4.1
Good
159 Reviews
2249 Shirlington Road, Arlington · 6.18 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Chicken Portabella Calzone
- Mozzarella Sticks
- Chicken Wings
- Garlic Knots
“If you are looking for a reliable, family-owned spot in the Shirlington area that serves up genuinely fresh, high-quality Italian comfort food, Pizza Pie Me is well worth checking out. What makes their pies stand out is the commitment to doing things right: they make their dough and sauces in-house daily, and you can really taste the quality in their exclusive cheese blend. The crust hits that sweet spot of being hand-tossed, crisp on the outside, and soft on the inside, holding up well under a generous layer of toppings. Beyond the classic pizzas, their stuffed calzones and fresh-baked subs are major crowd-pleasers. The only reason it’s sitting at 4 stars instead of 5 is that it's primarily geared toward takeout and delivery with very limited seating, so it’s not quite an ideal spot if you're planning a sit-down dining experience. Overall, it's an awesome local gem for a quick, delicious, and authentic pie. Highly recommended for pizza night!”