6 Best Sandwich Shops near Gettysburg

“They really care about the customers. I used to come here frequently but didn’t go for almost a year.
Despite this, they still remembered my order and had it made quickly like they always do. Can’t recommend stopping here for a bite to eat more.“

“This was one of my favorite sandwich shops in the Midwest, I was surprised to find one here in Pennsylvania.

I was concerned with it being inside a gas station, but it’s the real deal. Just as good as the dedicated locations.

I will for sure go back every time I’m in the area.“

“5/16/2023 Just got back from Jersey Mikes with our delicious subs!!! Always perfect 👍🏻 They were very very busy getting a catering order ready and waiting on a long line of customers. All the staff workers were so very kind and patient with all the customers while they continued preparing orders! GREAT JOB!!“

“This Subway located inside the Gettysburg Outlets Food Court is awesome! They say "Hi" to each guest who walks by and they have the nicest staff. Everything is always so clean and appears very organized. I noticed they are always slicing fresh meats and refilling the containers constantly. The subs always are delicious.

Footlong Cookies - If you add a scoop of ice cream from Dough & Arrows on your footlong chocolate chip cookie you will be in heaven! Its super warm and a melty yummy treat!“

“This place is the greatest it was like 1pm on Wednesday the worker there was the only one there working her name was Jennifer. This girl got awesome customer service and is great at what she does I came back in at around 7 for dinner and this girl was still there. Am a regular now and I feel like I see this girl everyday. She is a hard worker and u can see she takes her job seriously. Keep up the great work.“

“It was my son’s birthday on Wednesday and we wanted to get some subs to go to the park for a picnic. I ordered online and there was no option to make personal edits to the order, so I called in. The employee was so accommodating; she took care of all of my needs and was super polite in doing so. She even called back to make sure she understood the directions I gave her. I got to the location and the girls who were working this day were professional, the store was very clean, and I was overall SUPER impressed. I will be going back, for sure. I know that currently the staffing situation is hitting hard on any restaurant business- but whatever the management is doing at the Biglerville Subway should be replicated. Please give those girls a raise!“