39 Best Pizza Restaurants near New London

“Great food. Everything that I've tried is delicious. My favorite local place to order food from.“

“We stop in once a week. Sometimes we eat there and sometimes we call and pick up. The atmosphere is fabulous. If we ever do have to wait for our food, it’s totally worth it. If my husband and I are together we sit and have wine while we wait. They are all very friendly! If we get take out, we always get extra so we can have leftovers, which are always delicious. We reheat the pizza in the toaster oven, it’s amazing. We also love the desserts there! It’s just a great spot and we love it! I’ve never once been disappointed with any of their service or food.“

“Great food and great service!“

“Took grandkids to 896 Pie today after a swim in the pool. Great service and amazing pizza. Brent is the owner and he was so friendly and engaged with his customers. All the grandkids and two adults enjoyed the perfectly cooked pizza. Thanks for a great visit“

“The gluten free pizza is delicious and safe for those with even the most gluten sensitivity! Highly recommend!“

“First time trying this place and it was amazing! We had a friendly, attentive server. He checked in with us many times, refilling our drinks and chatting with us. The garlic bread, salad and Pizza was absolutely amazing!! Can’t wait to go back again.“

“Going to Tony's is always a wonderful experience. The owners and staff are amazingly warm and friendly. And of course, the food is mouth watering delicious; the very best around.“

“New Garden cheestake the best“

“My mother, daughter and myself went for breakfast this morning to celebrate my daughter’s 14th birthday before school. The food was fantastic, the service was amazing and they even decorated my daughter’s waffle and topped with a candle. We come here often for their pizza, sandwiches, and my daughter believes they have the best chicken fingers around.“

“Awesome food and service. Great people too. 5 stars.“

“We live in Newark De but were in the area and stopped for lunch. So glad we did. The food was delicious, fresh and the portions were huge. We will be back when in the area again and will definitely consider for any catering needs in the future. Highly recommend.“

“We came here on a random Friday looking for simple Italian food and we were not disappointed! We got a Stromboli and a chicken eggplant salad, both very generous and delicious.
Staff was also on point !
-> Be aware small card surcharge“

“❤️Oh my goodness! We’ve always loved Casa Italia. Their food is delicious, and their staff are very friendly and courteous. They are our go-to restaurant for ordering pizza and more. So when I saw a FB post asking about pizza place recommendations of course I said Casa Italia! 🙌🏻 🍕 Then tonight we placed a pizza order and what a sweet gift! Surprise Cannolis! 🌸If you haven’t ordered from Casa Italia yet, you’re missing out! Not only is their menu fantastic, but they truly care about their customers. We love Casa Italia!“

“We tried Margherita's for the first time today and it was absolutely amazing! Staff was very friendly! We got mild wings, pizza, salad, chicken fingers and fries! it all was delicious! we will be back!!“

“It was really good thanks!“

“Love the team at Pasquales Pizza in Cochranville! Michael and Peter and the staff are so personable. It's like coming home to a family dinner without having to cook or clean up. The taste of the ole-country is here! If you haven't grabbed a pizza, a cheese steak, a cannoli, from Pasquales, you are missing out on a quintessential Chester County dining experience. Every night doesn't need to be a black-tie affair. Grab your date, and a pizza, and enjoy the best in local casual dining & take-out. The online ordering works pretty well too! <3 Tracey & Drew Cope <3“

“The Stromboli was pretty good and didn’t hurt the pocket“

“Good pizza! Also nice that’s it’s a family run business where everyone contributes. Very nice folks.“

“If your ever in southern Chester County in PA and you want to take a break from driving through mushroom country, come get a slice of delicious pizza made and cut by nicest people on the planet. The pizza is hot and delicious and I would definetly come back!“

“I give them a five star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating. I always knew this little shop was tucked in this shopping plaza but I never ever tried. Well let me just say I was missing out. I’ve now tried several different items and different pizzas and all of them have been delicious. You gotta try the BBQ beef cheesesteak (add extra meat and extra cheese) and BBQ chicken pizza. Wow 👍👍. I can tell they get slammed with takeout and delivery orders. Great staff. They’re my new go to.“

“This place really is something special. Not only do they have the best vegetable stromboli I've ever had, they're also one of the friendliest and most welcoming restaurants I've ever eaten in.
The atmosphere is very old school pizza spot, which is hard to find now days. They always seem to be doing something for the community every time we visit, right now it's a Christmas toy drive which is awesome. We need more places like this everywhere.
If you haven't been yet, I definitely suggest going to Brothers, get a boli! I'll be returning soon so I'll included photos next time.“

