Pizza Restaurants near Mifflintown

The Original Italian Pizza - Tyson Hill Pizza • $
27171 Rte 75 N, Mifflintown

Customers` Favorites

Meat or Cheese Ravioli Plate
Baked Ham and Cheese Sub
Cheese Sticks w Sauce
Cheese Steak Hoagie
Chicken Parmigiana
Penne with Chicken
Chicken Fingers
Loaded Nachos
Birthday Cake
Small Calzone

“I ordered stuffed shells with marinara sauce. My wife ordered a cheese steak sub and fries. Oddly enough, they brought her fries out a full 15 minutes before her sub and she decided to eat them while hot. Her sub did come out, but the amount of steak on the sub was all but laughable.I, on the other hand, had a great meal experience. The stuffed shells we're stuffed with cheese and swimming in a pleasant marinara sauce. The shells were served hot in a hot bowl. Delicious.My advice to OIP is to have servers ask if a customer wants a side before the actual meal.“

4 Good41 Reviews
Fox's Pizza Den Pizza • $
1803 Butchershop Rd, Mifflintown

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza Big Daddy
Build Your Own Pizza X
Grilled Chicken
Stromboli

“They're pretty busy sometimes at night when I call. But they get my order and I must have it maybe 15-20 minutes. Of course I'm close but still it's great to know if I'm hungry I'll get fed quick. I don't mind the food the pizza is fine. The strombolis are okay the subs are okay“

3.2 Average30 Reviews
Sal's OIP & Restaurant Pizza • $
31 Main St, McAlisterville - 7.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Calzone

“Sals is a go to if you want local mom and pop pizza shop pizza. Subs are better then tyson hill however can't anyone make a real meatball anymore? Still, better then most for being where they are. Careful menu selection determines happiness.“

4.1 Good22 Reviews