33 Best Italian Restaurants near Tannersville

“I haven’t been there yet, but after hearing this lovely story of how wonderfully honest and kind the owners are and hearing so many stories of how delicious the food is I will definitely be stopping by!!!“

“My family and I ate at Volare we had a great experience the food was delicious i grew up italian my parents are phenomenal cook so when it comes to going out to dinner, I usually don't like to pick Italian restaurants, but I'm so glad that we went here. The food was delicious and fresh, including the dessert. I was hoping to post pictures to this review that I took, but unfortunately they're not loading. Highly recommend this restaurant. We had chicken Parmesan, which my son had and he loved I had pasta and clams and again it was fresh and delicious for appetizers. We had octopus, which was fresh. The baked clams were delicious Looking forward to going back“

“The absolute BEST PIZZA!! But was it just pizza? No, no it was so much more than a slice of pizza. I was dancing in the restaurant while whole heartedly enjoying the slice of one of the best slices of pizza I have ever had! I barely made it to the table before the slice was in my hands! We ate in the restaurant but ment to take it to go! If that’s not an indication of how good the pizza was I don’t know what else to say. Before I could leave out of the door into the snow to let the employees finish cleaning without my dancing and mmmmm’s being a distraction I am walking to the exit with pizza still in hand because I could not put the slice down!!!! All the while calling a friend that lives nearby for him to order pizza for himself ! Would rate 10/10 already have recommended and trying to figure out any excuse to come back from Ohio immediately“

“First time visiting this shop! Absolutely delicious, best bread in the area for sure 💜 bada -bing sandwich is sooooo good ! Will be back for sure :)“

“We stayed at the Chateau during a winter storm. It was pretty bad out, so we decided to eat at Mountainview. I was a bit hesitant because of the reviews. However, I was pleasantly surprised. The restaurant was busy. The bartender was also the only waitress. Although she was extremely busy, she was also extremely proficient. Our cups never went empty. We did have to wait longer than expected for our food, but given the circumstances, we understood. Our food was actually very tasty with a nice presentation! I will visit again!“

“Grazie Nicola! Another AMAZING dinner. You never disappoint. The food was spectacular! My son chose to eat at Momentos for his 21st birthday. The best birthday dinner, (his words). We have been coming for over 20 years, in the days of the pizzeria. We are so proud of you and your hard work, creativity and devotion to your art. We will see you soon! From Chef Nina.“

“All staff members were very friendly, food was delicious, and I love the Main Street vibe! My son has a gluten allergy - their GF pizza was great!! If we end up in that area again, we will definitely go back!!“

“Did a pick up order. Chicken Alfredo, chocolate lasagna cake and minestrone soup. Everything was delicious. Didn’t take long to get my order. The only issue was they put my chocolate dessert in the same bag with the hot food so I had to quickly remove it so it didn’t melt more.“

“My family and I had an excellent dinner here! Everything was absolutely delicious! I would definitely come back!“

“My Uncle asked me to order a few catered items for my dad's memorial on 7/22 that he graciously paid for. I chose Carrazza's mainly because it's local. We ordered F/T's of baked ziti, meatballs, chicken marsala and green beans. I could not believe I had a minimum of 8 guests rave about their meatballs, all asking if I had made them. My sisters both received compliments as well. I heard 'these meatballs are the best I ever had', 'they are fantastic', 'get me the recipe' and 'I hope you don't think I am a pig but I gotta grab some more of these delicious meatballs'. All of the food we ordered was delicious, but I have to say... I am considering ordering a tray of meatballs to freeze in meal sized portions for my husband and I. It will make dinners easier for me with less work and less waste. Thank you Mike for all of your help, patience and kindness.“

“LUV THERE PIZZA ! GREAT PEOPLE! GOOD SERVICE !!“

“It’s great food, great atmosphere, perfect music and great service. It’s our favorite restaurant.“

