21 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Castle

“The pizza is the best but today I ordered boneless wings. They were the best I've ever had. I would definitely recommend trying them!!“

“We were looking for good, old fashioned homemade pizza and we hit the target here. Loaded with toppings and homemade sauce was fabulous. Highly recommend !!!“

“Love the wine slushie, bread and dipping oil, pepperoni pizza and cannolis! Atmosphere is also great! Would highly recommend if you’re around New Castle!“

“I love Fox's, have been ordering since the 1970s in the original shop. Best pizza anywhere!“

“Great pizza, great prices, I just found out they have dessert pizza🤤“

“The most like your Italian grandmother's pizza you'll ever find outside of grandma's! Nothing but the best quality, always fresh ingredients and every pie hand made with care and love. The BEST!!

Parking: Readily accessible parking.

Kid-friendliness: Family environment

Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible via wheelchair,“

“My experience has always been great except for yesterday and on the toilet this morning. I came in and picked up some chicken and green sandwiches (one of my favs)
Got back to the shop and WOW were they hot!!!!
So much red pepper flakes in the greens I was sweating and my nose was running. I’ll definitely be coming back, the food is great. Maybe tone that down a bit. If this would happen again, at least I know to keep a roll of toilet paper in the freezer for the next day.

Ps: yes, I still finished my sandwich 🤣 🥵 😎
Thanks guys you rock!!!“

“Take out was about an hour wait, but worth it. The red sauce is great and they put a lot on the pizza. We got a poor man's pizza which is good. I like their red sauce better. I normally like hot wings, but food in New Castle can be HOT! Thank goodness we ordered the mild - they had just the right kick! Next timw I will dine in.

Vegetarian options: You can get any type of veggies on pizzas and salads. If you have acid issues from tomatoes, the poor man might be for you.“

“The food was great however there was a woman who was waiting on people and she was not friendly at all. She didn't smile, wasn't pleasant and rude to quite a few people that we heard her wait on after us.The pizza we had was amazing and the guys that brought it out to us were super nice but she was not.“

“Delicious and good Specials!“

“I do really like their pizza, they have a very good menu of salads, sandwiches and much more!! And Joe, the owner, he is a very good guy!! Always willing to help our schools with a fund raiser!! Thanks, Joe!!“

“Farone Brothers Catering did my son's wedding this past weekend. Fred and Anthony made sure everything was absolutely perfect! The guests just raved about all the wonderful food - and the catering staff and bartenders went above and beyond to make sure it was a perfect day! I thank them all so much for everything. If you want a beautiful wedding give Faraone Brothers Catering a call for a five-star event!!“

“I'd most recommend the subs, especially the tuna, nice that it comes with a drink included in a really good price, daily specials!“

“Service was amazing!!!! I really enjoyed the pierogi pizza“

“We love Patsy's Bar and Grill! Since it's opening we've stopped in often and have tried just about everything on the menu. We've never had a bad meal, everything is always delicious. They have a decent wine and beer selection and a very nice appetizer selection too. Excellent sauce and pasta dishes. And, a great wait-staff.“

“When you are craving Pizza Joe’s, nothing else will do the trick!! Their pizza is always hot, fresh, and so so tasty. I ordered an 8 cut Hawaiian Pizza with the intent to eat some for dinner and pack some in my lunch the next day. I just wanted it too badly and couldn’t stop eating. It never made it to lunch! I’m not sorry. I have never ordered a pizza (or anything) from here and felt dissatisfied. Dipping a heated pepperoni roll in their sauce is always a good idea. Order some for yourself so you can share my pizza fueled joy!“

“Always clean with friendly prompt employees. Service is quick whether ordering delivery through door dash or calling for pick up. Always have had a good experience. Food was always perfect as it should be. Couldn’t ask for a better experience.“

“Nice place great food. Good service“

“Mr. Pizza An absolute Awesome gem in New Castle Pa for years, we are absolutely blessed with the best! New York style since 1972 came from Brooklyn NY where it started in 1953, it's just like being in New York and having the Real deal NY slice , the absolute Best! ????“

“My only complaint is that I ordered 2 orders of cheesy cup thing & they put pepperoni in one. Last time there wasn't as much cheese as before too

Parking: Not a lot of parking right in front & its kinda tight but there's spots a little farther away frm the door“