50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Cumberland

“The BEST pizza in the area. It’s been our go-to for years and the pizza is always great!!“

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“Just had literally the best cheese steak - South Philly Cheese steak!! and I have tried many cheese steaks in my years“

“We have buffet on Sundays again from 11:30-2:30pm!“

“I have ordered from here at least twice a month for over a year now. The owner is a fantastic man who really keeps his word. They have the best pizza and Strombolis..“

“Great pizza, friendly atmosphere. We give 5 Stars!“

“Best food i’ve ever had😘😘would never choose anywhere else for pizza!!might order this for my wedding when i’m older!“

“Everything is always delicious!“

“Had the cheese ravioli today. Was delicious. We love this place. Have never had a bad meal. Everything always fresh and delicious. The owner is great. Always so friendly.“

“I had the opportunity to try this place for the first time yesterday, I don't live in the area, but a friend recommended I try it. I have to say, the food was amazing!!! The customer service was also amazing!!! If you're ever in the area and you don't try this place, you're doing yourself a disservice!!! 10 out of 10 highly recommend Bellia's Pizza!!! I will definitely be back whenever I'm in the area!!!“

“their pizzas are amazingly good. you can tell and once you take the first bite that it was freshly made👍“

“The food was fresh! Yesterday I had the veggie pizza ( outstanding) Today I went back and tried the cheeseburger sub. Again excellent choice. Coming from a food service background, I’ve rated in many restaurants and many states. Fabio made sure that all was perfect. From the fresh bread to fresh ingredients ( you can taste the freshness) GRET JOB. Please please please go there on 3 rd street. ENJY“

“What a great find during a recent weekend in Harrisburg. Our server, Maria, was outstanding - knowledgeable, very friendly, and fun. Other staff members were also very accommodating and gracious. I particularly enjoyed the whipped ricotta app and arugula and beet salad. Highly recommend!“

“Lovely people. Great wings and pizza. Felt like family. 🤓“

“The best pizza shop in the area. The staff is so awesome and professional. I love the cheesecake subs with fried onions and grilled sweet peppers. Always delicious 😋 Love everything about the restaurant. TRY IT!!!! Won't be disappointed.“

“David's pizza is by far the most amazing pizza restaurant I have ever ate at in my whole life! I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking for top level food at a very affordable price! I also tonight had the pleasure of meeting the owner Mr Davis himself and let me tell you he is a very special and kind man who cares about his customers which is very hard to find in today's world! Please if you haven't yet try this place out or you are missing out! I know I will be coming back again and again!“

“I tried the buffalo chicken pizza and it tasted really good“

“Arguably the best pizza in the hbg / Hershey area . 3.50 for a slice is a steep though but I’d rather pay that than 3 bucks for garbage. I’m just thinking it shouldn’t be what they charge back east where rent is mucb more expensive . Either way it’s much better than most of their comp“

“BEST grilled chicken salad! Chef’s kiss! The chicken is perfectly seasoned and cooked!“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“I am new to the area and this made me feel at home but even better!! I order about every week. Fresh and very hot. Family restaurant and made me feel very welcomed!! I brought my family from back home here for dinner, they enjoy this just as much!! I need to try a few more things on the menu so I can brag more!!“

“Great food love this place. And great customer service“

“Congratulations on your “Best of 2025” best of business award!“

“If you’re anywhere near Harrisburg and haven’t tried this place yet, you’re missing out on a slice of Italy itself. These folks are true Italians through and through — you can taste the love and pride in every bite. From the moment we walked in, they treated my family like we were part of theirs. The service wasn’t just good; it was genuine, warm, and downright old-school in the best way. Now, the pizza. Their homemade sauce? Absolute perfection — easily the best we’ve had since our trip to Italy. It’s rich, fresh, and clearly made with the kind of care you can’t fake. The crust hits that magic balance: light, crispy, and chewy. My oldest, who’s never really been into pizza (still not sure how that’s genetically possible), couldn’t stop talking about how good their pie was. That alone says it all. Bottom line: this isn’t just pizza — it’s craftsmanship. A must-have, every time.“

“They have delicious pizza, and so happy they make a white pizza! If you order 2 medium or 2 large pizzas on Thursday, Friday, or Saturday, you get a free 2-liter.
They also have delicious stromboli, calzones, and subs. Eat here! Just eat here!“

“Pizza was delicious and their subs are huge and filling. Best cannoli I’ve ever had!“

“The pizza is TOP notch. One of the best pizza places I have ever had. The grandma style is amazing as well as a normal hand tossed pie. I have ordered over a dozen times and have NEVER been disappointed! That is super rare to get consistently great quality food“

“some of the best NY style pizza in the area :) but they are the most expensive as well :(“

“This is a great establishment. I love there pizza, owner always makes it how I like it. Great customer service, the owner is always very friendly and makes sure customers are satisfied!“

