18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fairfield

“My husband and I have been here frequently, we continue to come back. The food is amazing and the staff is so very helpful and friendly. There is nothing bad about this place, I have come to think of them as family with how they treat us. Thanks for always being great. 0“

“Food was amazing and the waitress were the best.“

“My husband and I came in for 2 Sicilian slices(well done and crispy, like we like it), mozzarella sticks and 2 drinks. We are locals to Gettysburg. WOW! Our food was delish, portion size was more than we expected. We will be back, our new Gettysburg go-to pizza!!!“

“Plenty of parking. Outside tables. Family friendly atmosphere.“

“Excellent! Best place for pizza in Gettysburg, hands down. We also really love that they have the most amazing choices for those on a gluten free diet in our family. Fantastic! (Only one small suggestion: Please consider providing real plates, even if they're just cheap plastic for dine in guests. Or if you can't, better quality paper plates would be, well - better! Any pizza of substance - and yours certainly is - needs a heftier plate than the thin ones currently provided).
Highly recommend this place! 👌“

“if you like Italian food this is the place! Will return as often as possible.“

“Outstanding Food! You get your money’s worth with anything you purchase from the menu. True authentic Italian food! Wait times are long, especially on busy days (which happens to be every day they are open) but their food is worth the wait. Some of the food takes longer to bake as well because of size. Friendly service from whomever answers the phone to take your order to the delivery person. Friendly service, as well, when you pick up.“

“excellent food, excellent staff. Highly recommend 👌“

“Went for lunch with family. Nice outdoor patio with excellent brick oven pizza, although it was cold by the time we got it to the table. Staff was very nice, but would recommend getting the food out a bit faster. It's a bit out of the way, but certainly a nice place to spend time with good company. Would highly recommend. Will definitely visit again.“

“We stopped in Emmitsburg for gas and chow, on our way back to NY, and decided to forgo McDonalds for once and get a pie from Carleo’s when we spotted the store front. So glad we did…possibly the best pizza we ever had! We hit the road and ate the whole 16” pie in 10 minutes and were seriously debating on turning around for another.“

“Really good pizza for as busy as they were. The chicken wings were a little over done and the place is noisy due to the crowd screaming into their phones. Just walk in order your food find a seat and wait til they call your number. If ya want good pizza, give this place a try.“

“30 days ago when I first came into the restaurant my ticket said “guy at the end of the bar.” Today it says “regular.” I cannot say enough about the hospitality the owner Mr. Bob and every waitress has shown to me over the month. I spend about 250 days a year in a restaurant and I know good food and service a mile away. The Ott House definitely doesn’t disappoint. See you in the summertime in OBX Ott Family!“

“The pizza is yummy! CRISP crust, marvelous sauce, and melted cheese blend is tasty-Delicious!“

“The pizza crust and sauce are out of this world!“

“We stopped there on the way home because my granddaughter was hungry. They fixed her a salad while we waited for the pizza. All was fresh and wonderful. She loved the salad. The staff there was very pleasant.“

“Little Italy V catered my 70th birthday party. The Ziti was awesome!! Plenty of meat and cheese and the garlic bread that comes with it is big and tasty! We ordered 10 dozen wings which were cooked to perfection! The 70+ people at my party loved it all! Thank you Luciano and Victor! You are the best!!“

“My bartender was Bailee she was very friendly and courteous. She kept my drinks flowing and continued to check in with me.“

“We had a party of 16, accomodated within 45 minutes on a saturday night. We had several pizzas, lasagna, gluten free entrees, chicken franchaise, and some seafood pasta options. Our server was incredibly personable and made sure that our orders were perfect. Everything was delicious and served hot and at the same time!“