50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Finleyville

“POSITIVE - This is an amazing location for a variety of outdoor lifestyles both Male & Female and also kid friendly to enjoy. They host Car shows, Bike Nights, live band and many others for great photo opportunities and social media tags. The food is good and reasonably priced however it is a "CASH ONLY" business. So be sure to stop at an ATM before arriving. Alcohol is reasonably priced also.There parking lot is massive and every event I attend has been packed. So if you are tired of indoor restaurants or just want to experience a fun outdoor adventure. Tiki is the place to be.NEGATIVE - They need to have a lot more shaded seating [preferably away from the stage]. It's a hit or miss that I and as many others are forced to stand, holding and eating our food & drinks because many customers just place purses and other items on the chairs & tables like some deck chairs at some resort then take off. Due to lack of seating, events do not last very long. (2 or 3 hours) than everyone leaves standing too long.Bring Ear Plugs. Noone does a sound check and more often than not the live bands play at a volume heard across the highway for no good reason. Another reason many people only stay for 30min to an hour.Kid-friendliness: The car shows and bike nights are great events to get kids outside and marvel at historical machinery, socialize and get fresh air.Parking: Massive parking lot. Most see to understand. Every event I've attended also has been free parking.Wheelchair accessibility: Outdoor location on more or less relatively flat surfaces. They do have at least 1 wheelchair accessible Porta Potty.“

“I just wanna write a review after tonight's experience. we called multiple places to find out that they were all closed. Called Vocellis and was told it would be 1.5 hour, only one delivery guy. we ordered and waited over 2 hours. the food was hot and the employees were polite. the young kid that delivered the pizza was very nice.“

“Omg the food is sooo GOOD my 10 year old son and I started looking around the neighborhood to see if we could spot an apartment to rent ! No joke !! Delicious !!!!!!! Please bulld where i live.. Western NY ! Im writing to shark tank players on Twitter to INSIST they help franchise this gemstone of a restaurant ! lol. ?“

“I had to see what all of the hype was about this place and on Thursday night I ordered a Sicilian pizza… WOW! Top #2 best pizzas I have tasted! Service was great, friendly folks, and for the price my family and I took about 2 days to finish! New favorite local pizza shop hands down!“

“Easily the best pizza I've had in Pittsburgh! I'm from NY and I've been looking everywhere for the perfect slice. This is it. Ingredients are all made in-house and it shows. We just finished our order and I already can't wait to go back. I don't review much on yelp but you all need to know about this place!!!“

“First time ordering from here yesterday, and happy to say we found our new go to place for pizza! Very friendly and helpful staff. Love the great directions on the take and bake. Everything was delicious. Already looking forward to the next time!“

“Spoonwood is a great spot for just about any outing. Great selection of beer and a nice variety of food options. The restaurant has a nice open layout with outdoor seating available in the nice months. We've been here a few times and always seem to have friendly and personable servers which makes a nice evening. I'd rate the place higher but I do feel the prices are a bit too high.“

“We tried Antonio’s for the first time tonight. We ordered a deep dish pizza with pepperoni and the general tso’s chicken pizza. Both pizzas looked and tasted amazing. I don’t find many places that put fried chicken on pizza, so I appreciate the unique menu items. This style and quality of food is exactly what we were looking for. We will definitely be back.“

“Food is incredible! Truly, one of the South Hills hidden gems. Will definitely be back. Lots of people ordering pick up also, so that’s always an option. Probably one drawback though, to making sure in-house customers are taken care of promptly. There were a decent amount of people, so expect to wait a little bit. I believe they’re hiring servers though! So, check out Bee’z Bistro; you won’t be disappointed. And, ask for their specials menu!“

“Ordered a white pizza with tomatoes and traditional pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Both excellent pizzas for a great price. The white pizza actually had a good amount of tomato on it. That rarely happens at other pizza shops. Keep it up Pizza Al's!“

