34 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Derry

“FANTASTIC food!!!! The pizza is thin crust, sauce is amazing with toppings all the way to the edge, you don’t often see that. The atmosphere is casual, comfortable and inviting. The service was great, thank you Nadine. Hats off to Mike the owner and his team. The pepperoni pizza is the absolute best I have ever had. This was my very first visit and it certainly will not be my last.

Parking: Plenty of parking available.“

“Just had their pizza today for the first time tried 3 different ones and each one was very very good.. will definitely order again and try different pizzas“

“Amazing food and even better people! Cannot recommend this place enough!“

“We love them! Fast, friendly and fabulous! The staff are wonderful, food is awesome and whether it's pick up, dine in or delivery they get it done quickly. Very generous pizza toppings. Salads are great! Lots of great choices on the menu. The steak hoagie is a favorite. The best part is that they support our veterans. You can pay for a meal to "bless a vet" which is a really nice way of giving back.“

“I had the pizza and wings. Excellent. Sauce is a bit on the sweet side but I loved it. The wings shocked me because most pizza places have sub par wings , but Ginos are great. Great quality wing an flavor. My new go to spot in Ligonier.“

“Mondays has always been a favorite of mine! The food has always been great! The staff has always been so friendly. But this week!!!! Let’s talk about it! This week we had to throw together a quick birthday dinner for my daughter, we were running out of options, mondays got back to us with in less than 5 HOURS to get their place set up, and ready for us, our party of 20 arrived and they were so welcoming, open to our suggestions and helped us save a lot of money😂 the staff was on top of it, the food, drinks, service, their smiling faces, everything turned out perfect for us!“

“We live very close, and Only place open on the 4th of July so thanks for that! Friendly staff , nice little market of things you may need when you run out or things for keystone park camping etc. Good pizza, needs more toppings, like cover the half in mushroom, cover the other half pepperoni. We like the soft crust. Sauce is sweeter. Had buffalo wings, a bit too sweet not spicy or buffalo tasting. But nice place , has outdoor seating only. They do deliver. Thanks, will be back again!

Kid-friendliness: Gave my kids candy , staff was nice to my children.“

“I lived in Leechburg and my friend lived in Apollo, anytime we went out and ended up in the Saltsburg area we made it a point to stop at Johns Pizza. Well 2 years ago I moved back to Florida but next month I'm going back to visit and have already made plans to stop at Johns. Can't wait“

“My boys and I have been getting Sanso's pizzas for years. It is definitely my first choice for pizza. And when I used to drink, that's where I'd head for my beer because i felt that it was reasonably priced. The employees are always friendly. The food is consistently good. You can now order & pay online for delivery. And if you want to sit and relax and eat your food at the restaurant, there is a dining area. There's many reasons to love Sanso's in Blairsville!“

“we love the sugar shack. they have really good gobs, cookies, pizza and perogies. The lent fish meal is great too“

“Highly recommend!!! we stopped out tonight for dinner. We tried the 10oz. meatball it was AMAZING! I had a salad my husband had a fish sandwich. the fish unfortunately had an area that wasn't done and they right away fixed it. We don't complain ever and understand it happens but they went above and beyond to apologize!! we underatand it happens. The fried dough bites were positively heaven in your mouth. service was excellent! and we will return again!! ❤️🤗“

“We order here often. Although tonight I had a pleasantly unexpected kindness. I ordered on the app and arrived on time to pick up…normally I’ll deliver but today I decided not to (because funds are tight and a tip wasn’t feasible). They were packed in house and clearly had many orders coming in and out as phones were ringing and box’s and pizza were piling up. They could not find my order, but were sure they made it and assumed it got snagged for delivery. Immediately they told me they’d refund me and have another ready in 10 min. I waited and honestly with how busy they were I didn’t intend to insist on the refund. They brought it out to me where I was waiting and I took it and headed out and figured I wasn’t asking about a refund. I was just thankful it didn’t take too long because the family was hungry. When I got in my car, the Pleasant Unity Pizza app alerted me that I had been refunded!! I am grateful that they are so respectable. For that, I will always return here. Plus WE LOVE THEIR FOOD! Top faves: Italian sub and steak sub, White Pizza, Pierogi Pizza, Buffalo Ranch Chicken Pizza, Taco Pizza, pretty much all their pizza😆Wings Breaded zucchini Hot cheese balls Anyways, thank you PU Pizza!!“

“This is really good pizza! Our usual places were closed on Sunday, so we gave this place a try. Glad we did! I really appreciate the well-seasoned, peppery sauce and quality pepperoni at this pizzeria. They also politely honored our weird request for no cheese. Thanks! :-)“

“Great place to enjoy quality food and receive excellent service from the wait staff. Thanks“

