Pizza Restaurants near Newburg

“Millennial truck driver here, came in at 4pm after parking to get some pizza. From start to finish on buying pizza only took 3 minutes. I ordered three slices of cheese pizza which I'm assuming was literally just made, 1 large coke and 3 pieces of pizza was $19 which hurts the heart but its a turnpike restaurant, what else can you expect, I'm surprised they didn't charge as much as the turnpike charges me to drive my semi on it which was $250 today.“

“We moved to Shippensburg in 2022 and had been looking for the best pizza place in the area. Who knew it’d be right here in town? Great pizza and prices. Staff is super friendly. No skimping on the yummy cheese or toppings and a great sauce. Love it!“

“pizzas are great, staff goes above and beyond.“

“Great place for some good pie.
Very nice staff and can remember your order after 2 times being there (I was impressed). Depending on time a year parking can be a challenge but don't let that stop you. My opinion best pizza in the burg.“

“SHOUT OUT TO CAMERIYN. She was an excellent delivery driver. Super kind and appreciative and she just really made me feel good expressing how grateful she was for the tip. I am a good tipper and most drivers from anywhere that come to my house say nothing about the good tip I just gave. She acknowledged it and was such a kind sweet young lady. Anyone who reads this...please tip your drivers appropriately. They work hard and they are in a tipping profession so please reward them with a nice tip.“

“Went to this place because the mexican restaurant next door sucked. The decoration I thought was wonderful, especially the TV showing videos of flowers. Mac and Cheese Bites came to us super hot (yay!) and were awesome but pizza was even better!! Longest cheese pull btw. Guy that served us was doing a good job He deserves a raise just because why not? Anyway 5/5 stars on every part!!!!(we hate u mexican restaurant next door)“

“I can't speak on atmosphere as I've only had delivery. I'm in town for a couple of weeks for work. This place does not disapoint! Fast free delivery. Salads are amazing! Pizza is amazing and the prices are way more reasonable than in FL. They top the other places in the area for sure!!“

“Incredible menu and Real Italian dishes with home made flavors and fresh ingredients
This is more than a “pizza joint”
that serves pasta
Menu has lots of choices for young and old with Old World recipes and fresh ingredients“

“John, one of the managers at the Shippensburg store was amazing! He was respectful and took good care of my order and me. I'm an over the road trucker and not alot of places deal very kindly with us. The fact that he was so awesome means alot to me. That man needs a raise!“

“Love the pepperoni tavern pizza“

“Our server was outstanding. She took care of us the night before and is the reason we went back. Unfortunately for the restaurant, she is graduating and leaving to start a career. People make a difference. Bonus - the prime rib was one of the best I've ever had“