“I have had the good fortune to be a customer of Fioris for over 40 years! My ex husband worked at the Brookline location when he was a teenager and Fiori and Pepino were family friends. I have lived in several places and have tried hundreds of pizza shops in my lifetime and I can honestly say that nothing beats Fioris, not even Via Napoli at Walt Disney World! My personal recommendations are pepperoni pizza (they put the pepperoni under the cheese) and a meatball sub "my way" which simply means extra sauce and extra cheese. Thank you Fiori for coming to Pittsburgh from your beautiful country and gracing us with both your exceptional food and engaging personality...I fixa you up! ;)“

“Come for the tasty pasta, stay for the excellent service and homey vibes.My boyfriend and I love places like this. We live just down the block, and really, there isn't enough local eats that still feel a bit dressed up, even though casual wear is appropriate. We've gone twice now, and both times, our servers have been lovely. On our latest date on Thursday, our server was there to greet us and ask about beverages not a minute after we sat down. She was super attentive, very fast, and a total sweetheart. The food has some hits, but it's all up to preference. I love the cheese ravioli. My boyfriend had the steak hoagie and we both agreed that while the steak was perfectly cooked, the sauce was a bit on the sweet side for us. That said, it was well made and presented, and we still left with full bellies. Carbonara's is fast becoming a regular date spot for us, and I haven't been disappointed yet. And those portion sizes? Perfect for work lunch leftovers! Yum!“

“We went there for take out on Sunday night for dinner. Tried a small babaganus, regular falafel, one assorted aladin special kebab platter and one seesh kebab platter. The platters comes with buttered rice. Some of them comes with salad as well. The food taste really great. All the kebabs were very well cooked There, flavorful and tender. Babagsnus was very tasty as well. There was a pita with one of the above dishes but not sure with which dish I got the pita. My complain is about the quantity. The platters cost anywhere between 17 and 21 dollars. Given the price the quantity was not what I was expecting. Also the dips like tahini sauce or garlic sauce were not free which was kind of wired. They will change you 75 cents for that. The ambiance looked ok to me. There were one one couple eating in the restaurant when I went to order. So not sure if it gets busy during some other time of the day. There were ample parking available. The shop also sells cakes like carrot cake tiramisu and baklava. The service was really good. I ordered upon reaching there. It took them under 15mins to hand over my order“

“I absolutely can not stand pizza. I have tried just about every place. A friend recommended your pizza. I am a believer in Pizza finally. Your chicken, bacon, ranch pizza is drool worthy. It is the only pizza I will willingly eat!! Thank you“

“Go order a pizza here now! Harry’s is the best pizza in the area! We drive 20 minutes from Washington, PA (where there are plenty of pizza shops) to get this since it’s our favorite! Literally the best tasting pizza I have ever had! How can it be so good? They have the best quality ingredients, perfectly cooked crust (crunchy and on the thinner side) and also exquisite service. They also have super high quality cheese and pepperoni in addition to a seasoning that they add to boost the flavors. I can’t say enough about Harry’s!“

“Was looking for a new place to try and have heard great things. Called and spoke with Leah, explained that it was my first time and wanted to know what she recommended. Gave me recommendations. Decided to order the meatball hoagies and the pizza bread, both were great. I wish the meatballs had extra sauce, but I'll order extra next time.“

“When I saw the price of the pizza special, I figured there was no way this place could have good food. Boy, was I wrong! It's a square pie, and very very good, worth the nearly half hour drive that I have to make to get there. Their hoagies are decent as well, especially because of their fresh made bread. The owners have been really nice people, but there's a struggle when it comes to parking sometimes.“

“This is by far, the best pizza and the best calzone I’ve ever tasted. The cheese to sauce ratio was impeccable. The crust was a perfect bit of crunchy around the crust. There was NOT a single bite of pizza that was soggy - and given the moisture of the cheese and sauce the pizza had, I was floored by how perfectly cooked it was.This place is CASH ONLY and although there is sorting available, it doesn’t seem like the type of place you want to sit down and eat. Not that it’s unwelcoming, it’s just very quaint.Vegetarian options: There are plenty of vegetarian pizza toppings available for personalizationParking: Plenty of parking with a bit of a walk from the lot“

