have a seperate vegan menu with creative options. It's a spacious yet cozy setting and it really does feel like the family is sitting down together for a traditional Italian meal!“

“The owner was so friendly when we walked in the door. He gave us lots of time to look ofer the extensive menu and gave us a great education lesson on his fancy pizza oven. The pizza was fast and delicious and the garlic dipping sauce I could eat on its own!“

“The pizza is good, I’ve even seen puffed up crusts with good browning. It’s definitely much better than other Pizza Pizzas I’ve been to, which makes this place an even better value.

It’s always been ready for pickup within 15-20 minutes, and we’ve only had 1 or 2 issues in the last decade.“

“My family and I found this delicious restaurant on Uber Eats. I am so picky and I don't like any of the chain pizzas. We ordered the party size meat lovers for 2 adults and 2 large boys. I had one piece (since sadly I wasn't feeling the best). I need to order it again so I can enjoy more pieces. Yummy, local, small business - great all around“

“The store is nicely and clean. Convenient location also. The staff are friendly and quick. Enough seating space is there to sit comfortably if you want to dine in.

The food is consistently good—not just the pizzas. Their wings, garlic bread, panzerottis, and sides are fresh and tasty.

The store remain open till late, after midnight which helps to satisfy late night cravings. Ample parking space is there in the plaza.“

“pizza kits! great idea and a wonderful way for the community to help a small business :)“

“I recently visited this Pizza Pizza location for a quick dinner and I was pleasantly surprised by how good everything was. The girl taking orders was very nice and helpful. She made sure to repeat our order to confirm and everything came out perfectly. The pizza was hot, cheesy and well-balanced with sauce and toppings. The garlic dip was a perfect match. The store was spotless and the overall vibe was friendly and relaxed. Great service, great food . I’ll absolutely be returning.“

“This chain is based in the Vancouver area and has not too many locations in the GTA. Fresh Slice is underrated, and I love that their typical cheese slice is the creamy cheese with alfredo. It’s a nice break from having typical tomato sauce on any other pizza I have. Overall, very good experience yesterday for my lunch.“

“Pizza Pizza at Elgin Mills is easily the best one around. The pizza is always fresh, and made just right every single time. I actually travel past two other Pizza Pizza locations just to come to this one — that’s how much better the quality and service are here.“

“I got a delivery order from this location, it arrived on time and food was very delicious and warm. The delivery driver Ismael Zarei, was very kind, very polite and very respectful and he really cared about the customer happiness and customer service I would highly recommend this location.“

“Used to hate Pizza Hut cause I thought it was trash based on old experiences. However, this one is right by my house and I saw a sign for $2 personal pizzas. Reluctantly gave it a shot, and it was fire. I guess it’s true as they say “you can’t out pizza the hut.”“