“Delicious Italian hoagies!“

“great food, great service! a local staple in the community“

“Best pizza & customer service in town! We love it!“

“stoll as good as it was 20 years ago when I was eating it for study fuel!“

“Ordered delivery while in Elkton on business. Food was delivered quick, hot and delicious. Had the pasta, steak sandwich, and chicken rice soup....All delicious and will order again when back in town or passing through...“

“Great food and atmosphere!!“

“Great food! Great people!“

“Great drinks, good food, fabulous staff. The crowd always rocks! Supports local live music! Ride the Goat loves playing this venue!“

“Ordered delivery. Person on the phone was polite, order arrived quickly, food was good and it was still hot. Granted, a tad over priced. I dont know why its saying I rated the sevice 3/5. I have it a 5 star and the food a 5 star
P.S., I didnt have a card or a ride when I ordered so thank heavens!! A place you can CALL and pay with cash for delivery !“

“Just face it most of the pizza in Pennsylvania is God awful. I am from New York so I know what I’m talking about. If you disagree with me it doesn’t matter because no matter what you are wrong. Bravo is ONE OF TWO places that I can honestly say the pizza is up to NY standards. The cheese is high quality
(Grande probably) and the pizza dough is spectacular. The guys behind the counter are so nice and bust their behinds so you can eat well. Show your appreciation for the good food and hard work Bravo provides. Love your pizza guys! Makes me feel like I’m home! Thanks so much!!

Vegetarian options: Get a salad, get some pasta, get some cheese pizza, it’s a pizza shop! Of course there a vegetarian options!

Parking: No problem

Kid-friendliness: Of course! It’s a traditional pizza shop. Every kid should be so lucky to have a regular pizza shop to go to.

Wheelchair accessibility: Absolutely no problem for people who use wheelchairs.“

“always satisfied with our meals, never feel like we do not get our money's worth, even on some more expensive options. homemade pasta is wonderful! highly recommend the blush sauce! Our Date nights there are great from salad to dessert!“

“tonight we got dinner from here. the lady was the only one there and she was handling everything. we did not have a long wait time and the food is great! i wish she had help. but she seriously needs a raise!“

“Second time ordering from here, food is fresh pizza is very good, and buffalo wings were good ,excellent service great customer service.“

“I ordered a build your own stromboli with 1 ingredient wrong and was mad at myself for forgetting the ingredient and settled for what I was getting. The manager said no I'll make you a new one I want you to be happy. I couldn't believe it it. When it arrived it was amazing so I highly recommend this seasons 5 stars“

“Got an awesome half bushel of crabs steamed to perfection yesterday!“

“I was so excited to move to Maryland and find out Nick and Joe's were still in business. N &J was the spot to hit if you went to the Castle Mall.
I have decided to redo my previous review because I never read the reviews before and it looks as if someone is out to sabotage N&J REVIEWS. That is not fair because this is somebodys family who has worked hard for over 50 years. The one thing I will agree with is the girl who answers the phone ,sure does not like her job, she is rude and doesn't like for you to ask questions about anything. I've only ordered delivery because of a car accident so I can't speak on the establishment atmosphere itself. I know back in the day we loved going in because they would speak Italian and we would bring our friend who spoke Italian and the things they would say that they didn't know we could here were crazy stories we loved to eavesdropin. They also loved beautiful woman who they would also speak about but in a great way.
I can tell by reading the reviews and comments that have been on here lately are being made from someone that has a grudge against them and are having people that I'm sure never been there to put bad reviews up. I would ask people to go there themselves and form your own opinion. I've had things not up to par but nothing to do with the taste and quality of the food. I would not being going there for 50 yeara if the food tasted the way the reviews said. I hope in the future people leave an honest review because even if you don't have your own business karma will get you another way . Good luck in the future Nick and Joes ... maybe just critique a few things and maybe have the phone person who is the first representative of your business go to a customer service training course on line because her attitude could already set somebody's 2mind to having a bad experience so then they look at every point of service with not so rose colored glassesI wish your nothing but the best and I just ordered your 2 medium pizza specials one with jalapenos... face 5 star for atmosphere because I'm not going to give bad stars for something idk about
.“

“It's a college bar, and you get what you expect. Dirty floor and the atmosphere is clearly catered to 21 year olds. That being said, Grotto's wings are always solid and the grand slam sauce brings it home. The pizza is plain but is done so consistently you always know you can count on the taste and texture. Would definitely recommend if you want to go watch a game and enjoy some quick food.“