11 Best Italian Restaurants near Pocono Pines

“Me and my husband ate here tonight and we ordered a large pie with mushrooms and pepperoni along with an Italian Stromboli. Thanks to Debbie for recommending the mushrooms, this place takes an extra step in using fresh mushrooms adding seasoning and cooking them first then placed on pizza. It was delicious!!! We will definitely be back. Thank you 😁“

“Food was very well prepared and our waitress Hellen A. Was very attentive and kind hearted to my family and I, we are very much appreciative and will be recommending her and Sortino’s to many of my friends in the area of the Poconos“

“The pizza is delicious!!!“

“It’s great food, great atmosphere, perfect music and great service. It’s our favorite restaurant.“

“This is the best Pizza in the Poconos! I rate a 8.5 on the Pepperoni Slice. Though I haven’t did an official review that is the score I would give. The Penne Ala vodka is the most authentic Ala vodka ! The people pissing and moaning either don’t know real Italian food or they just wanna cry! Either way get a tissue and a slice idk.“

“Ordered a white stuffed pizza yesterday. Suggestion: More mozzarella cheese in the crust, thicker crust, cooked a little longer so the crust is crispy! Put it on the menu, and name it after me LOL“

“Very friendly staff, great food. The only complaint, my pizza had a very floury bottom, which left a floor aftertaste. Not too pleasant, but the pizza was flavorful and well cooked. Two subs, super fresh rolls, not toasted. All and all a nice Italian joint! They do sit down service, I didn't utilize, but noticed the server was very attentive and pleasant to her customers.“

“One of the Best restaurants I’ve been to in over 6 years living here!“

“awesome experience Leila is the best !!“

“I love the food here. Truly amazing service and counter staff is wonderful and very helpful when I don’t know something. She is very nice and very knowledgeable. I would recommend mikes to anyone in the area who is looking for a good dinner and a good night. Great family like environment. Love it here!!!!“

“I can only speak on a single slice that was a re-heat and I am due to return and try out some more stuff. I stopped in December of 2021 so as you can see, it's been quite some time since then and I need to get back up there and do a re-visit. The guy behind the counter was pretty much a typical pizza place employee...not what I'd call "friendly", not unfriendly...just adequate. Maybe 6-8 tables inside but mostly geared towards takeout.

So a slice and a soda was over $6, so that was a bit concerning out of the gate, but I don't just based on stuff like that solely. I enjoyed the slice. There was a nice char underneath which I love, good snap to the crust, it was nice and thin, good cheese to sauce ratio. Not much else I can really say about it other than I'm due to head back in. If you're just looking for a slice though, Brother Bruno's - DIdn't Suck!“