46 Best Italian Restaurants near Prosper

“We first discovered this gem thru delivery and we were so impressed with the personal pizza and calzone that we had to go in! My fave is the Marguerita pizza. We’ve been in twice and love the service, fresh and tasty food and the price point! Lovely ambience. Can’t wait to go back with friends. Delicious 😋“

“Got the Shrimp scampi and the asparagus is now less than ever. Just short sticks. Different than before. Pls fix this as otherwise everything was good.“

“This is the best gluten-free pizza I have ever had!! The owner was SO kind and friendly with our group of 10. The food and service was outstanding, and we will definitely use this restaurant for our pizza needs! ❤️🎉 Thank you for being so kind and welcoming, and thank you for the delicious pizza and salad!“

“The best Italian in Texas! I’m highly impressed with the food, presentation, and staff. You must try everything by becoming a regular here. Great for family dinner, date night, or a business dinner.“

“Amazing Chef-curated Italian !!!“

“Excellent authentic Italian food...party of 5 went for Mother's Day and each of us had a different dish. Everything was excellent including cocktails. Service was great and attentive. Will definitely go back for lunch and dinner. Finally a great Italian restaurant close to us!“

“Honestly one of the most consistent food choices on 380. I’ve here 5 or 6 times and absolute banger! Love it.
It’s kinda like a chipotle but for pasta.

The service is amazing and all the employees conduct service well.

I would skip the pita roll things.
And it can get a bit pricey but… The quality is amazing.“

“Delicious food! Super fresh!!“

“Excellent service. Catered an event for me and could not have been more pleased. Food was delicious and plentiful. You cannot go wrong using this restaurant.“

“Best service ever with Audi last night. Lovely live music as well. We have been in 3 times already and love it.“

“The food is amazing. I've been twice in a week span and I'm addicted. I ordered the Verona special pizza and not to sound like I'm boasting but it's one of the best pizzas I've ever had. the crust has this unique really tasty flavor. first visit I had the chicken parm and it came with two large chicken breasts smothered in red sauce with a good side of spaghetti noodles and sauce. It was amazing and very filling. This place is definitely a wonderful spot. And they are very busy with take out orders so you know the food great.“

“We had a couples baby shower for our daughter and her husband with 35 guests in the party room last Saturday. From the lovely setting to the service and food, everything was incredible. We received so many compliments from our guests. Thank you Holly, Ephraim and our amazing servers who helped make this a very special day.“

“Lovely ambiance, nice people. Fresh, unique. quality ingredients. We love it! ❤️“

“Sitting at the light and craving Italian food/parmesan chicken. So, I googled Italian food and this place popped up 0.2 miles and I was like 🤔 guess that’s where I’m going! Lol And, I was definitely impressed with this place! Look at this plate! The salad was fantastic too! I’m not one to just go and try random places. But, I guess I’ll be doing it a lot more! Lol“

“I’m standing up for this restaurant owner because they refuse to let people bring their pets into their establishment. If you have a trained service dog, it should be marked as so. Just because you want to go out to eat with your dog does not mean you should be allowed entry into every establishment you want. Order your food to go and take it to a local park.“

“Had the Philly Cheesesteak sub and the Pesto Mozzarella sub, both were excellent!! Great menu selection and awesome tasty food!“

“We had a great experience at this Olive Garden. The food was good and the service really set it apart. Our server, Lauren, was helpful on menus choices, very attentive (she must had refilled our salad twice proactively). Thanks for the great dinner for the family.“

“This is a great little Italian place. The started bread is probably some of the freshest and tastiest bread I have ever had, it definitely has that home made taste. The pizza was great and so was the mancotti. You won't go wrong eating here.“

“First time here
I can give them four stars in total.
But the garlic bread we ordered wasn't even close to garlic bread.It just looked like a bread with butter.
The cheese bread was good .Also we ordered spinach calzone it was just ok .“

“Lombardi's catered my wife's birthday party at our home and did an incredible job. Chef went way out of his way and prepared the BEST spread I could have ever imagined. George came and helped serve and tended bar. He was so gracious and everyone loved him. Can not say enough about how happy my wife was. We are always treated like royalty when we dine in the restaurant. If you have a house party these are the go to folks to make it special. Pepe, George, Stefan and the rest of the A Team. Thank you. You are all special to us!“

“We tried the Gallo Nero food today. The two women that greeted us at the front door were so polite and helpful. We had ordered a pizza and piece of cake to go and we decided eat on the patio. They brought out a high chair for my infant daughter and brought out all the food to the patio. It was such wonderful dining experience. The wife and I rarely get to go on a date with young kids but this was not only amazing food but awesome service. I will be back again with more friends and family.“

“The cheese pizza with added ricotta is phenomenal!“

“Food was hot but not seasoned well. Staff was friendly and attentive“

“yes yes yes yes yes yes to this restaurant. Like and follow and go eat!!!“

“Eating at Olive Garden never disappoints. But our server Jonathan makes the lunch experience even better. He always was ahead our needs, bread, drinks, food, etc, he took care of every detail. Thanks Jonathan we will be back!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻“

