35 Best Pizza Restaurants near New London

“Ordered door dash from this place on Christmas Eve since it was the only pizzeria still open at the time. The pizza was absolutely delicious. Thin crust and cooked just right. Unfortunately I live a little far away from this place but it might just be worth the drive because the pizza was so good.“

“A fancy dining meal without the fancy dining cost, with a relaxed atmosphere. I really love they use local sourced ingredients as available. Fresh made and very delicious. Ordered their pizza and it was beautiful as it was tasty. Will be returning for future meals.“

“We stop in once a week. Sometimes we eat there and sometimes we call and pick up. The atmosphere is fabulous. If we ever do have to wait for our food, it’s totally worth it. If my husband and I are together we sit and have wine while we wait. They are all very friendly! If we get take out, we always get extra so we can have leftovers, which are always delicious. We reheat the pizza in the toaster oven, it’s amazing. We also love the desserts there! It’s just a great spot and we love it! I’ve never once been disappointed with any of their service or food.“

“This place is absolutely amazing! Have gone here my whole life living right down the street and wouldn’t go anywhere else! They were so understanding when we came I five minutes before closing as were still able to whip out a whole cheese stake, pie, and more! Absolutely amazing costumer service and the most delicious food in the area! So nice to have a family run business who will always got the extra mile!“

“Took grandkids to 896 Pie today after a swim in the pool. Great service and amazing pizza. Brent is the owner and he was so friendly and engaged with his customers. All the grandkids and two adults enjoyed the perfectly cooked pizza. Thanks for a great visit“

“It was a dinner date with my husband.We received free bread upon request. It was perfect with the sauce. We ordered "Baked Salmon", "Beef Brasato" as main dish and Nightly Special "Shrimp Scampi" as sides and "Tiramisu" for dessert.Overall, We loved the food.“

“Best roast beef subs on the planet!!!“

“Best Turkey Reuben with all the fixings. THE BEST!“

“Stopped in for a slice of pizza. Big Z is located in a shopping center near the University but there is plenty of parking. They had a two slice with drink special on the weekend which was added bonus. The pizza wasn't bad. The crust was a little more crispy than I would like.“

“We live in Newark De but were in the area and stopped for lunch. So glad we did. The food was delicious, fresh and the portions were huge. We will be back when in the area again and will definitely consider for any catering needs in the future. Highly recommend.“

“Very cute place. We stopped for lunch when my son had an Orthodontist appointment next door. Food was very good. The house dressing was so good. The pizza was perfect. Nice crust and the sauce was delicious. This will be our new stop for lunch after the orthodontist.Parking: Nice lot next to buildingKid-friendliness: Cute small dinning room. Maybe difficult for a stroller.“

“ABSOLUTELY LOVE CASA ITALIA! It's always my recommendation for my loved ones looking to dine in this area. The employees are amazing..they are polite and professional. The owners are incredible they really know how to make you feel like family! The food is great every single time.“

“Delicious pizza! Friendly staff!“

“This review was originally posted on the Kennett Square Community Facebook page and it got removed by the moderators. I hope that the owner of Lilianas reads this and knows that the Kennett Square Community Facebook page is removing good reviews of your restaurant. You may want to look into that. Here is my review for the world so that everyone knows how amazing the chicken wings are at Lilianas: Folks, we need to talk about the gastronomic glory, the taste bud tantalization, the scrumptious, soul-satisfying, finger-lickin' ambrosial delight of Liliana's wings. First of all, as I always like to point out, I'm originally from Delco, where the chicken wing wars wage hot and heavy every day of the week. I've seen people almost coming to blows over wing debates, so I'm well-versed in the main requirements of what wing connoisseurs are looking for. First, the wings have to be meaty. They have to be large. They have to be crispy, but they also have to be juicy. They have to be steamy, but the steam can't impart one iota of softness to the skin. While the skin can't be soft, it also can't be, in any way, hard. At the same time, the crunch should be heard across the room. The wings can't be remotely slimy, but they also can't be remotely dry. The meat should cling to the bone, but it should also release from the bone effortlessly when called upon to do so by human teeth. Think of a yin/yang symbol representing all things present in perfect harmony. The wings have to be reasonably priced (well, maybe moreso in Delco than here in fancy-pants Chesco, but I digress.) And of course, it is not just the wings themselves, but the sauce, that is also of utmost importance. It has to be homemade. It must have the right amount of heat. There must be a perfect ratio of butter to other seasonings. It must cling to every exposed surface area and every nook and wing cranny, but it also can't be too thick. At the same time, it most definitely can't be runny in any way, shape or form. There must be a variety of flavors from which to choose. Well, Neighbors (and travelers to our community), let me tell you something. Lilianas knocks it out of the park on all counts, with no exceptions. We went last night right after the awesome community tree-lighting event in Toughkenamon. This was our first time at Lilianas, so we had no idea what to expect. We were greeted warmly and seated immediately. Upon opening the menu, I noticed right away that they offer individual wings for $1.50 apiece. This is fantastic because it allows for a lot of variety, and the prices are commensurate with other wing offerings in our area. I wanted to go OG hot, but I also wanted to try Lilianas house sauce, so I ordered two of those and two of the Hot. They came out on separate plates, stacked delicately like in a five-star restaurant, and glistening under a veritable river of each sauce, which pooled and spread out to cover 90% of their eight inch plates. "Uh oh," I thought. "That's way too much sauce. They're going to be soggy." But au contraire! I picked one with the house sauce and crunched into it. The flavor blasted through my taste buds like an exploding rocket and activated the pleasure centers in my brain, releasing a deluge of feel-good chemicals as bountiful as the sauce on the plate. After closing my eyes and practically reenacting Meg Ryan's deli scene in When Harry Met Sally, I calmed down for a couple of minutes to check out what ingredients could create such a reaction. I'm sure the recipe is proprietary, but I do know it's like a combination of a garlic-parmesan wing, a hot wing, and an Italian herb wing all wrapped into one, with a LOT of vinegar. The hot wings were legit hot, also with tons of delicious vinegar flavor. For those who love highly seasoned, uber intense, heavy on the vinegar sauces, both of these sauces should be your go-to picks. I am kicking myself for not ordering the sweet chili and the mild as well. The wings I tried check EVERY box lis“

