11 Best American Restaurants near Carrolltown

“This is a very small and a little run-down place, but my husband and I loved it. We have only gone two times so far, but did not have a bad experience either time. The first time was just my husband and I. The waitress recommended the Buffalo chicken fries, so we got them. We each got a burger (which they get locally), and since they come Ala cart, we figured why not. These fries came out on a huge platter smothered in chicken, cheese, and so much gooey goodness. They were AWESOME! We could not finish since we also ordered breaded mushrooms and cheese curds as well. No idea there would be so many fries. They are very good reheated too...surprising for fries. The burgers were also excellent. Fresh made patties, not frozen. This place is definitely a hidden gem. We took my son this past weekend, and he loved it as well.“

“The absolute best salad I have had in my 52 years of life…..and I tasted the 2 wings sauces that my husband ordered…..magnificent!!! By and far the best wings I have had locally…..perfect.flavor andcrispness!Give this place a try!!! You will NOT be disappointed!!!“

“Requires reservations! The dining area is beautiful and small but spread apart far enough you have privacy, it's a very cozy environment. The food was amazing! Very fresh, the is fine dining, the servers were very nice and helpful! The owners were great! I can't stop thinking about the food. It was seriously so good. It was our first night out after our daughter was born in July 2022. We were exhausted parents of two looking to have a nice dinner. To my surprise, this was also the location of my proposal. They brought out champagne and this place will forever be my favorite place. I may not stay in Pennsylvania forever but it'll always be my favorite restaurant“

“We ate here when we were passing through. To say we were pleasantly surprised is an understatement. The food was fantastic and our waitress was amazing. We clearly wandered in just as some kind of major event was kicking off. In spite of that, the service was swift and accurate, and the manager/owner even wandered by to make sure our meal as good (it was). Everything from the appetizer to dessert was great. Unfortunately, we aren't likely to be back in that area, but if we are, we're eating here again.“

“Going home just doesn't feel like it used to compared to just a few short years ago for me. There's a number of reasons for that, but this isn't that type of review. One of the things I miss the most is the home cooked meals I would look forward to. Recently, those meals are far and few in between. On a recent trip my brother and I had decided to give this place a try. He had been here before, but this would be my first time. We ventured over and walked in. There wasn't much of a crowd and we were seated with menus in hand in no time. I did a once over of the menu quickly and spotted meatloaf. I don't know what it is about meatloaf on a menu, but I have to give it a try each and every time I see it. Our server was quick to take our order and we were just now going to wait until things started to arrive. I looked around the space as we waited and took it in. This place really does give off a small town vibe with the decor. My brother told me that the space is bigger when they use the other dining room as well. With it being not so busy, they had no need to use that part of the space. Unlike the one reviewer that said they get hit with a smell when they come in here, the only smell I got hit with was the food being prepared. We both started off with a side salad. It was a decent size, but I did have to pick through it a bit as there was some undesirable pieces of lettuce floating in the salad. They give you ample salad dressing so you can go all in or add as you go. Wasn't anything special, lettuce, tomato, onion and your dressing. Nice way to start off the meal. Then the main dish arrived. Like I said, I went with the meatloaf which came with two sides and a roll. For my sides I went with mashed potatoes and my choice of vegetable, corn. The choice of vegetable varies on what they have that day. You could tell that there were some shortcuts taken on some of the plate, but not the meatloaf. With gravy over the meatloaf and mashed potatoes it was the way to go. The meatloaf was seasoned nicely, it was overpowered by peppers or onions, it was just right. I did the Pennsylvania thing in me with the mashed potatoes and corn. I would take a glob of the potatoes and stick it in the corn to eat it. Not sure if anyone else does this, but I find it easier and sometimes the combination is spot on. The addition of the sweet corn to the potatoes gives is a buttery taste. While we were noshing away at our meal we got a bacon cheeseburger with fries to go for my Dad waiting at home. They cooked it at just the right time. As we were finishing up the meal I saw them placing the to go order near the counter. Almost perfect timing. Paying was easy and we headed out for the night.“

“Had to take my dog to the Ebinsburg hospital for surgery, which is about and hour and a half away from home. We were recommended to go here for breakfast. The parking lot was full when we got there and just then you knew it must be good food. We both got the 2x2x2 breakfast and it was very good. The food was cooked perfectly and had that home cook feel to it. We didn't have to wait long and the service was great, prices definitely reasonable. If I'm ever back up this way again, I'll be sure to stop back in again. Highly recommend!“

“I should have started with chocolate cake.This spot is what you want a family restaurant to be: super clean, big menu with family favorites, generous portions, friendly service, dessert.My meal: spaghetti and mballs piled high and topped w/ 2 fried eggs. Garlic buttered texas toast. Salad. Oj.Food came fast and done right.My only regret: not enough room for the most important part. Dessert.Enjoy every minute with your fam and friends.Cheers.“

“Been here multiple times and everytime it's been great. The food is great and the service is pretty good. Their wings are what keep me coming back. Try the cousin wolfies wings, you won't regret it. They got pool table and the bar is usually pretty alive too.Parking: Got a big Ole gravel parking lot right next to the building“

“TRUCKERS. STOP HERE.More details seen belowTry their Reuben sandwich. Just do it. Best Reuben I have ever had to date. I rate everyone on that sandwich. First place I've ever decided to give full marks. Corned beef 10/10 saurkraut 10/10 melty Swiss cheese 10/10 red/white rye swirl bread is peak reuben, 10/10 thousand island dressing was perfect, even as a prepackaged brand that is applied by the customer. 10/10. Served hot and with great homestyle fries (bottomless ones no less) the whole meal is great. At a price of about 15 dollars for the platter, i don't think it can be beaten. I'd have willingly paid 25 for this meal. They could charge prime steak prices for this meal and it would be well within reason. But they don't. It's cheaper than a big Mac meal in some places. The truck parking is great, the area quiet, plenty of light and room. Not far off the beaten path and not hard to get into. As a Trucker, this place couldn't be better. Clean restrooms great food great prices and a wonderful mountain view sunset. I'll be stopping here every time I come through these mountains from now on.Parking: Plenty of room all around. Good maneuverability. Easy to get into and out of. Good lighting.“

“Personally I always get delivery and my delivery guy is the bomb. Really funny, fast delivery and the Stromboli is PHENOMENAL. Not a fan of the pizza but only because it's not the type of sauce+cheese combo I like. Wings are EVEN BETTER. Really crispy and awesome sauces. All for really great prices? In this economy?? Absolutely great. I'll order from Young's till the day I die lol.“

“One of the best Strombolis in Central PA if not the best. I get the Italian Stromboli every time I'm there and it never disappoints. Really big for a "small" and great price. A small will easily feed 2 people. Take out or eat in its always awesome Boli!“