42 Best Pizza Restaurants near Harveys Lake

“An absolute must-visit whenever you’re in North East Pennsylvania (NEPA)!
While Grotto Pizza famously launched as a beachside staple on the Delaware boardwalk, its heart is pure NEPA. It was created by Dominick Pulieri, a Wilkes-Barre native and King's College alum, who took his local roots south to chase a dream. But despite those legendary coastal beginnings, make no mistake: Grotto is a true local treasure.
The iconic swirled-sauce pizza is only matched by the fantastic ambiance across its locations. The Harveys Lake spot, in particular, is an incredible place to spend a summer evening, grab a pie, and watch the sunset over the water or listen to live music on the deck. I make it a point to stop by every single time I'm in town, and it never, ever disappoints!“

“The BEST PIZZA! Wing pizza with blue cheese/pizza cheese/wing sauce and their famous red sauce! It’s just awesome! It hits the sweet side and a bit of spice !! Just too good! There’s no pizza that comes close! Yummy! Along with any other pizza with toppings! Win win !“

“This may sound crazy but this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. And I’ve lived all over the country and grew up at the lake. The buffalo, general Tso, and plain cheese pizza are all to die for. I wish I still lived in PA so I could order on a regular basis.“

“Pizza is delicious, friendly service.“

“Their pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever tried in my life! We travel 50 minutes 1 way from Benton to get it. I always get the Canadian bacon and pineapple pizza with sweet sauce and thick crust and my fiancé always gets the chicken wing pizza with thin crust. We have never tried anything else off their menu only bc we’ve been obsessed with the pizza we get from day 1. Great place and I recommend them to anyone who loves a good pizza!“

“food is always good just really disappointed today went to place an order only to find out they close at 8pm . So sad I had to travel to get a decent pizza like to keep my business local but never so disappointed.Be awhile before I order this close to home“

“Best pizza around!“

“Best pizza I’ve ever had, I’ve been coming here since I was a kid and it’s still the same. Wings are outstanding and I love their signature pizza with no onions.“

“Love the food! The owner! And love the fact you have options for open or closed face pagash. absolutely delicious!! Go get yourself some to try! You won't regret it!! perfection every time!!!!“

“Good People, Good Tea, Good Place !!!“

“Drove by this pizza place several times but just noticed it tonight. Hubby was driving so I googled it and we turned around to give them a try. I was a bit nervous because the pizza boxes seemed a bit light when bringing them to the car. They were pretty thin pizzas. Man were they good!! I really enjoyed the thin crust too. They were not too thin, just perfect actually!We will definitely go back for more. The prices were not bad either!“

“I just ordered their chicken noodle soup and it’s perfect. It has the grandma made it her self taste to it. I have been looking far a good soup place and this is it. This definitely is a warm-up bowl of comfort. 10 out of 10, this is definitely a 10.“

“Tirado's Pizza Mexican Grill has ✨the best food✨ and is a wonderful, family owned restaurant that Kingston is lucky to have. Extensive menu options and they rotate through different specials throughout the year. Whether it's Mexican food you're craving or pizza night, give them a try, it's all delicious! The Birria tacos are the best I've tried in our area and when they offer Birria Ramen-❤️‍🔥sooo good on a cold, chilly day. 🍜“

“Best cheesesteak and Stromboli in the back mt. Their prices are very reasonable and the people that work there are very friendly. I highly recommend 3 Kings.“

“Super friendly service very welcoming probably the nicest waitress I’ve come across in quite some time, delicious wings nice crispy wings not a single piece of fat. the kitchen sick pizza was out of this world the plain with onion was also delicious and I really enjoyed having deep fried without all the grease definitely will be back to try the hot wing and steak and cheese“

“Getting hoagies from III Guys is CONSISTENTLY hit or miss. Now it's constantly a *miss* so we're done spending money here. I got a turkey hoagie today and there was barely anything on it! 😠 A regular sandwich is thicker! Two slices of turkey, a tiny bit of lettuce, some onions and a couple tomato slices! Oh and it was DRY! We paid for mostly BREAD! Feels awesome to be shafted for what you paid for. I had to put my own Mayo on it, add lettuce and add tomato to fill it! That's NOT the point of take out. Food quality is going DOWN last few years. ((See comments for pics of this sad hoagie)) We're done giving them the benefit of the doubt. The other hoagie we bought was also lacking & dry. Plenty of other good quality restaurants to choose from than wasting money on food that clearly quality isn't a priority. ~Signed Another Unhappy customer“

“Absolutely loved their boneless bites and Sicilian style pizza! The staff was so friendly and quick with our order.“