“Was feeing Italian food and my friend and I wanted to also eat at a place that gave us a European vibe. Food was decently good. Service was great, staff was kind and professional. We ordered calamari, the mussels and linguine in red sauce and a chicken Alfredo pasta, finished with coffees and a lemon cream cake. The pasta dishes were good and plentiful but I feel like the mussels and linguine was missing some seasoning that I can’t quite put a finger on. It was still good. The lemon cream cake was good but the lemon was almost too subtle, and it tasted more like a pound cake. We still enjoyed our food and time there. I wouldn’t mind giving it another go. Great for small or large groups. Till then let’s eat!“

“We have been trying pizza restaurants for months and haven't found anything we really enjoy. Emily's is SO good. The crust, toppings, and sauce are excellent. We're addicted.“

“I am a rare person who does not use social media. I don't write reviews. But after a wonderful dinner, our family was served last Saturday night, something needed to be said. My son-in-law and I are fortunate to share a birthday. Kathy and I have wanted to try Crudo's for about a year. Last Saturday, we were joined by our two daughters and son-in-law, plus our grandkids. So three generations were there. We each agree it was the most memorable experience we have had in a very long time. Ernesto did a great job serving fantastic meals and desserts. I love that the atmosphere is welcoming and quiet enough that we could actually talk with one another. But what happened after dinner really sticks with me. Ari, the owner, chased me down in the parking lot to again wish me Happy Birthday and say how much he appreciated spending it with my family. That was amazing. We will be back again and again.“

“Best meatball sub anywhere. Layla is awesome upfront also!!“

“Cute little place with delicious pasta! I have tried different pastas they serve and all of them were on point!!!!!! Service is also great, Eduardo was very polite, friendly and had great recommendation on the menu. Also service is quick, so if you are using the Tesla Supercharger, this is the best spot to stop. I wish they could open a location in Fort Worth because that is where I live!“

“This place is awesome the sauce is amazing it's different from their places in the fat that is Rich and hearty it's not watered down the toppings are rich in flavorful you're going to have to wait 20 minutes to get your pizza but man it's worth the wait it is great pizza and with the wait! Call it in and plan!“

“I picked up pizza that is it“

“We went for their Thanksgiving Buffet. The assortment of food was terrific and the food was delicious but it was all cold or like warm......ruined the experience . We would have given 5 stars but eating all your food warm / cold is unfortunate. The chaffing dish stations needed to be HOT and staff should have been checking this. I am sure the food would have been outstanding if it was hot.“

“Everything was great. Bakery was awesome“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We had an amazing experience at this pizza place!
We ordered the chicken wings, and they were absolutely delicious—perfectly cooked with a unique, flavorful seasoning. The shrimp Alfredo was beyond amazing, served with cheesy garlic bread that tasted incredible.

We also tried two pizzas: one half pepperoni and half cheese, and the other with pesto sauce, veggies, and chicken — honestly, one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

The roasted potatoes were super crispy and light, and the salad was so fresh and full of flavor. They also served us a za’atar and cheese manaqeesh that was out of this world — the mix of cheeses and the flavor of the za’atar reminded me of home in Palestine.

Highly recommend this place! The food is delicious, the prices are very reasonable, and everything tastes homemade with a special touch. ❤️🍕“

“We recently had the pleasure of having dinner at Millie's. The staff and the service was exceptional. The food was just amazing. We are so glad we found this place as we are surely coming back. We met the owner and she was a delight. Everything we ordered was prepared well and we enjoyed some awesome authentic Italian dishes.“

“Thanks Crhis & Parrys team members! Kids loved the pizza. Came through in the clutch for our littles birthday!“

“The best pizza outside of Italy!“

“This is hands down my favorite spot for pizza and stromboli! They’re generous with the toppings, and the crust has a flavor that stands out from the rest. It’s truly a hidden gem. The prices are very reasonable, especially compared to other pizza places, and it’s locally owned and operated. Definitely worth a try!“

“We had a wonderful experience at Palio’s McKinney! We were searching for a local business that could comfortably host the Kung Fu Academy of North Texas’s 2-year anniversary appreciation dinner (about 25 people), and Palio’s exceeded every expectation.

From the very beginning, Ramon was incredibly responsive. He immediately offered to reserve the space for us and even encouraged us to bring banners and anything else we needed to enhance the celebration. When we arrived, the tables were marked with custom “Reserved” signs featuring our logo which was a thoughtful touch that meant a lot.

Our pre-order was ready right on time, the food was delicious, and the service was outstanding throughout the night. I had ordered two cakes and let Ramon choose the flavors; he surprised us with one beautifully customized with our academy’s name.

The team truly went above and beyond to make our anniversary special. We couldn’t be more grateful, and we look forward to celebrating with Palio’s again!“

“Really good pizza and pasta. Good portions and lots of flavor“

“This was our first time today and its really good! We had a calzone,a pizza ,wings and dessert. We'll definitely go back!“

“Amazing East Coast style pizza in Texas! Highly recommend!“

“Our family’s favorite Italian restaurant in Frisco! 🙌🏻“

“Ordered for 6 everyone loved their food except me. My eggplant parm was like rubber. Maybe it was old? Aside from the eggplant texture the flavors of the dish were good. I tasted a bit of everyone else's and it was also fine.“

“Great Customer Service and food was amazing as always“