31 Best Italian Restaurants near Dallastown

“Parma Pizza is an absolute gem! From the moment you step in, you're greeted with friendliness from the staff. But what truly sets Parma apart is not just their delicious food, but also the incredible dedication of owner Darren to the community. Whether it's supporting local events or simply going the extra mile to ensure everyone leaves with a smile, Darren's commitment shines through. And let's not forget- the pizza! Parma Pizza is more than just a restaurant; it's a place where great food and community come together. Highly recommended!“

“Had a great night at Victors. Food was outstanding and the service was impeccable. They seemed to check on us at the most appropriate times. The drinks were delicious and hard to drink just one. Here you pay for what you get!! I recommend this place for either couple night or with a group of friends.“

“This was our first time here since the new owner took over. The reviews were mixed, so we took a chance. I am so glad we did. The subs we ordered were over the top, full of meat, and very flavorful, especially with the smoked bacon added.We also ordered the fried mushrooms, originally thinking they were expensive, but once we received the order, the order was more family sized, and the marana sauce served with it was very flavorful.I highly recommend thus place“

“I live in Maryland and was visiting a friend in the area. Wanted pizza, found this place on google and it was close, so we decided to try it. We ended up getting strombolis. The staff was amazing, and the food was outstanding! Very reasonably priced and giant portions! We already decided to come back next time I visit and we're trying the pizza lol. We ate inside and the staff was very nice and personable. Highly recommend!Parking: Plenty of parking“

“Our family loves Pizza al Bacio! My son's favorite salad is their grilled chicken salad. And their bread is the best we've had. My family usually also gets the mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, pizza, and stromboli. We always do take out because we prefer to eat at home, but the shop owners and workers are friendly, and our food is hot and ready quickly. We highly recommend Pizza al Bacio for casual Italian food!“

“We truly enjoyed every thing about this restaurant. The service was exceptional and the food was fresh, homemade and absolutely delicious!! The ambiance was welcoming and relaxing. We would definitely recommended this restaurant. If you haven't been there or got food from there you should!!“

“I stumbled into this place because I had some time to kill. So cute inside. Warm and cozy. Everyone was friendly. Really liked the atmosphere. It’s a pizza place you want to hang out in. Food good too!! Everything well stocked and it was clean!!“

“Came in as a walk in for a large group and they were more than willing to do what they could to seat us in a reasonable amount of time. Gladly, our group shrank significantly, and they still did all they could to make our late dinner very pleasant.“

“Always love this restaurant, excellent homemade, quality food. Great service every time. It's so nice to go to a restaurant that is not a chain and have excellent food consistently. I love that they have freezer food you may purchase for food prep in a pinch .“

“We love Vincenzo's! Every single person that we have encountered is so very pleasant. They are our "Go To" pizza and sub shop from now on. Their food is very good and we are appreciative of the superb customer service. This is what life and love for one another is about, being kind and respectful of one another. Bravo Vincenzo's!“

“We visited MexItaly during a bus tour fundraiser for the American Cancer Society and had the best time! The quick service, unique space, and friendly staff made for an incredible experience. It can be hard to manage that many people at once but their team did a fantastic job and we were so appreciative of them accommodating our group. We will certainly be back again and would recommend it to anyone!“

“Amazing family. They remember faces when you come in often enough. Treats everyone like family. They pour their love into their food which always comes out amazing. Andrew and Anna are the greatest around. Their service is phenomenal and they always rise above my expectation. There's always good vibes when me and my fiancé walk in and we're always happy to see them. we practically consider them as family because they always help us out.“

“First time ordering from here. Food was delivered within 30 minutes. Fair prices. I can tell you the crab pretzel was awesome!! Nacho cheese fries were great too and have a little spice to them. We liked everything we received and will definitely order from here again ?“

“I never leave reviews but I was pleasantly surprised with my experience. We ordered delivery for dinner in a pinch and it was so easy to order online, the delivery driver was super nice & sweet. The food was even better than what I was expecting and great quality! Very satisfied and will definitely order again!“

“Grab takeout from here all the time! Good food that's worth the price!Parking: A small parking lot that fills up quickly, but usually has spots available.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking spots.“

“I've been coming here for years and the owner and I have been friends since high school! The food, drink menu, and atmosphere are superb! I usually get the Italian Stromboli and my husband loves their cheeseburger sub. I've had lots the other items on the menu and you can't go wrong! Friendly service, clean bathrooms, this is a 5 star experience! Thanks Vinny and the rest of the crew at Golden Crust! You guys rock!❤️“

“Shame that we were only here on a visit. This place would be a regular stop for sure. Very comfy ambiance. The wait staff was very friendly. The food was out of this world. Plenty to take home and not at all pricey.Dietary restrictions: Most veggie options can be made vegan.“

