10 Best Sandwich Shops in Bethlehem

“The Wooly mammoth is delicious“

“Just found this place and literally best hoagie I’ve ever had!! The chips are great, the desserts are great, music is upbeat and the staff is super friendly, funny, and helpful!! The place is kept clean and you watch them make the food. This is definitely my new hoagie home!!!“

“I finally made it to Eli's original steaks and subs... what a sin to have waited so long! these are the pinnacle of steaks in the valley, they rival the best on Philly for sure! strongly recommend. Eli's basic steak sandwich is phenomenal, and those made with the in-house ribeye are better yet. succulent meat, savory spices, and the bread is unbeatable do yourself a favor and get there a soon as possible if you like a great sandwich!“

“Wrap’d Tight Fully Loaded is a gem of a lunch spot. Everything is exactly what you want it to be. The food is fresh, flavorful, and actually fully loaded like the name says. The portions are generous, the ingredients taste high quality, and every bite just hits. But honestly, what makes this spot stand out even more is the owner. She is an absolute sweetheart, truly just a kind, genuine person who makes you feel so welcome the second you walk in. You can tell she really cares about both the food and the people she’s serving, and that kind of energy makes the whole experience even better. Great food, great service, and a genuinely sweet angel running the place. I will definitely be back.“

“Une véritable prestation de qualité. Nous avons eu l’occasion de le recevoir chez nous, au sein de TACQUET INDUSTRIES, et ce fut un vrai délice. Une personne en or, communicative, qui apporte une véritable joie de vivre. La cuisine est d’une excellente qualité, aussi généreuse que raffinée. Je recommande vivement cette expérience inoubliable : une prestation tout simplement extraordinaire 🤘🏼😎“

“Went to the new Bethlehem location for lunch today. The line was EXTREMELY long and the staff members were absolutely rocking it. They were extremely efficient, nice, and making a great product. I was blown away at how quick the line went and how much pride they put in the sandwiches. Will definitely be back!“

“Nice , clean place—I ordered the meatball sub on Italian, with provolone. The sandwich artist was friendly & made my sub nice & saucy just like I asked! It was very delicious, meatballs very tender & sauce was cooked well and very tasty! I was hesitant to order it because I’m very fussy about my sauce, and it was excellent! I will definitely return!
Also, it was nice and quiet, and I was able to read and do some puzzling while I sat. Thank you!“

“Fast friendly service. Good food and free wifi. Caution with this cooler weather, it can get cold in there. Felt like there may have been a delivery driver with the back door propped open for some time while I was there. It was fine when I first arrived, but shortly after there was a chilly draft despite the front door being closed.“

“Johnny’s is very standard. Not sure that it lives up to all the hype but I’d grab breaky here again.Edit: I actually just had their veggie cream cheese and it might've changed my life forever (I've never liked veggie cream cheese). Stuff is liquid gold“

“I like their hoagies and customer service, but the portions of meat and sometimes the quality of the bread are my main issues.

A primo-sized cheesesteak costs around $16 after tax, but they only give you a small portion of steak on your sandwich: you bite into more bread than meat (as shown in the photo). I think the amount of meat they provide in relation to the price is not worth it. The cheesesteak does taste good though, and other sandwiches like the Sharp Italian do have good amounts of meat.

With the bread, it can be stale and very chewy. The quality of the bread distracts from the hoagie’s taste. I’ve noticed if you order near opening, the bread is softer, but mid-afternoon is when I taste the staleness. The quality can be inconsistent.

Despite these concerns, the dining room always remains very clean and welcoming, and the staff are friendly. My only critiques would be the generosity with ingredients and the freshness of bread, especially given the cost.“