14 Best Sandwich Shops in York

“These boys know how to make a cheese steak sub!!!“

“We went on 2/8/25. Staying at the Hampton inn for a dance comp. Our waiter, unfortunately l, didn’t catch his name was absolutely AMAZING! More people kept getting added to our party, he, without hesitation, added more tables and chairs. He took our orders and separated the checks without us even asking. He just really went above and beyond and was amazing! I hope he gets the recognition he deserves! Thank you again! Food and drinks were 10/10!“

“I don't usually, but feel compelled to say that DAN is the MAN. I came to support a school fundraiser and ordered takeout. It was very busy. While waiting for it, I witnessed a family with 3 small children and the youngest got sick on the floor at the takeout area (asthma attack)... Dan jumped into action, offering towels, asking if he could help, checking if the child needed an ambulance(thankfully no- inhaler did its job) , then immediately mopping up thoroughly and placing the wet floor sign. Soon after, I witnessed him showing positivity and encouragement (instead of scolding) to a young server whose patience was being tested (by a customer I assume). He then motions to me and explains that my sandwich was incorrectly prepared (it happens- everyone's human) and it would take longer to remake the sandwich, so he offered me a free drink while I waited. All this while performing his regular busy duties and keeping all the wheels in motion and "putting out fires" everywhere. This man is a treasure and a great asset to the wonderful team at East York Isaacs! What a PRO! 🙌“

“best fresh sandwiches 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 never disappointed me always on point“

“First time I ever had a Jersey Mike’s sub. Had the roast beef. Delicious!“

“Our first time here. It was nice and the service was great. We will Have try it again“

“ordered takeout. everything was good, but once we got home, we realized they forgot to give us one of the 3 soups we ordered. 😞“

“I go here 3 or 4 times a week. What's my favorite place to get something for lunch, for work. They're very friendly and when you asked them to change what they normally do they have no problem doing it for you. The only place left where you can ask for extra anything or add something and it doesn't charge you extra money

Vegetarian options: You can order any sub without me and automatically makes a vegetarian or you can have them put it in a salad instead of on a sub.

Dietary restrictions: They can make any sub into a salad for you

Parking: There is about 15 to 20 parking spots but it's a shared location so there are other businesses that use those spots as well“

“Italian herb, and cheese pepperoni and ham and ,mayonnaise, banana peppers, jalapeno peppers. Haven't been to a lot of sub ways, but I've been to more than a couple. This Subway in downtown York has the best bread. Probably because they cater to a lot of businesses here in downtown York City pa. They're always busy and friendly. extremely fresh it's the tastiest ! it's the one and only Brandy Hayes reporting to you with the tastiest and the finest here in York PA“

“I had to take a minute to share my experience here yesterday. I placed an order online, and I received a notice that my food was ready. I walked inside, and the store was filled with customers. The staff was busy. Even though things were busy, one worker looked around every so often at the room. She looked at me, asked if I was being helped, and I told her I had an online order. She asked my name, and she turned to the row of order slips and said something to another worker. That person immediately walked over to me, handed me cups, and said I could get my drinks and that she was sorry for the wait. It wasn't long after that, a different person announced that there would be a wait for a certain bread, but that they were happy to offer the others that she mentioned. A few people left, but others stepped up to order with the alternative options. No one behind the counter grumbled, and the food kept coming out consistently but slowly. I was very impressed at 1) staff attitude and willingness to make customers aware of what was going on and to make sure everyone had attention given to them; and 2)the food prep never stopped-these folks continued to work as a team to get orders filled. What professionals! I will tell others how customer friendly this store is, even under pressure. Thanks for my lunch on a very hot day!“

“I was pleasantly surprised when I stopped by today. Greeted by very friendly employees and a clean dining room. The food area was very clean and fresh also. Best sandwich I’ve had from there in a long time!!“

“We used this location for the Red Lion Girls Soccer team for boxed meals. It was a very easy process and Chuck was great to work with. The price was extremely reasonable and the meals were ready on time. We will definitely be using them again!“

“I have been multiple times and the quality and portions of the food are great! I’ve had a wait a few times, but that’s expected with a new business, especially one located in Walmart that can be extremely busy. The customer service has well surpassed the short wait though, and I highly recommend!“

“DOEA NOT RECOMMEND!!!!!! what did I get when I recieved my order.... nothing but 2 toasted sub rolls with ZERO meat.... nothing.... not a thing. one rol had mushrooms and that was it. guess that's what you get when you order 2 Italian subs with no mustard.... just bread. Look at these photos... these ridiculous photos to show how incompetent people can be. I will never return. Thanks for wasting my $35. Oh and they don't answer their phone either“