“My boss picks up food from there at least two to three times a week and on occasions he brings me pizza meatballs and spaghetti with meat sauceits great I live right in the back of it I love the food it's absolutely great the service is great the owner and everyone there is absolutely the best I would rate at the best pizza restaurant“

“Delicious pizza with the best fresh, homemade sausage! The Caesar salad was a great addition to share with the pizza.Parking: The pizza is worth the parking. I recommend taking a right out of the parking lot during rush hour. Other times of day it's easier.“

“Man, this was the first pizza place on the east coast I went to when I got to Delaware. Now I'm ruined for pizza when I get back to west coast. They make a damn good pie. I know, i know I'm normally the Mexican food nacho guy, who am I to comment on pizza...I'm fat...that's my credentials. And I got fat on pizza long before I discovered my love of nachos. Their menu is huge. Pizzas, sandwiches, Stromboli, salads, burgers. If you're craving something they make it. And they deliver to. But they're not open Sundays. They have a great speed of service, and the prices are so affordable. A real value for the portions. And the staff are quite nice. It doesn't have a whole lot of indoor seating so get what you're getting to go or delivered.“

“Love the team at Pasquales Pizza in Cochranville! Michael and Peter and the staff are so personable. It's like coming home to a family dinner without having to cook or clean up. The taste of the ole-country is here! If you haven't grabbed a pizza, a cheese steak, a cannoli, from Pasquales, you are missing out on a quintessential Chester County dining experience. Every night doesn't need to be a black-tie affair. Grab your date, and a pizza, and enjoy the best in local casual dining & take-out. The online ordering works pretty well too! <3 Tracey & Drew Cope <3“

“tonight we got dinner from here. the lady was the only one there and she was handling everything. we did not have a long wait time and the food is great! i wish she had help. but she seriously needs a raise!“

“More than a bar. The food is really good. I have been providing Music Bingo for a couple months now and eating every so often. The pizza is really good. It's a definite contender for great Pizza. The cheese steak is really good as well. One of my favorites now. Nice large soft roll and super stuffed! Same with the French dip. Large portions! All three of those are above avg in my book. I have had a few other meals as well that have all been good. Great friendly service as well as guests have been welcoming. Wish I would have discovered the food when I lived closer. But a definite stop if I'm in the area and hungry!“

“The good is really good, at a nice price. Drinks are moderately priced, and the service is very good. Very good live music with a good size dance floor. There are several pool tables and a decent amount of seating. There is parking directly across the street. A short walk to get it it...definitely recommend going there and checking it out for yourself.“

“I miss when D.P. Dough was on Main Street, but I like that it is still in a walkable spot elsewhere in town. This is a great place that is fast food but still healthier than a lot of fast food, especially if you get stuff with some vegetables in them. Their bell peppers and tomatoes are usually quite fresh. This place has a reputation as a place stoners go when they get munchies, and although I will say this reputation is well-deserved, it can also be appreciated by people who don't use marijuana as well, so regardless of where you are on that usage spectrum, I would still recommend this place. The prices here are pretty decent; they haven't gone up as much as most fast food places have, and I think they are outright low compared to a similar volume and quality of food from most restaurants. The only minor complaint I have is that the past two times I've been in here, it wasn't super clean. Not like gross or anything, just the tables were a bit greasier than I'd like and there were a bit more crumbs around. I like the kinda dark, cozy atmosphere, good for coming here late night. I hate how many restaurants have really bright, harsh lighting. This place feels better to me, kinda toned down.“

“Good staff, fast turnaround, fresh made food, good atmosphere for its size, friendly owner, and good portions. Tables are clean and the place is well maintained. Definitely going to be my go to spot for a meal.Parking: Parking is convenient, inexpensive, and close.“

