20 Best Italian Restaurants near New Brighton

1 Marco's Pizza

3.0 Average 208 Reviews

303 5th Street, New Brighton

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“ordered for the 1st time and the pizza was great!”

2 Sal’s Ristorante and Bar

4.6 Superb 238 Reviews

2764 Darlington Road, Beaver Falls · 5.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Spinach and ham calzone (without the spinach) was fantastic! Oozing with cheese. So yummy. 😋”

3 Yolanda's Pizza & Restaurant

4.6 Superb 131 Reviews

1601 Pennsylvania Avenue, Monaca · 3.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have been gone from the area for decades, tried the calzone well waiting at Robinson’s Auto and fell in love. I can tell we’re going to see each other quite often!!!”

4 Monte Cello's of Baden

4.7 Superb 59 Reviews

601 State Street, Baden · 7.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent service and better then the orginal monte cellos in cranberry”

5 Vesuvio's Italian Restaurant

4.4 Superb 126 Reviews

88 Wagner Road, Monaca · 3.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This place saved my butt last minute by hosting my son’s birthday when the weather was not cooperating for an outdoor party. We had around 38 people in their banquet room for pizza and cake and it went great. The owner and staff made accommodations to fit our needs while staying within budget. I’m so thankful for the family and staff that operates this place.”

6 Nico Luciano's

4.4 Superb 125 Reviews

813 Woodside Ave, Ellwood City · 9.68 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I had been here quite a few times but I never had the hay and straw . I have to say that was the most delicious pasta dish I have ever had!”

7 Yolanda's

4.3 Superb 105 Reviews

2228 Darlington Road, Beaver Falls · 3.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Yolanda’s has the best Pizza, garlic wings, wedding soup and more!”

8 The Grille at Bridgewater Crossing

4.1 Good 58 Reviews

206 Mulberry St Ext, Beaver · 2.52 miles

• Delivery

“I ate at The Grille on Sunday. The brunch was excellent. Chef Sara is the best! The service was excellent. The restaurant is very clean. Nice bar! The outside view was wonderful, but it was too hot that day to sit on the spacious outside deck. Overall, it's a great place! I'll definitely be back to try other items on the awesome menu! Thank You.”

9 Mall Pizza BVM

4.8 Superb 94 Reviews

566 Beaver Valley Mall, Monaca · 3.9 miles

• Delivery

“Ordered an Extra Large for the family tonight. Everyone loved it. Nostalgic, delicious, and close to home. 10/10 - recommend.”

10 D&G Pizza -n- Subs

4.0 Good 107 Reviews

1470 Old Brodhead Road, Monaca · 4.16 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I walked down from the Fairfield. It’s so close so why not try it out. Place has a local sports bar feel with a pizza shop attached for good measure. There were a couple of things I wanted to try. First was their fried dill pickle: just ok with too much breading but the dip sauce made up for it. House cut fries: these are tasty and go with beer perfectly. Little less salt next time please. The Seafood Flat bread was a finger licking delight. I was seated at the bar so service was top notch and my order came in a timely manner. Beer was cold!!!”

11 Yinzer Fusion Limited, LLC

5.0 Superb 12 Reviews

1944 Maratta Road, Aliquippa · 9.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food is delicious and well portioned great for the price”

12 Ricky Dee's Pizza

5.0 Superb 9 Reviews

818 Raccoon Street, Aliquippa · 8.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is the primo Sicilian/Square cut style pizza place on this side of the river. The crust is crunchy, the sauce is punchy, the toppings are quality, all at a very cheap price. The place is essentially in a bar in a bowling alley, the bar is a bit kitschy in a fun way, but it means you might have to wait a little bit to be served if you walk in. There will be a wait, due to the nature of the place more than the volume, but it is worth it. This is almost life-changing pizza.”

13 R&A Catering, LLC

4.7 Superb 12 Reviews

1034 Pennsylvania Ave, Monaca · 3.13 miles

• Delivery

“They just did my wedding Saturday and they did such an amazing job. Not only with the decorations but the food was AMAZING. Everything that they made was absolutely delicious. Highly Recommend 10/10. Also they help us with a DJ name TJ and his wife that is a bartender they were also amazing I recommend all 3 if your throwing any sort of wedding or celebration. WORTH IT”

14 Sons Of Italy

4.7 Superb 3 Reviews

1115 Pacific Ave, Monaca · 3.2 miles

“"Non sono nemmeno italiano ma loro sono la mia famiglia." I'm not even Italian but they are my family.”

15 Conway Pizza

4.4 Superb 31 Reviews

1126 Foote Street Suite 1204, Conway · 6.12 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The team at Conway Pizza are friendly & welcoming,. No matter what I have ordered it has always been phenomenal. Everything homemade! I always order more so I can have leftovers!! So excited because it is soup season! My freezer will be filled! Yum yum!!”

16 Vocelli Pizza - Rochester

4.1 Good 48 Reviews

228 Adams Street, Rochester · 2.37 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This one is a tough recommend. On one hand, The food I've received from this location has been consistently excellent. Deliveries have been fast. People were friendly. All the basic good points. On the other hand. More than once an order was delivered and placed...but no knock or notification that delivery was made resulting in the food being cold. Nothing done about it. More than once during posted opening hours was everything dead. Not at an hour left...but with plenty of time left. Earliest was at 7pm when posted time said closing time was 11pm...phones would go unanswered...online ordering would state location was closed. I get things happen, but this is a constant irritant at this location. So while I do recommend this place, it's with a huge caveat leading to this final statement. If you can get service from this place, the food is great.”

17 Vinny's Pizza And Restaurant

4.2 Good 96 Reviews

620 Beaver Avenue, Ellwood City · 8.98 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Brought our team for dinner after our grand opening in ellwood city and the food was delicious! I personally got the cajun chicken pasta, it it was the best pasta I’ve had in a while. Got some tiramisu on the way out and that was also a 10/10. We will be back Thank you!”

18 Ambridge Italian Villa

3.5 Good 109 Reviews

1710 Duss Avenue, Ambridge · 10.01 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“been eating Italian villa for 40 years never had bad service or bad food.love me sum Italian villa stuffed grape leaves.and a yahoo burger.and the 16 cut meat lovers pizza”

19 Mario's Woodfired Pizzeria

4.1 Good 97 Reviews

594 3rd Street, Beaver · 2.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Really good food in a quaint yet endearing atmosphere.”

20 Gianni's Pizza - Center Twp.

3.9 Good 3,298 Reviews

3486 Brodhead Road, Monaca · 5.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“BEST steak calzones!! So yummy!”