“It’s all good. Try the breakfast pizza.“

“Not only does Fox's Pizza-New Alexandria have great Pizza, Candie and the rest of the staff are the nicest people! They support The New Alexandria Senior Center every single week with Pizza for our Monday Bingo. Thank you so much, it is greatly appreciated. ❤“

“ABSOLUTELY BEST PIZZA IN TOWN“

“Consistent, even negligent service. They make you pay for delivery, sauces, etc only to forget them ALWAYS. I stopped ordering sauces because you charge for and never bring them. Now on an order of 2 simple items, a pizza and a 2 liter of Coke, you forget the Coke? Well, I'm done. Not one more dollar. You have inspired me to utilize any of the five other pizza joints in a 2 mile radius. Wonder why customer loyalty is down? Because loyalty to the customer is zero. Peace.“

“Had the Valentines menu with my wife which was an outstanding deal and had plenty of options. Great service and friendly staff who all pitched in to help a packed house. One of my favorite places.“

“Best pizza I've ever had. Fabulous crust and sauce. It's an hour away for me but I'll be going back often. It's that good!!!!!“

“FANTASTIC customer service, great food and great promo discounts!“

“Ate at Fat Daddys for the first time this evening. got a large pizza and hot cheese balls everything was delicious! our server was really nice and did a great job. sorry I forgot your name..blonde hair definitely will be coming back ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“My first time having lunch at Lucky B's and it won't be the last. My friends and I had the white bean chile and it was awesome. Our waitress was the best. I think her name was Manda..“

“We went as a family on 1/13/2024. We ordered our food and the manager and her husband were super nice. They were running the store themselves. I would go there again!“

“We eat Foxes in Saltsburg at least once a week. Usually hv it delivered, but sometimes pick up. My husband always gets a pepperoni/sausage Stromboli. I get something different everytime. It is ALWAYS GOOD ! As in CONSISTENTLY !!! There is other good food around, BUT not always consistent. That's the key word. We hv had good customer service and delivery. Not too long ago we placed an order, but they did not think they wer gonna b able to do anymore deliveries bcuz the driver was stuck in someone's driveway. We felt bad. We did not want to go out in the very cold, bad weather after a long work day. Being that my husband hs a 4 wheel drive truck and an experienced driver, we sd we would come an get the food. 10 minutes later they called back an sd the driver was unstuck and they could deliver if we still wanted. We wer impressed. Alot of these delivery drivers r young, and not as experienced. They hv not had alot of bad weather growing up to practice. Other than not hvn Calzones, (ricotta). We love and appreciate them.“

“I consider Pizza Sienna to be very good-better than any national chain pizza shop. I am a fan of simple pizza, but the Sienna Pie is my favorite! It is loaded with just the right toppings. Pizzas have a nice crust, ample cheese, sauce, and toppings, and a good blend of flavors!“

“What should have been a great family experience turned out to be a headache-- not a regular headache, but more like a migraine. There were so many issues that I'm not sure where to begin-- the online menu is not the menu presented to us, the waitress had to get simple answers from others (which shows the lack of training). When the waitress asked who ordered the 1 meal, we told her that 2 people ordered that item. About 10 mins later, we questioned when that item would be out and realized that she never put it through, so 1 family member had table scraps for a meal. The seats are ok for comfortability, which is good because we had waited approximately 90+ mins to receive our food. Pizzas were flying out the door, while my young children waited the 90+ mins for their's to land on our table. We waited for our bills-- then waited again because the waitress had to be reminded to take money off the appetizers due to happy hour. Then waited awhile for our bank card... and again to get pens. If you have 2- 3 hours to spare, then this place is a gem, but you're better off going to see a movie then getting dinner elsewhere since it would take the same amount of time 🤷‍♀️“

“good food friendly staff :)“

“Great food and atmosphere! Closes to early and the service is terrible“

“I had a steak and cheese sub looked at it ... Where the beef no meat at all this was in latrobe and ordered a large pizza pepperoni mushrooms and banaña peppers. Hardly any toppings at all 31 dollars. Never again.“

“Always a great pizza when I get it from here. The staff are friendly and fast to get you your order as fast as they can. The pizzas are loaded with toppings and are baked to perfection with just the right balance of chew and a crispy crunch. Highly recommend coming here for your pizza fix.“

“An excellent gem hidden in Blairsville. Service and food were excellent. We sat outside, and it was perfect. Had the bruschetta for an appetizer and the spaghetti pesto. I took some pasta home so I could have room for the amaretto cheesecake. We’ll be back!“

“I love spaghetti with meat sauce. Their meat and sauce was superb! The meatball was tasty, but the sausage was amazing. It was all perfection & delicious!
The wedding soup was extraordinary and the breaded provolone cheese sticks were the best I've ever tasted!“

“Had a great meal and a wonderful server Noah. Thanks!!“