“My family & I love pizza burgh. Great customer service from ordering to delivery is terrific... Very friendly staff members. The food is always hot & delicious whenever it arrives. Can't go wrong ordering from here bc everything is yummy. Thank you...“

“we just moved to the area and have tried a few local pizza places...they've all sucked! 1. we got so SICK after eating it. 2. the pizza was okay, but the calzone was raw...like more raw dough than cheese!!! 3. just tasted like cardboard. 4. over priced but not atrocious. well tonight I REALLY REALLY wanted good pizza! I contemplated driving an hour and a half to get a pizza from a place that I KNOW is safe! I stead I took the chance with Pasquales. seriously the best pizza I've had in the LONGEST TIME. it was so fast, I honestly expected it to be horrible. but it was delicious! I usually can barely crush 2 pieces...I ate 6.. I do feel sick but that's just because I ate way too much!! the sauce has flavor, it's well seasoned. the crust is buttery and delicious. you can actually TASTE the garlic! they don't skimp on seasoning which is so nice! this is our new go to for pizza!!!“

“It’s a great experience. The ambiance is very welcoming and charming. Definitely one of the cleanest pizza places in Pittsburgh and they have lots of seats for a great dining experience. Amazing wings and food. The service we received was so amazing and we will definitely be back again. They made us feel welcomed and gave us an amazing experience.“

“I’m sure those who grew up with it think of it as their favorite, but i found it to be ok. Not bad, but not great. At least the sauce isn’t sweet like a lot of pizza in the area, but it tastes canned and not fresh. I’m reminded that pizza is like sex…when it’s good, it’s great. When it’s bad, it’s still pretty good. It wasn’t bad at all…just not great.“

“We order pizza from here roughly twice a month and we are never disappointed. We ordered a deluxe pizza tonight, 4/12/24, and it was awesome. I really LOVE the sauce! I love that I can taste the ingredients, PLEASE don’t change the sauce. THANK YOU to the Baldwin team for a fantastic dinner.“

“As most would, I expected to be entering an average Fox's Pizza to have an average meal. I couldn't have been more wrong. I was greeted by the friendly ( and equally as handsome) owner who literally transported me to Italy with his unmatched skills in the kitchen. Each bite was better than the previous, and I truly think this Fox's Pizza may have the best pizza in the entire world. You have to go for yourself to try this tantalizing and beautifully made pizza. I truly love the owner Matt and his endless wealth of knowledge surrounding the culinary arts. 10/10.“

“What a cool find! I was in town for an afternoon meeting and stopped by. I highly recommend the Odinator. Great sandwich! Be hungry! They have the best homemade chips I've ever had. The fried zucchini was on point as well. Will be back for sure!“

“If you like Detroit-style pizza, this place is one of the best! It has a delicious crisp buttery crust with fresh tasting tomato sauce. The cheese is a mozzarella and provolone mixture that complements the crust and sauce perfectly. One of my favorites in the South Hills.“

“I read some good reviews about this place, so I stopped in for carry-out for lunch on a Monday. The folks working there were GREAT! Really friendly and they explained how they make much of their food. I was tempted by their chicken tenders, so I asked if they used frozen chicken tenders and they not only said “no” and explained how they made them, they just happened to be making a batch of fresh tenders and showed me the fresh chicken breasts they use to make them. I ordered their Nashville Hot tenders and they were AMAZING! The breading was very light and flavorful and the dry Nashville Hot seasoning was spicy… very tasty!!I also got their Deluxe Italian sub, half size and it was excellent! Very fresh ingredients and the sub came together great… Very Nice!!This place is carry-out only, but they do deliver and they do prepare food rather quickly. Highly recommend! I’ll definitely return!!“

“Ordered YaYa's tonight and it was delicious. Plain pizza - steak hoagie and wings (yes the wings are pricey but they are everywhere) the garlic parm and honey bbq wings were great! Crunchy and not to much sauce. Pizza was perfect thickness and crust is even good it's like seasoned. Bread on hoagie wasn't soggy and the actually give you enough meat. Give YaYa's a try!“

