50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Cumberland

“The BEST pizza in the area. It’s been our go-to for years and the pizza is always great!!“

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“This is my go to delivery place in New Cumberland. Best pizza in Cumberland county as far as im concerned. They deliver and they are usually early and very pleasant to interact with. A+++ �“

“We have buffet on Sundays again from 11:30-2:30pm!“

“I have ordered from here at least twice a month for over a year now. The owner is a fantastic man who really keeps his word. They have the best pizza and Strombolis..“

“I tried the buffalo chicken pizza and it tasted really good“

“Had the cheese ravioli today. Was delicious. We love this place. Have never had a bad meal. Everything always fresh and delicious. The owner is great. Always so friendly.“

“Very good pizza. Tastes very fresh and juicy. Great atmosphere. People who work there are very kind. BIG portions. Thanks again for great food.“

“Everything is always delicious!“

“I had the opportunity to try this place for the first time yesterday, I don't live in the area, but a friend recommended I try it. I have to say, the food was amazing!!! The customer service was also amazing!!! If you're ever in the area and you don't try this place, you're doing yourself a disservice!!! 10 out of 10 highly recommend Bellia's Pizza!!! I will definitely be back whenever I'm in the area!!!“

“My Family and I go to Hershey Park and this Pizza is a must have whenever we go, excellent Pizza and excellent service 😋 Thank You so much“

“The food was fresh! Yesterday I had the veggie pizza ( outstanding) Today I went back and tried the cheeseburger sub. Again excellent choice. Coming from a food service background, I’ve rated in many restaurants and many states. Fabio made sure that all was perfect. From the fresh bread to fresh ingredients ( you can taste the freshness) GRET JOB. Please please please go there on 3 rd street. ENJY“

“The owner and his staff are always very pleasant. It’s a nice clean environment and my salads are always made with fresh vegetables. I’ve tried a few different items and haven’t been disappointed. Tonight I went with the penne a la vodka. The sauce was creamy and delicious! Also the bread that comes with the salad is really yummy, it has garlic, herbs & cheese on it.
If you’re looking for a great pizza shop in Harrisburg, I highly recommend David’s Pizza.“

“their pizzas are amazingly good. you can tell and once you take the first bite that it was freshly made👍“

“I am new to the area and this made me feel at home but even better!! I order about every week. Fresh and very hot. Family restaurant and made me feel very welcomed!! I brought my family from back home here for dinner, they enjoy this just as much!! I need to try a few more things on the menu so I can brag more!!“

“Great pizza, friendly atmosphere. We give 5 Stars!“

“I love boulevards pizzeria, I just got a pizza from them tonight. The owner is super friendly and nice. He gives good customer service and always makes us feel welcome. I hear Nick take orders on the phone . I highly recommend this place they sell amazing pizza, chicken wings , bacon cheese fries and so much more 🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“Arguably the best pizza in the hbg / Hershey area . 3.50 for a slice is a steep though but I’d rather pay that than 3 bucks for garbage. I’m just thinking it shouldn’t be what they charge back east where rent is mucb more expensive . Either way it’s much better than most of their comp“

“Lovely people. Great wings and pizza. Felt like family. 🤓“

“Great place to eat!!!!!!!“

“My husband and I saw this establishment by chance and decided to give it a try on our way home from some errands this weekend. We were greeted by the co-owner who could not have been kinder and even threw in two hoagies for us to try since it was our first time there. Absolutely phenomenal pizza and the hoagies were to die for. We plan on returning asap!“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“What a great find during a recent weekend in Harrisburg. Our server, Maria, was outstanding - knowledgeable, very friendly, and fun. Other staff members were also very accommodating and gracious. I particularly enjoyed the whipped ricotta app and arugula and beet salad. Highly recommend!“

“The pizza is TOP notch. One of the best pizza places I have ever had. The grandma style is amazing as well as a normal hand tossed pie. I have ordered over a dozen times and have NEVER been disappointed! That is super rare to get consistently great quality food“

“Best pizza/sub shop in the area … everyone is super nice!“

“Us Railroaders love it here!“

“Delicious Pizza, went pretty late and the place was super clean and the staff was so friendly.“

“Very good value. Their pizza and strombolis are very satisfying.“

“Best pizza in town“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“The Barrett family is sending a huge thank you to the Pizza Shop for showing their community support in providing a donation for sponsorship to support William in going to Fargo ND to compete in the National Championship for freestyle and greco wrestling!! Thank you for your support!“

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

“Great food love this place. And great customer service“

“We have been coming to Jigsys for years and it never disappoints. Yesterday we had the opportunity to have a family event in their awesome lounge area with catering provided for 20 people. Boy what a treat! We were provided a spread including a variety of their specialty pizzas, wings, stromboli and an enormous antipasto…all of it amazing! Everyone went home happy and full that’s for sure. The staff were also fantastic and super attentive throughout the afternoon making the party just an overall perfect experience.