“I have been going here with my wife for years. They have never disappointed us.Good food & good attitudes. I am more than happy to support these guys every time I am back around West Grove.It's obvious when a small pizza shop is buying good ingredients, you can always taste the difference.Highly recommend:the StromboliPlain Jane pizzaChx fingers & specifically the way they make their boneless Buffalo fingers.We have not tried any app that we found disappointing on the menu.Thank you for never letting us down on a Friday night when we were too tired to cook coming back from WG!Keep up the good work guys!“

“Second time I have ordered from them and they never disappoint! I figured I’d have at least a hour wait since it’s Super Bowl Sunday and food was delivered to me in about 25 minutes! I highly recommend them to anyone that’s looking for an excellent pizza shop.“

“First time trying this place and it was amazing! We had a friendly, attentive server. He checked in with us many times, refilling our drinks and chatting with us. The garlic bread, salad and Pizza was absolutely amazing!! Can’t wait to go back again.“

“I'm gonna give this place five stars, the people are friendly and family oriented. Some of their sandwiches and their Gyro are fantastic. The tzatziki sauce is excellent and I would strongly recommend all of their subs, including cheesesteaks.“

“If you're looking for an amazing pizza experience in Nottingham, look no further than Original Nottingham Pizza. This place truly knows how to create a pizza that is both delicious and satisfying.One of the first things you'll notice about Original Nottingham Pizza is the fantastic quality of their ingredients. From the crispy crust to the tangy tomato sauce, everything is fresh and bursting with flavor. And the toppings? They are plentiful and expertly chosen, ensuring that each bite is a true taste sensation.But it's not just the pizza that's worth raving about. The barrria, which is a Mexican dish made with slow-cooked beef, is absolutely fantastic. The meat is tender and full of flavor, and the accompanying toppings and sauces are just the right balance of spicy and tangy.And let's not forget about the tacos. Not only are they delicious, but they are also very reasonably priced. You'll definitely want to try the different varieties, as each one is unique and flavorful in its own way.But what really sets Original Nottingham Pizza apart is their commitment to quality and service. The staff are friendly, attentive, and always happy to help you choose the perfect pizza or taco. And the cozy, welcoming atmosphere of the restaurant makes it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a delicious meal.In conclusion, if you're in the mood for some seriously good pizza and Mexican cuisine, Original Nottingham Pizza is the place to be. With top-notch ingredients, expertly crafted dishes, and friendly service, this restaurant is truly a gem in the heart of Nottingham. Don't miss out on this amazing dining experience!“

“We tried Margherita's for the first time today and it was absolutely amazing! Staff was very friendly! We got mild wings, pizza, salad, chicken fingers and fries! it all was delicious! we will be back!!“

“Called ahead and placed an order for 5 pizzas for my mountain biker boyfriend and his friends. Showed up early to pick up and they were damn near ready early!! They gave me all 5 pizzas, plates and napkins. As I was getting everything together to leave, several people offered to carry out the pizzas, I declined because I am just simply stubborn and knew they were busy. Finally I caved and said that one middle aged gentleman could open my car door. Just then a young man named keegan(hoping I’m spelling that correctly) sprung into action and said I just simply can’t let you carry those!! Grabbed them and then stood by the door to open that for me as well!! What an incredible young man, whoever raised him did good!!! We need more of that kid in this world!! Thank you Mario’s for everyone from start to finish being awesome and Keegan keep up the good work!!“

“One of the only ma and pa shops left. They make the best sandwiches for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The soups, pasta salads and desserts are all homemade. You can always expect a hot cup of coffee in the morning and swing by for a great milkshake in the afternoon. Always amazing oysters and crabs!“

“The sauce is on point, the bread is on point, the cheese is OnPoint, the grease is even on point, the little strips that look like onions that are actually sausage strips is on point. get the small size pizza Half cheese, half pepperoni sausage.The garlic knots are good and cheap .65 cents . Easy walk across the grass to wawa. You can’t miss this place. This is the itThe girls and staff are funny tooDietary restrictions: Seemed flexible“

“We stopped at lunch to get a slice of pizza and a meatball sandwich. The pizza was good - nothing to make it stand out from many other places, but definitely worth getting again . The meatball sandwich was smaller than most places but was also less expensive and came with fries. Overall, a much better deal. I wish they had a lunch deal that included two slices of pizza and a soda, but alas, a special that is common to many places does not exist here. The eating area is spacious and comfortable.“

“Honestly shocked at how delicious the pasta dishes are, considering it's a pizza place first and foremost. The chicken was so tender and yet also crispy. There was plenty of cheese provided, and the sauces were perfect. The garlic knots that came with the pasta were like fluffy clouds of buttery garlic. Absolutely wonderful and affordable!Only complaint would be that the formal dining area was closed and the TV in the informal dining was pretty loud - but it was playing sports.“

“I stopped in for a chef salad and it was delicious. Everything was crisp and fresh, no soggy at all. The egg was so orange and it actually had flavor you could definitely tell it was local fresh eggs!“