“Been wanting to come here for years. Finally made time to stop by. Only suggestion I would make is service. The pizza takes awhile which is understandable however the check was brought to the table while we were still eating. Would have ordered more drinks and dessert if offered. But that was okay Dairy Queen is right next door.Did appreciate getting a Wednesday special discount even though I thought the pricing was fair to begin with.“

“Been a customer for a year now since me and my girlfriend moved to South Park... We absolutely love this place! This is our go to take-out place for pizza, wedgies, fries, and fried Zucchini! Food is delicious and their marinara sauce is top notch!“

“Our favorite place. We come with my 1 and 4 year girls probably 3 times per month and they love it. Great for kids with a simple menu and great beer. Fair pricing and staff that cares. Last weekend I was solo-parenting and it was pouring down rain so I brought my girls up for a quick bite. I can’t recall who it was but the worker was super helpful as she could see me myself with two little ones and they brought our food to us along with drinks and helped my older daughter put her used cups in the wash bin. They clearly see the value in being a place that caters to young families and kids and if I could give 6 stars I would“

“Found this place when i moved to the area, unique place and different name. Pizza is good, Italian hoagie is amazing.. exactly the taste i look for in an Italian hoagie. Mac and cheese bites are great, definitely better than the sheetz ones. The employees are very kind and personable. Prices are reasonable, I love it. Keep up the good work“

“Cozy little pizza shop with great food! A best kept secret….but not for long! Owners are super nice! I highly recommend anything on the menu esp the pizza and wings.Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free crust and can make items vegetarian friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: No steps“

“An absolute gem. They hook you UP with even the side salad with roasted red peppers and a couple of black olives. The dipping oil for the bread was off the chain. Both entrees were outstanding especially for the price . Will DEFINITELY be back!“

“This has become my absolute favorite pizza shop! I eat it more often than I probably should but it's fantastic! The thick crust is where it's at! I've never had a wait time over 25 minutes which is perfect. We call and by the time we get in the car and get there it's ready. There only 2 things I can think of that someone may not like... I don't think they deliver but I'd rather go it anyway. And my only actual complaint is the cheese. It seems it doesn't get very evenly distributed. It's thick in the middle and very sparse near the crust sometimes. But again I absolutely love this place and if you live in the Monongahela area and haven't eaten here yet, do yourself a favor and get an XL thick crust pepperoni pizza!Wheelchair accessibility: Flat level ish parking lot, no steps or curbs.“

“I figured I’d try their Tuesday special. I ordered a small pickle pizza and got a free small. Both pizzas were sooooo good. Lots of cheese and toppings. The crust was baked light brown and was not too thick. Both pies were HOT when the arrived and I’ll order again. Honestly, these were the best pizzas I had since moving here.“

“They are super great, come eat here if you are Hispanic, very good prices and discountsParking: On the corner you park and that's itKid-friendliness: Of course you can order an extra large pizza and it is very economical so you can eat with friendsWheelchair accessibility: Very well suited for someone who cannot walk“

“Good pizza. Firm, no flimsy...not too greasy. Generous toppings. Not the most flavorful pizza I've ever had, but I'm into it and I'll order again. Easy online ordering and they open at 1030 which is nice when you need to place your order early for a later time. Delivery guy nice and followed directions.Convenient location also.“

“James is the best pizza maker around! We love their pies and won’t go anywhere else in tahn - I’m especially obsessed with their pickle pizza and garlic knots! Just a great, friendly, reasonably-priced local shop with truly medicinal marinara!“

“Favorite place to order pizza. It's well-priced and soooo good. We like the spinach specialty pizza the best and usually opt for the family pack deal that comes with an additional two-topping pizza. They are quick to make them, and since they are so close, we usually just pick it up ourselves.“

“First time customer! I came all the way from the south hills because I heard this pizza was one of a kind! I grew up on this type of pizza and it’s hard to find! It was spectacular and I will be back! The cook was so nice and so proud of his pizza! Fabulous!!!!“