If you are looking for a place to host an event with amazing food, friendly service and a great atmosphere, this is the place.

Awesome place!“

“I've been trying different pizza places around harrisburg. A friend suggested Santos later in the neighborhood so I thought we'd stop by. Imagine my surprise when they had pizza like you get in New Jersey or NYC. I asked who worked there was Italian or from Jersey. Much to my surprise, it's a family of Mexicans from I believe Oaxaca. And their pizza is Far and Away the Best pizza I've had in this town. I particularly like the spinach and mushroom and their Margarita pizza. There's stuffed pizza, pepperoni mushroom, you name it,it's all great. Plus the subs and other items, but I always go for a slice or two. And two are usually one too many.
And as a bonus,I get to practice my bad Espanish on them and they don't laugh at me too much. LOL!“

“Pizza was delicious and their subs are huge and filling. Best cannoli I’ve ever had!“

“Best local pizza 🍕“

“Love this place been coming for years . Although it's been a long time we came on Sunday with a big fried items order but they did not hesitate to serve us. The people were friendly even though they were closing they were happy to do it my grandma absolutely loved it and she is so picky for food but she ate very well that day ?❤️.“

“Best pizza in southeast-central PA I’ve had so far! Thin and non soggy crust with a good sauce (not too sour, bland, or garlicky). Crispy pepperoni cups are the best. Pan pizza makes the difference. Wish they were open everyday!“

“Excellent food. I always order more than I am going to eat a one meal. Their food is so fresh my son and I can eat salad n taco pizza , then have carnival fries for a snack, next day we have canzone in the air fryer Robertos is the best and not yucky or fall apart when we heat it up ... love love love it ! Always polite even when they are swamped, and if you are patient, they even carry it out to my car for me. I AM A VERY HAPPY CUSTOMER BEEN A CUSTOMER FOR OVER 20 YEARS !“

“First time getting pizza from them and it was AMAZING! Definitely reminds me of the Italian pizzeria back home! My kids absolutely loved it too, we definitely will be back again, and again! It's hard finding a good pizza spot that has deals on 2 large pizzas.“

“Ordered 2 Italian baked dinners. Excellent flavor, big portions plus a great salad and breadsticks. Frank and his crew always prepare the best!“

“Passed by this pizza shop forever and today finally stopped in....EXCELLENT!!! The pizza & wing special was outstanding! Best pizza & wings I've had in a long time! 5 star 🌟 Recommend!“

“Thank You for reaching back out to me I greatly appreciate you guys.I know it was doordash fault not you guys.I would definitely recommend one of the best around Pizza Shops Out of Central Pennsylvania.Not only is the food good but I gotta give the owners and works a 5 star for the fact if you go in to order they are incredibly friendly and they care about you're experience and as long as you guys are around you will keep ordering from here I hope you all have and amazing day.“

“My favorite pizza around! Online ordering is so easy, delivery is quick, and their sauce is amazing!“

“Went in for a slide and got the meat lovers thick crust. Large piece for $3.98 with tax. While waiting I was shocked to see the very large menu of subs, cold and hot, salads and Strombolis. Casual setting if you dine in with great 80s music and sever was great. I was feeling like I walked into a joint in NYC the minute I opened the door and when I saw the sever wearing a NY cap, I figured I was right on with a smile on my face.“

“Great atmosphere, delicious food, and the staff was amazing.“

“So, last night a group of 12 of us supposedly had reservations at the 1700 steak place in the Hilton. Upon arriving they did not have our reservations. Called Bacco to see if they could accommodate our large party. They said they could. I have to say… they were fantastic! We were seated downstairs and our waitress was FANTASTIC! There were some call offs and only two servers and she handled our group like a champ. She was personable,sweet, nice and very engaging and accommodating with anything we asked! I wish I could remember her name but, unfortunately I can’t! We totally enjoyed ourselves and the food was awesome!“

“the Italian subs you make are the best in Cumberland county! Thank you for having delivery service.“

“Normally a great experience at Home Slice with great food. Point of criticism to work on is having your staff better communicate wait times. Arrived at the time I was told it would be ready. Was then told 10 more minutes, fine. Food wasn’t ready for an additional 45 min. Clearly wasn’t in the process of being made when told 10 more minutes (a pizza and 2 subs doesn’t take that long to make)“