12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gettysburg

“Awesome spot! It has a nice little eat-in area and they provide great service. It looks like a typical hometown pizza shop upon walking in, but don't sleep on this joint! So far, the best NY pizza I've had in this area, it even rivals the pizza in NEPA and parts of NYS for me. The owner (I assume) is also very nice, just a genuine dude who likes to have a chat with his customers. We will be back for sure! ??“

“I came here with my family at the recommendation of friends and we really enjoyed this place. It was busy but the staff worked hard to get the orders ready. I enjoyed the regular pizza I got, my wife enjoyed her gluten free and our son enjoyed his chicken tenders and french fries. Upon leaving, I saw the drive-thru in action and was impressed with how they were able to fulfill all their orders. I would highly recommend this place.“

“This pizza shop is fantastic! The pizza is always fresh and delicious, with a perfect crust and generous toppings. Their subs are just as tasty—packed with flavor and made with care. The staff is super friendly and makes you feel welcome every time. Highly recommend stopping by!“

“First time but wont be our last! Our pizza was cooked to perfection with a generous amount of cheese & sauce, plus the pepperoni was cooked with a crispness just on the edge 🤌 SO satisfying! The wings stole the show with meaty drums & thick & juicy flats. Out of the 4 flavors we tried, the Old Bay wings SLAPPED! 10/10 We will be back soon to try more!“

“We were visiting PA from Long Island and stopped here. Being from NY I'm always comparing other states pizza. lol Brothers Pizza is AWESOME.“

“if you like Italian food this is the place! Will return as often as possible.“

“I just picked up a pizza at Blessing. I ordered through DoorDash for pick up. App said 18-25 minutes. Within 5 minutes of placing the order, I got the notification that it was ready 🤔. Picked up my pizza and it was cold and undercooked. I love Blessing pizza. Hoping it was just an off night 🤷🏼‍♀️“

“My bartender was Bailee she was very friendly and courteous. She kept my drinks flowing and continued to check in with me.“

“This was my second time dining there and food is fresh and tastes excellent“

“The pizza crust and sauce are out of this world!“

“my first time ordering from them and even though the food was good I wasn't too impressed. I accidentally typed in the wrong phone number so I had no idea that I did that and nobody text me that my food was on his way and it was taking a while so I checked and my food was sitting outside on my porch cold because nobody bother to knock on my door to tell me that it was here. And when I opened up my food my garlic dipping sauce that I ordered was not included in my package. Again good food just no dipping sauce nobody told me that my food was sitting outside“

“We had such a wonderful experience in every way - from menu recommendations, to great service and exceptional food! Our sweet server, Sara, offered helpful suggestions including a favorite, Montepulciano wine, an antipasto salad, customized lightly breaded entrees and desserts! The limoncello cake is not one to miss! We have family coming to visit soon and we will be sure to bring them here!“