“Mike’s has the BEST CHEESESTEAKS!!!! We were traveling and stopped in for lunch and were very impressed with Mike’s, our server Mary Margaret 😍 and our out-of- this world Cheesesteak Sandwich!!! We highly recommend Mike’s Italian Restaurant. Rosemary and Tom. Lake Naomi.“

“Food was very well prepared and our waitress Hellen A. Was very attentive and kind hearted to my family and I, we are very much appreciative and will be recommending her and Sortino’s to many of my friends in the area of the Poconos“

“We ordered fried calamari for an appetizer it was cooked perfectly! Since it was our fist time here we decided to try the Mamma Maria’s Special pizza which was delicious and they definitely did not skimp on the toppings!!! We also ordered a chicken cheese steak with peppers onions and mushrooms had amazing flavor! Last we got two cannolis to go and they were the best cannolis we’ve ever had. Great service and food came out fast! We were only in the area for the weekend if we are to ever return to the area we would definitely come back here again!!“

“Food is phenomenal and staff is super friendly“

“We loved our dinner here, from super fresh salad bar with lovely pastas, 2 homemade soups, stuffed shrimp that was fresh as oceanside and perfectly cooked & seasoned steak! This chef is raising the bar here, so check out this up and coming restaurant gem!“

“excellent food and good people!“

“We’re not from the area and this restaurant came highly recommended for the best pizza around.

We came here on a Friday night. There weren’t many single slices available. But our awesome waitress said we could get a whole specialty pizza and do 2 different types. So we did that and we’re glad we did. We had leftovers the next night! The price was more than fair. About $20 for a specialty pizza and 2 sodas. Wow!!!

We didn’t get to try any craft beer but that had plenty to choose from! Nice atmosphere. We would definitely come back if we’re in the area again!“

“Ordered a white stuffed pizza yesterday. Suggestion: More mozzarella cheese in the crust, thicker crust, cooked a little longer so the crust is crispy! Put it on the menu, and name it after me LOL“

“awesome experience Leila is the best !!“

“The best. I moved down to Easton and just haven’t been able to find anything that compares.“

“Great place! definitely worth a visit!“

“Friendly people very cool interior food was outstanding highly recommend this place and the portions are huge we will be back“

“One of the Best restaurants I’ve been to in over 6 years living here!“

“The food was excellent. The server sucked never got my bread with my dinner.my husband was asked if would like another drink,answered yes. She didn't come back till he was finished eating without the drink, said she got busy. Yet I seen her on her phone.Never asked if everything was okay . Asked for a take out container. Waiting 15 mins for one. That girl will bring you business down.“

“By far the best pizza in the area! Always hot and fresh! just wish the other pleasant server was there!“

“this family has been feeding me since I was a kid....but it's been said the Gilliland family and the Polumbos go back together since prohibition in NYC to the Poconos“

“Great pizza and wonderful staff.“

“Amazing pizza! best in the area.. Fresh and delicious and very consistent. Never got a bad pie. Always Amazing.“

“I was a auto mechanic at ray price ford on 940 near mt pocono in 1992 when I first met Roberto he made me a cheesesteak that was out of this world and now I live in Hanover Township and I still go there with my family for dinner and that cheesesteak hero I rate him a10 Nick Nipitella 👍👍👍🍺🍺“

“i’m so obsessed with this spot. bono’s has literally the best pizza in the area and i will not settle for anything less!!! they have such good deals and they are sooo incredibly kind. it’s so rare to find a place that is not only affordable but delicious too.
i’m writing this while eating their pizza and it never fails to hit the spot.
i love love love you guys! 🥹🫶🏼“

“I’m a New Yorker and I recommend this Pizza 🍕 spot.
Clean environment to dine in
Hot fresh pizza
The Garlic knot is great and very garlicky indeed as should be with raw Garlic 🧄
I’ll dine here again when out here and in need of a slice or two.
Not forgetting all the pepper flakes and herb jars all filled to the top to add to your slices if needed.
They also have beers 🍻 and different juices and soda at cold to enjoy of your choice with your meal.“