Sandwich Shops near New Brighton

“Wonderful Subway experience. The location was super clean. Food was fresh hot and delicious. Nicole (manager) is Wonderful. Service and speed was top notch. This Subway location far exceeds other Subway locations. Please support this local business in New Brighton!!!“

“-- They are such a wonderful people and their food is so good - my fiancé always beg me to stop by so he'd get his favorite sandwiches and I'd get treats for my dog Leo and he loves it too! The best market around!“

“If you're looking thru reviews trying to make a decision, just go here. Great pricing, not a chain restaurant it's small, clean and it's always a friendly atmosphere in there. Sandwich chains have set portions and if you aren't there to get vegetables heaped all over your sub, you're beat and walk out with 2 slices of cheese, 2-3 slices of meat and that's about it. This place doesn't do that. When I order turkey and cheese I get plenty of both. They make those sandwiches like they'd want them made for themselves. Definitely not stingy.“

“Jackson was super nice
That young man was definitely deserves a raise for how pleasant he was
He definitely cares about his job and his customers unlike other kids his age
His parents did and excellent jobs raising him!!!“

“Friendly, family atmosphere greets you upon entry! We have loved the delicious meatball subs and pulled pork sandwiches! We love that they collect items to help the Beaver County Humane Society!“

“Just stopped in to get a #8 in a bowl and it was delicious! I was super excited when I got back to the hotel to find the guy who made my salad gave me some extra pickles with juice! I use it as my dressing and this is by far my favorite jersey mikes bowl I've gotten! Thank you!! Staff is super friendly and the restaurant was very clean!“

“The food is good but at the time we arrived, there was only one person working and quite a few people in line for food. Although she was working as fast as she could, she needed help. That help arrived about 15 minutes after we did. This did help the line move faster.“

“Picked up steak salads after work tonight. Casey and Raven were amazing. Casey took my phone order in a friendly and professional way. Salads were ready when I got there. Plenty of meat (and signature roast potatoes) and staff was great. The place is really convenient for us but that's not why we keep going back. We love the steak salads!“

“Did DoorDash for Subway. I got a BNT with lettuce pickles green peppers, And onions got creamy Sriracha Parmesan vinaigrette with a tea and a bag of chips.

The sandwich wasn’t bad. It was just a lot of sauce like extremely drenched in sauce. The chips were open.“

“UPDATE: I just want to update my below review. The management at this location reached out to me within 24 hours of leaving this and refunded my order. Not only that, but Michael was sincerely interested in specific feedback about the pizza and finding ways they can improve going forward. Customer service like this is why I will continue to go back to Primanti’s even after a bad experience. Kudos to Michael and to Primanti’s for taking ownership of a mistake and striving to be better next time. You don’t see a lot of that anymore. Thank you!

The pizza at this location is awful. I’ve had Primanti’s pizza at multiple other locations around Pittsburgh and have always thought their pizza is great. I’m not sure how true this is, but I’ve heard that not all locations have a pizza oven. I’m not sure what they’re doing at this location with the pizza, but it was inedible. The cheese was waxy, hard, and extremely greasy and burnt. The sauce was dried up and tasted awful.

We got the family meal deal tonight and had to throw the entire pizza out. My kids hated it. My wife and I both tried it and it was absolutely terrible. The sandwiches, tenders, and giant Bavarian pretzel we got were great tho. The pizza is my only complaint. Something needs to be done to improve it at this specific location. It’s really bad.“

“The staff here is polite and the store is clean. The food and tea is always fresh. And there’s plenty of seating.“

“Delicious sandwiches enjoyed the atmosphere, and was with my wife Kimberly.whom also enjoyed her hoagie“

“The building is old, both interior and exterior, but this isn't Subway's fault. They could renovate the inside, or at least update it, but the landlord may not permit it. Who knows. The staff has always been good, and the food is handled properly according to food industry standards. Despite the age appearance, the restaurant is not dirty. I've been a patron since I was 16.“

“Best hoagies ever, reasonable price“

“Whoever the young lady is who worked on 4/7/25 at the Ambridge location at 2:30-3PM deserves some recognition. Her name may have been Dora? Not sure. Anyways, some guy came in and started being nasty towards her over the fact that he thought his cold cut should have more meat on it (for no extra charge). The woman making his sub calmly and professionally explained the menu, the pricing, and what all a cold cut combo would entail, and the guy just starts bullying her and telling her “you’ll be on the news for this… subway used to be great… blah blah…”
Long story short, the customer was 100% in the wrong in this instance and that female worker handled the situation with much more grace and patience than I would’ve. She sure didn’t deserve all that bs, but she handled it phenomenally well. This five-star rating is specifically for her!!“

“People got to remember to tip the workers. They work very hard and I watched a few people not even leave a buck. I was there watching the staff prepare a big order over 40 subs and watch the person pay by check and not even leave a tip. How rude for customers to do “