Bumpin Buffalo Bar and Grill

$$ • Bar & Grill, American, Bars

245 Main St, Hill City
(605) 574-2471

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

4 - 334 reviews

I’ve eaten here several times, and this hiking trip, I took my hubby. He loved it so much that we didn’t eat anywhere else. Nothing here disappoints for flavor! Delicious and filling! Our waitress was super nice, and even though they were busy, we felt like our food arrived in a timely manner. We will be back next season! I’m not sure why anyone would complain about the price. I didn’t find it unreasonable at all, especially for being in the Hills.

It's a hit or miss. Certain items on the menu like the buffalo burger are pretty boring. The hot beef combo or the brisket sandwich are both incredibly good.I would recommend reworking the menu a bit to get rid of surcharges. Extra for cheese, extra for sides, extra for dips, it leaves a bad last impression when you get the ticket. It's annoying to have to sit there and think about all the stuff that will cost extra and it makes the overall experience worse. A simple menu is good.

Beautiful antique bar gives it a very wild west atmosphere and the food was fantastic. Service was really great in this era of understaffed-ness and fast turn-over. Had the best french dip. So good.

More Reviews(334)


View all photos


Monday 11AM - 7PM
Tuesday 11AM - 7PM
Wednesday 11AM - 7PM
Thursday 11AM - 7PM
Friday 11AM - 8PM
Saturday 11AM - 8PM
Sunday 11AM - 7PM