“Always a small shop like this in towns. Pizza was great and price as well but not a dine in place.Vegetarian options: NoneParking: Street if pickup most people don't pay to parkKid-friendliness: Would recommend for takeout and pickupWheelchair accessibility: None“

“Yum! Visiting town for business and had to try this. Very good. Quality of food is excellent! Variety of pizza hot and fresh. They’ll make one if they don’t already have the variety. Bread sticks are delicious, everything was! Customer Service was top notch, all employees friendly and smiling. Troy was very friendly and informative when I checked in for a table. Price was a value. Would visit again when in the area. Give it a try you’ll be glad you did!Kid-friendliness: There were many kids here. Very kid friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Open spaces between tables.“

“My partner got the best Bolognese he says he's ever had, and my Pumpkin fettuccine(sans sage) was extraordinary. Our server recommended a great wine and we finished with panna cotta for dessert. Really a stellar experience and I Highly recommend.“

“I'm extremely lucky to live in the apartment building right beside this place so I've tried a lot of their menu. Great food, always with very friendly service. I tried the cheese supreme on a whim and... Y'know that pizza in A Goofy Movie (or maybe the sequel) that is so ooey-gooey with cheese and just looks so perfect that you know it couldn't possibly exist in real life? That's what their cheese supreme is like. Also try the baklava.“

“Returned to our old haunts and ordered. a long time favorite: "ham boats" plus a margarita pizza. Ham boats were delicious... a simple sub sandwich (see my photo) with ham & cheese, and a few "Fixin's, slightly toasted....yum. Pizza was just OK. Crust was crispy but really lacked any distinctive flavor....sauce was same. Toppings were fair. (You can kinda "see" what I mean in my photo). Filling. Next time will probably just stick to the ham boats... Always a winner.“

“Presto South York, my new favorite Presto. Matthew and the zoodles are the reason I keep coming back. He knows customer service, always polite and engaging. Love the recommendations, so far every suggestion has enhanced the meal. The zoodles and sun dried tomatoes are a must. Go try them out, they are open, you won't be disappointed!“

“To start, they were very polite on the phone, and made sure to repeat the order back to ensure it was correct.I was greeted with smiles and a very positive attitude as soon as I walked in, which not many places seem to do anymore. Both ladies working there made it an awesome experience.I ordered a large pepperoni, a California cheese steak and a order of fries. Everything was very well made, exactly how I wanted it. The pizza had great flavor and they weren't stingy with the pepperoni. The fries were crispy and plentiful. My sub was above average but not the best I've ever had, the lettuce tasted a little old and it could have used some more meat, but nonetheless it was good.I would recommend Marcello's over any other pizza shop in York.“

“This place is a great lunch spot in a place with a ton of fast food options. The food is so fresh, always. They have a half sub and fries for $6.50 or something like that at lunchtime and it's a heck of a deal. I've eaten several of their subs, right now I'm enjoying a top tier Italian sub and it's outstanding. The customer service on the phone is wonderful and the gentleman who answers speaks so clearly and kindly without making you feel like he's being slow with you. Just an all around great lunch spot!“

“This is one of those great little hole-in-the-wall bars that makes York a great place it is a little small bar that's always there and always open the staff is awesome and the owner is a great guy this is one of those places that's a rare gem good cheap beers great pool tables good place to just kick back and have a good time!“

“So, this has been our go-toplace for the last six months. Their fried mushrooms are out of this world, and their salads are delcious. Pizza are great as well.We always get delivery, and the gentleman that has delivered has been the same and is nice, professional, and nothing but polite when he delivers.This place is running on all cylinders and a must!“

“I only went here because it looks so old school...like places I remember happily from my youth. I've only had two cheesesteaks from here and they were perfectly wrapped and absolutely satisfying. Seriously, my favorite cheesesteak. I just moved to Columbia and they're maybe a block from me. Thank God.“

“This place was really good. The pizza and service was good. However, the lasting impression that I came away with was the quality of the workers and staff there. They weren't overly bubbly but they seemed happy to be there and happy to serve us.“

“Yesterday was our last time ordering from Sal's. We have had issues for the past year. I'm very disappointed because Sal's used to be my favorite restaurant for over a decade. However, I will not be suggesting your restaurant anymore. Our pizza was dry and burnt in the crust, the salad was bad, the chicken on it was also dry and had no flavor .. no dressing was packed in the bag, Additionally, the buffalo chicken wrap had watered down sauce buffalo sauce and maybe blue cheese dressing??? Not a crumble. The whole wrap was a soggy mess. It was a weekday order...early evening, not a busy time.“

“So we are moved here from Buffalo NY almost 3 years ago. So hard to find great wings in p.a. we had noticed parma posted they got a Char pit. Suggested char bbq wings and she said they would and did an amazing job. Reminded me of being back in Buffalo. Thank you Mandy and the rest of the staff there.“