“Ordered on one of the busiest nights of the week. HALLOWEEN! Food still came out hot a fresh. Worth the wait! I hope you all get to enjoy a nice cold beverage after work.“

“I ordered a couple of pizzas today via DoorDash to feed my team. The quality of the pizzas and the flavor was top notch. My only issue was the “large” pizza is tiny. Which normally I would be ok but trying to feed a group at work with those tiny pizzas was a bit rough.“

“We sat outside, the music was a bit loud but we got over it. Played corn hole while we waited on our food. Fried pickles were okay. The breading was thick for my preference. We got the parmesan garlic wings extra crispy. We didn’t really taste the flavor on the wings. Just large chunks of garlic on a fried wing. The meat lovers pizza on a single crust was it for us. Delicious and airy crust.“

“Best pizza in southeast-central PA I’ve had so far! Thin and non soggy crust with a good sauce (not too sour, bland, or garlicky). Crispy pepperoni cups are the best. Pan pizza makes the difference. Wish they were open everyday!“

“Excellent NY style and strombolis“

“Very good value. Their pizza and strombolis are very satisfying.“

“Passed by this pizza shop forever and today finally stopped in....EXCELLENT!!! The pizza & wing special was outstanding! Best pizza & wings I've had in a long time! 5 star 🌟 Recommend!“

“I ordered through grubhub, this was my first time ordering from Niko's. I got a pepperoni pizza and it was great. There was plenty of pepperoni and cheese, the crust was crispy. I will definitely be ordering again!“

“The atmosphere was very nice and clean. We got a variety of pies, including the high rise dough and the cauliflower dough. The high rise dough was very soft, while the cauliflower dough was crunchy. Both great options. From the sauces, my fav were the pesto and spicy red. The toppings were nice. For the finishing the hot honey and spicy chili oil drizzle were my favs. It was great the next day as leftovers too.“

“Consistently great food and friendly service. I will drive 15 minutes to go here when there are other pizza shops closer to my home. There aren't any pizza shops that compare.“

“Love peppinos! The food is amazing, the people are always nice and friendly, they have good space inside!!! The lunch specials are amazing!!!

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly and everything made to order!!

Wheelchair accessibility: Can access with wheelchair! No stairs!!“

“Best local pizza 🍕“

“Recomiendo mucho este lugar para comer los mejos tacos de carnitas bueno toda la comida está muy rica 😋😋😋😋😋😋😋“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“My favorite pizza around! Online ordering is so easy, delivery is quick, and their sauce is amazing!“

“I love boulevards pizzeria, I just got a pizza from them tonight. The owner is super friendly and nice. He gives good customer service and always makes us feel welcome. I hear Nick take orders on the phone . I highly recommend this place they sell amazing pizza, chicken wings , bacon cheese fries and so much more 🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“Good food, reasonable prices and good friendly service.“

“Ordered online the 5 for $35 deal. Got 3 pizzas, where you select the toppings you want, and 2 sides, my choice . Great deal for a quick supper when no time to make food when having other activities/events for the evening. Arrived to pick it up and they were finishing my order up. Worker was pleasant and greeted me with a smile and handed me my whole order. Great offer! Need to order online (in the app) prior to pick up. 👍“

“The Funnel Cake fries ! 😋❤“

“The Barrett family is sending a huge thank you to the Pizza Shop for showing their community support in providing a donation for sponsorship to support William in going to Fargo ND to compete in the National Championship for freestyle and greco wrestling!! Thank you for your support!“

“I found this place on an accident. I turned into the parking lot to turn around and go to a different pizza place but figured I ended up in their parking lot so it was fate. I'm so glad I went in and gave them a try! As soon as you walk in it smells amazing! The pizza in the window looked great and the desserts in the car looked delicious. I got a large extra cheese pizza, a large pepperoni pizza, large cheese steak boli and 4 cannolis. The man at the counter maybe the owner? An absolute sweetheart. He was so patient with me during the ordering process and genuinely seemed to enjoy his job. While waiting for the food to be made I was presented with 3 bags of their house made chips to try. And oh my goodness they could just sell nothing but those they were so delicious!!! The house blend chips were delicious and went great with their spicy dip. The barbeque give middleswarth a run for their money, seriously that good. And the buffalo were BUFFALO. lol. If you love spicy his that builds in intensity as you eat then they are the chip for you. Super spicy but a nice warm addictive heat. Me and my husband were seriously blown away at how good those chips were! The pizza also didn't disappoint. Hot, fresh, delicious airy dough, flavorful sauce, and good quality cheese. The cheese steak boli was massive in size and flavor. So much cheese, delicious caramelized onions and so much meat. We ate off of it for 3 days. Such good food, service, prices, and quality. We loved the cannoli filling the shell just was soft but oh well things happen. Everything else was top notch especially the man I interacted with from the moment I walked in to him carrying it out to my car he was absolutely fantastic. Please give this gem a try you won't be disappointed.“