19 Best Seafood Restaurants near Hallam

1 Captain Crab Seafood & BBQ

4.6 Superb 143 Reviews

4223 Lincoln Highway, Hallam

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We always came there for crab legs in the past. But we just discovered their amazing brisket and burnt ends. Huge fans! And we just had my family over this past weekend with several lbs of brisket, burnt ends, and sides we made, and everything was GONE! So delish, food was so tender it fell apart, served hot, and loved by all! And the owners are amazing!!!!! Our new fave spot in York and we will be back again and again!!! Thank you for the delectable experiences and we can’t wait to host more family and friends with your food!!!!❤️”

2 Rockfish Public House

4.6 Superb 422 Reviews

110 North George Street, York · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“my mom and i had a great time here and their mojitos were really great and i would rate this restaurant 10stars”

3 The First Post

4.8 Superb 429 Reviews

3691 E Market St, York · 2.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Today, had lunch at The First Post in York, PA. The place is nice and spacious, located on East Market Street. Our party of four shared a ravioli appetizer and had French Onion soup. Both were delicious!!! Easily the best French Onion soup I've eaten!!! For lunch, we each had something different. My Aunt had Salmon Salad. My wife had The Post Steak Sandwich with fries. Our son had the Blackened Shrimp Alfredo. I settled for.the Fish & Chips!! Each of us loved our meals - taking at least half home!! The portions were enormous!!! To wrap up, we decided on some dessert. My Aunt and wife had the Creme Brulee. My son and I had the Chocolate Reese Cake Tort. So good!!!! Service was phenomenal!! If in the York, PA area, you MUST stop in and eat up!!!”

4 Paddy's Seafood

4.9 Superb 97 Reviews

29 E Main St UNIT 1, Dallastown · 7.47 miles

“Awesome crabs!! Thanks so much!!”

5 White Rose Bar & Grill

4.3 Superb 492 Reviews

48 North Beaver Street, York · 7.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I'm a Yorker. But hadn't frequented the white rose after they went to a more upscale setting, my old high school homie suggested we go there and after we got seated I found out his out of town visit was for a death in his family that he assumed I knew about but I did not... now your staff being as great as you guys are and the food made this bad personal experience for us very nice otherwise, and it made me feel I may visit again sometime for lunch and a cold 🍺”

6 Falls Crab Shack

4.5 Superb 154 Reviews

1179 Cly Road, York Haven · 10.93 miles

• Take-Out

“Love ❤️ This place Best home cooked meal around ....You won't get a bettler place to come and enjoy .”

7 Beanie's Bar & Grill

4.5 Superb 373 Reviews

78 West Main Street, Mount Joy · 8.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Beanie’s delivers exactly what a local bar & grill should: bold portions and punchy flavor. The Volcano Burger was a full send. Juicy patty, onion rings stacked high, jalapeños, salsa and ranch. A punch full of flavor. The Southwest Chipotle wings had that smoky heat balance dialed in. Not just spice for shock value — actual flavor layered in. The patty melt leaned classic comfort with a side of fries. Nothing over the top. It was perfect, and seasoned beautifully. The mild wings over fries (Monday deal win) proved you can still get a solid meal for just $10. The nachos? Exactly what you want. Cheese, jalapeños, taco meat onions, salsa and sour cream. Atmosphere-wise, it feels local in the best way — relaxed on one side, bar going on the other. Perfect mix for introverts and extroverts. This is the kind of spot that builds community through food and friends. Sincerely , Full Effect Eats ❤️🍽️”

8 2 Wild and Crabby Guys

4.7 Superb 59 Reviews

34 West Philadelphia Street, York · 7.23 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Loved the crab cake and cream of crab soup!”

9 The Captain Krab

4.3 Superb 152 Reviews

2801 East Market Street Ste g7, York · 4.01 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They have very good quality sea food much better then most!”