“I don't live in the area, but I decided to give this place a try, and I'm glad I did! The store employees were super friendly and the order of wings and pizzas were ready very fast.The wings were full of flavor -- garlic parmesian wings were savory and the the teriyaki wings were like candy they were so good.The pizza was great. What was probably most notable was the crust -- it had a nice firm outside but soft and fresh in the inside. They put mushrooms in my order by mistake, but I just decided to remove them by hand since we live far away and I didn't feel like creating a fuss. The cheese blend is also very nice.Beware that parking isn't particularly good -- as you'll be in and out, thus isn't the biggest problem in my opinion. In any case, if you are in the South Park area and want to reward yourself by supporting a friendly business, give this place a try!“

“Had lunch for the first time in years on 3 /20..Had a very nice server Maria .Did an excellent job.We ordered 2 apps and a caprese salad to start.Arancinni And the meatballs.Came out quickly and were excellent.Nice portions, cooked pefectly and hot..Then ordered ravioli which again were delicious and nice portion..Will be back “

“With this whole COVID-19 thing going on right now, I called The Pizza Stop and placed an order for the chicken parm dinner. I've got a pretty big truck so at first, when I arrived there, I was a little concerned about parking. But after pulling into the driveway, I found that there's ample parking in back of the place. Once in the door, I was greeted with a friendly hello and a noticeable smile behind the mandatory masks that we're wearing during this pandemic time. My order was ready when I got there, we exchange a few friendly words and before I left, I took a quick look around noticing the cozy dining area that would work nicely for a BYOB. Should have asked if that's an option during normal dining times. At home I unwrapped my dinner and got ready to enjoy. The chicken parm was covered with cheese and sauce and very tasty. But I was also impressed with the spaghetti; so many times when you get pasta as a side for take-out, it's over-cooked and mushy. This spaghetti was done perfectly with just enough sauce and a sprinkle of parmesan cheese. I added some red pepper flakes since I personally like sauces on the spicier side, but the flavor of the sauce would hold up nicely all on its own. Accompanied with the garlic bread, a side salad and a red blend (something that I added to my meal that I had sitting at home) and I had an Italian meal that could stand up to any of the restaurants you would find in the Italian/Bloomfield district for a fraction of the price! I should also add that I was pleased with the portion. More food than I need to eat in one sitting. But since I'm working from home now, I've got a delicious lunch to look forward to for tomorrow. No complaints here, I'll be back again. The Pizza Stop gets five stars!“

“Beautiful outside patio that has the perfect vibe. We were greeted immediately and asked for our drinks. The food was excellent and the server was attentive. I recommend stopping by this place on a beautiful summer night.Kid-friendliness: Outside patio is very kid friendly. We took our 2 week old child.Parking: Plenty of spots that share with the other half of the building.Wheelchair accessibility: Flat level straight from the parking lot.“

“My friend & I just found this place, despite living just 1 mile from it for many years, so it's very easy to miss. The pizza is amazing. I wasn't sure what I thought at first about the sweet sauce, but it grew on me almost immediately. Its unique and delicious. Crust and cheese are divine. I'd give it a 9/10 and I will definitely be back. And soon! they do have limited hours but it's worth it to go on their time.“

“First timer here. We just had the Sicilian with pepperoni. It was absolutely delicious. The sauce wasn’t over sweet or over spicy. It was the perfect accompaniment to the light and fluffy pillow like dough with the ends having the perfect amount of crunch. Great balance all around. We will definitely be ordering more of this in the future it was BOMB“

“Food was decent. Our server was very kind and attentive. Only negative and it was our own fault is that we went near the closing time. So staff was rushing to clean up etc…therefore we felt a little rushed.Kid-friendliness: Pizza!! I don’t know of any kid that doesn’t like pizza.Wheelchair accessibility: First floor and has table/chairs for easy wheelchair access.“

“The fish hoagies where very good, the waitress or cashier was quick n efficient and cook was quick let me know how long. If you not tried definitely I've it a go very good pizza shop.Parking: Small parking area but more on other side where gas station is plus whole shopping plaza parking too.“