Sandwich Shops near West Orange

“The three guys working today around 5:30pm were working like a well oiled machine! It was fairly busy with several people in front of and behind me, but they were able to keep the line moving without making people feel rushed and getting all of the orders out and correctly with good timing. I've spent most of my adult life in the food industry and their hygiene, food handling, and customer service were all on point! Of the subways in Orange, this is definitely the best one. Great job, guys! Hope you're working next time we come in 😁“

“I had an amazing experience at the Subway location in Orange. The staff was friendly, fast, and made my order exactly how I wanted it. Everything was fresh, the restaurant was clean, and the service went above and beyond. Easily one of the best Subway experiences I’ve had—definitely recommend this location.“

“Camryn is very attentive and kind to every customer that walked through that door(even if they were less than kind to her). On another note..that was the best gosh darn golly wolly pizza I ever had. I was ascending to heaven. My feet were off the ground. I owe my life to Camryn“

“Dec 27, 2025
I arrived around 9:51 PM and honestly thought the staff member might be upset since it was close to closing time. But I really appreciate how kindly and respectfully he spoke to me. I bought two sandwiches, and I had two kids with me who were very hungry, so I didn’t have many options since Subway was open only until 10 PM. He was very understanding and helpful. Thank you so much, man I forgot to ask your name, but your kindness truly meant a lot to us. (From Texas)“

“This subway had the freshest ingredients I have seen at a Subway in SO LONG. Both the gals working behind the counter were extremely polite and efficient. It's unfortunate we were just passing through. Our Subways up where we live in DFW are nowhere near this nice, both ingredient wise and customer service. I would eat at them more often if they were. I'm sorry to say I didn't catch either of their names. But I know how hard it is to find good help these days, and it seems you hit the jackpot.“