10 Scotty Dog's Lounge & Grill

4.3 Superb 145 Reviews

2254 Industrial Hwy, York · 4.82 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Scotty dogs had a food truck at our school. My friend mentioned she got the crab soup and it was really good so I thought I would give it a try .. I go up there and they are closing up . I told them I only wanted soup and the guy was able to give me a cup since I told him I was just going home to warm it up. Let me tell you it was so yummy !!! The guy was super nice as well and had a conversation with me and even though he was closing up I feel like he gave me the time and made me feel welcomed and not a pain for being there so late. Will def have to try the restaurant out because of the crab soup is good I’m sure everything else is as well”

11 3rd Base

4.3 Superb 131 Reviews

512 North George Street, York · 7.16 miles

• Delivery

“This was the first time that my wife and I ordered from 3rd Base, and while all we ordered was a Cheeseburger Sub and an order of fries, let me tell you that our dining room was eerily silent for 5-10 minutes as we both were so impressed and surprised at how damn good our meal was, that we didn't talk, share, or otherwise allow any outside interference as we thoroughly enjoyed our meal. To me, the food is quintessentially some of the best Central Pennsylvania comfort food around and we are thrilled that the menu prices for burgers, subs, and appetizers were lower than expected, even though the quality and quantity of the portions were well above average. We have definitely found our new favorite go-to spot.”

12 Kelly's Inn

4.2 Good 195 Reviews

1906 North Sherman Street, York · 5.48 miles

• Take-Out

“I love Kelly Inn From the Owners to the staff. They remember what your food order are as well as your drink and treat you like family. I always dine alone and they made sure I was comfortable and checked on me, now mind you I normally get the jumbo crabs and thier Neptune pasta platter which is filled with huge shrimps and real scallops so I have plenty to eat, even with that they stop and check on me. I have to travel 30 minutes to get there but it so worth it and if you haven't had their Cosmo its so delicious thank you from the bottom of my heart I truly enjoy my visits with you”

13 Lighthouse 153

4.5 Superb 39 Reviews

214 North Franklin Street, Red Lion · 7.28 miles

• Delivery

“Lighthouse 153 is a delicious addition to FSS. We are so lucky to have this culinary option in Red Lion. The Mariner’s Mussels and Lighthouse Steamers were cooked to perfection and the broth was SO delectable, we had to soak up every last drop with the side of bread. The shrimp on the Po Boy are substantially meaty. The Crabby Balls, Crab Dip, & Lobstah Roll were all seasoned to perfection. A sweet & refreshing WildBerry Lemonade washed it all down. Bonus: the staff are helpful and pleasant. Can’t wait to go back to try the other menu items!”

14 Conewago Inn

4.2 Good 355 Reviews

3480 York Haven Rd, Manchester · 8.04 miles

• Delivery

“Burgers were top notch. Chicken tortellini soup was way too salty last week.”

15 Flavors Of Jamaica

4.4 Superb 128 Reviews

2582 Eastern Boulevard, East York · 4.37 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food here is top-notch. I’ve been a regular customer for months now. The place is spotless. Since the last inspection, they’ve made significant efforts to comply with state regulations. It’s evident that they’ve put in a lot of effort to maintain cleanliness. However, I personally believe that the shopping center is solely responsible for pest control. I’ve had the pleasure of dining in and taking the food home. There’s no other place in town that offers the best oxtails and jerk chicken.”

16 River Trail Brewing

3.9 Good 141 Reviews

40 East Front Street, Marietta · 4.39 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“great food, great service, and the beer wasn't bad either 🙃, I'll be back.”

17 Henry's Seafood

3.9 Good 82 Reviews

5865 Lincoln Highway, York · 2.15 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Their ads for sales are false! Went outta our way to get seafood for a nice dinner and they had the Jumbo Snow Crab Legs on sale for $9.99 a pound...My husband went and wanted to get 2lbs for him and I ...he got there and the were only selling them in 4lb bags!!! No where in the ad did it state sold in 4lb bags.It said$9.99 a pound!!! My husband tried to ask them we only wanted 2lbs but they said this all they have!!! So they try and get you there with falsely advertising all other items stated sold In whatever lbs but not those...I called and talked to someone and he totally was incompetent of what I was trying to say to him....won't be going there again as they seem to try and dip in your wallet for $ and don't stand by their false advertising”

18 Crabby Daddy's

3.3 Good 3 Reviews

1066 Mount Rose Avenue, York · 6.12 miles

19 Captain Bob's Crabs

3.5 Good 13 Reviews

90 Martin Street, Red Lion · 7.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Crabs seasoned great and full. Had a party of 11 outside and everyone enjoyed the evening with live music as well.”