26 Best Italian Restaurants near Wind Gap

“The best gluten free pizza I've ever had!! 👍🍕❤ Omg! SO SO good!!“

“Lord, have mercy, we think ya'll have the BEST sausage and green pepper pizza 🍕“

“Great place for good Italian food. Tina and Mama Rose are full of energy and make you feel like you’re sitting in their kitchen. The meals are deliciously. We will be back for sure! Bravo!!!!“

“hey! i was the kid that said i was going to give this pace a 5 star review! also, the food is SOOOO good!! This was like, the best pizza i have ever tasted arguably! the servers and employees were very kind, the halloween decorations look awesome, from the table i was seated at, there was a very pretty view! i recommend people to come here!“

“Grazie Nicola! Another AMAZING dinner. You never disappoint. The food was spectacular! My son chose to eat at Momentos for his 21st birthday. The best birthday dinner, (his words). We have been coming for over 20 years, in the days of the pizzeria. We are so proud of you and your hard work, creativity and devotion to your art. We will see you soon! From Chef Nina.“

“Had a great dinner here. Everything was hot and fresh, the atmosphere was amazing and it was really clean inside. I think it might be the best italian restaurant in the Bath area.“

“All staff members were very friendly, food was delicious, and I love the Main Street vibe! My son has a gluten allergy - their GF pizza was great!! If we end up in that area again, we will definitely go back!!“

“I appreciated the friendliness from the wait staff. The food was of good quality and quantity for a reasonable price. I had the steak calzone with onions and recommend ordering it, however the personal pan size portion was so large that I only ate half and took the other half to go. Yesterday (March 25, 2023) was the first time I ever ate there.“

“Absolutely love the entire vibe of the place. The decorations are out of this world. The pizza and mozzarella sticks are some of the best in town. Highly recommend“

“Did a pick up order. Chicken Alfredo, chocolate lasagna cake and minestrone soup. Everything was delicious. Didn’t take long to get my order. The only issue was they put my chocolate dessert in the same bag with the hot food so I had to quickly remove it so it didn’t melt more.“

“Had a pepperoni pizza delivered it was excellent and still hot.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ every time I visit my son we order food to be delivered from this restaurant. Well slice delivery driver took it to the wrong place and delivered it, and it went missing! Well, this restaurant owner felt so bad that they actually made us our food and delivered it within 15 minutes and made it right and I think that’s highly honorable! Their food is so delicious! From now on we’re ordering directly from them, no more middleman!“

“Best Sicilian pizza!!“

“Mike’s has the BEST CHEESESTEAKS!!!! We were traveling and stopped in for lunch and were very impressed with Mike’s, our server Mary Margaret 😍 and our out-of- this world Cheesesteak Sandwich!!! We highly recommend Mike’s Italian Restaurant. Rosemary and Tom. Lake Naomi.“

“Been coming here since they opened about 16 years ago. Every dish has been yummy and plentiful. When you leave Johnnies, you will be full. The prices are very reasonable for the quality and for the proportions you receive. The pizza is the best! The just right crispy crust with homemade tomato sauce and the cheese isn't greasy. Just right! Every time. I travel quite a distance just to eat there and it's worth the 45 minute drive. Sure I can go to other places, but the food, the portions, the atmosphere, the friendly staff, easy parking, the cleanliness, and the way they make me feel like I'm part of their family, makes it hard to go anywhere else. I also like that I can bring my own bottle of wine or any other adult beverage I may want to enjoy with my food. And Johnnie-the man himself- he is the Champion when it comes to making you the best food you will find in the area hands down. Once you try them, you'll understand my review. Thank you Johnnie for every meal and every pizza pie I've had from you. Nothing but the best!“

“Stopped at Leo’s for the first time tonight.. ordered 2 pizzas & garlic knots.. everything was delicious! The crust was perfect. Sausage & peppers added great flavor to an already delicious pizza!! Can’t wait to go back. My kids said it’s their new favorite pizza place. Clean & decorated nicely!“

“I just picked up a plain pie and knots from Villa about an hour ago for lunch with my family. My first time ever trying them and they were friendly, polite, and the food is great!“

“We loved our dinner here, from super fresh salad bar with lovely pastas, 2 homemade soups, stuffed shrimp that was fresh as oceanside and perfectly cooked & seasoned steak! This chef is raising the bar here, so check out this up and coming restaurant gem!“

“excellent food and good people!“

“I recently had Sicily’s cater a family get together for my mom’s 70th birthday. We were impressed with the way the trays were packaged and how everything was so organized when conveniently delivered! The penne Vodka was the favorite! The chicken francaise was out of this world and a huge hit. We also had the sausage and peppers, meatballs, garlic knots and it was just wonderful. I Would definitely recommend having Sicilys cater your next event. And I would absolutely use them again in the future. Thanks to the owner who took the time to deliver everything and was so pleasant to do business with. Great local business to support!“

“I was talking to a friend of mine that must eat gluten free foods. She recommended this restaurant to me because I have another friend who can only eat gluten free. Yesterday we went to try it out! Fantastic!. My friend could not believe that wide variety of foods available. She even bought extra to take home. It was nice to see her so happy. I had "normal" Veal Parm sandwich and sweet potato fries. Excellent! It has now become our favorite!“

“Great service amazing food fast delivery“

“The grilled shrimp salad with the house balsamic is amazing!! Always a great meal.“

“Not sure how anyone can say anything bad about this place. We’ve been here going on nine years tried a lot of different places. This is the best place as far as pizza goes and other sides. you name me one pizza place that’s better than this place and I’ll go, but there isn’t any. Their shrimp Parm is on point. Their pizza is delicious garlic knots are out of this world. And if you’re gluten-free and dairy free, then make your own food. Restaurants don’t wanna hear that there’s freaking dairy/gluten impractically everything and again if you don’t want it, make your own, this place is great! Great job guys!“

“Food is delicious and staff was very friendly and accommodating!“

“If you wanted a good, crispy, almost identical to a New York slice then definitely come here. I live about 25 minutes away and this place is always my first stop when coming to this area.
I recommend a white or Sicilian slice 100%. The white is AMAZING and the Sicilian is thick, fluffy, and just the right amount of sauce and cheese.
The guys who work here are also amazing.
This place has great seating, good lighting, and I personally really like the little trays that they have lol.“