“I enjoyed my first trip to CrisNics this weekend after the America concert at the Kirby. My sisters have been there before and really enjoyed it, so I went along. I’m so happy I did! Great drinks, awesome food, large portions! But the most important and remarkable aspect of my experience was the friendly and engaging staff! They were incredible! Loved every minute we spent there! We will recommend people go to CrisNics and we will definitely be back! Thank you!! Slainte! 🍻☘️🇮🇪🍻“

“I got a italian hoagie just now. Very very good I'll be back there“

“Live music weekly, delicious food and drinks in a very pleasant atmosphere. A must visit.“

“I got take out. The fried seafood platter that came with your choice of 3 fried seafoods(I chose fried haddock, crab cake, and clam strips) it also comes with fries, tartar, and cocktail sauce… and then I was feeling frisky so I got the taco fries… EVERYTHING was phenomenal!!!! And the portions were HUGE!!! I have enough for left overs which I’m thrilled about. And all of it only cost me $23…. WHAT A DEAL!!!! My first but definitely not last time here!!!!“

“We truly appreciated your kind donation of pizza for our Coin War Fundraiser! Thank you again for supporting our small school and fundraising efforts! 💜“

“The food is always amazing.“

“maybe posting the food menu on your website would be nice“

“that noisey smile and thoes sinical remarks such good sprited nerd but always remember who's in control of the beer ¿♡☆?mm“

“Christine and her staff are amazing! Great food and service!“

“The pizza is always delicious, and the employees are friendly.“

“Met some friends there last night (4/13/26) and we had some great sicilian pizza with onions, salad, french fries, and a cheese steak hoagie. Everything was delicious! Friendly waitress who was very busy because even though it was a Monday, Tommy's was slammed! Highly recommend! 😋“

“My family enjoyed everything we ordered (Sicilian & Taco pizza and wings ). Thank you for delivering!“

“First time going to Happy Pizza. We had wings and a plain round pie. Every thing was great. We normally are never in Plymouth so this was just a find on Google. Both myself and wife when we at the pizza both said this was like Norms Pizza. We wondered if a cook was from Norms making it. It was just a question, but we will come back for this pizza next time in the area.“

“the best wings in the area!! and all of the food is excellent that I've tried. they go above and beyond expectations. I'm telling everyone I know.! I've never had a bad experience and I get it delivered and it's always hot and fresh and perfect too! 😉🙂😁“

“Amazing!! The ice cream was delicious! I got a kiddie mud pie which was perfect because I didn’t want too much. My bf got a large vanilla soft, serve with M&Ms and hot fudge! We both got them in a cup and were more than satisfied! Thank you!!!“

“I love this place. For the 1st time last evening I had the fried cod dinner. I was the most delicious fish I've ever had. It wasn't greasy. Pure white fish. Excellent potato filled French fries. Delicious coleslaw slaw. All at affordable prices. Pizza great too.“

“I haven't been there in a while but the should have the best Sicilian pizza around. Prices are the same anywhere around there. I have always had a great time going to see local band's there, took. Now I might just have to get myself some pizza from there very helpful.“

“This place is a hidden gem! For under $60, we were able to feed our family of six. We ordered an XL pizza, two heroes with a side of fries, and five drinks. The atmosphere was quiet and relaxing, and it wasn't overly busy. They also offer unlimited drink refills depending on the size you purchase. The food was fresh, tasted great, and the prices are hard to beat. We'll definitely be back!“

“great food! cool people! pool, darts, specials, and live music“

“Mallory(Cashier) is excellent! I walk into Grotto & she remembers exactly how I order my pizza…just a delight! Izzy is also good as Cashier. Sharon is an amazing waitress who takes care of me when I eat in. She’s one of the hardest workers that I’ve ever known. Hoping that Grotto CEO appreciates these employees.“

“I used to go here all of the time, but just recently started revisiting…I ordered a make your own panini and it’s chefs kiss 😚 I am so impressed and happy that even tho the order taker was a little annoyed with me lol it came out amazing!! 11/10 thank you guys!!“

“You Need To Know? Arrived just after 6:00 on a Saturday night & we were able to seat ourselves. There menu is vast & eclectic. There is something for everyone on it. Our sandwiches were all very good & the cheesesteak sandwich with ale ju was well worth a visit to this place. The only knock we had were the homecut French fries were soft & soggy. A quiet, great sandwich & drink spot for sure. Check them out! Now You Know! -TBH“

“Great food great staff it’s just that when we went to use our coupon that we paid for the bar tender stated that they don’t honor the full 30 that they would honor only 15 bucks which I don’t think is fair but it won’t turn us away just thought it was a little uncalled for when that’s what the coupon states“

“I ordered a couple pies on the 9.99 deal. Payed extra for stuffed crust. Everything was very good. Toppings were plentiful. The guy baking the pies was doing a great job making them perfectly cooked. This is the only domino location that does this well.“