23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fairlawn

“My Fiancée , along with my best friend Steve, and I met at Troy’s today for lunch and our cheesesteaks were absolutely delicious! The service was fast and prompt. I moved away from the area in 1999 and going to Troy’s for an amazing cheesesteak was perfect. On top of that, the Owner had overheard that it was my 52nd birthday and surprised our party of 3 with Baklava! Can’t wait to go back!“

“There was an issue with the customization of our pizza on the site that honestly made it tough to make. (Be careful to review your toppings and sauce selections, I’m not sure who would ask for extra barbecue sauce on a pizza, but it definitely wasn’t my intention). The shift leader, Connor, was very kind and helpful to explain what had happened and to rectify the situation. It was the kind of customer service that makes you more likely to give someone more of your business than if everything had gone perfectly from the start. Thank you!“

“Would prefer to give this location at 4.5 because sometimes the pizza isn’t made with care and is all crust or is lacking cheese, etc. Overall, however, this location is our favorite in the area. The staff is mostly young people and they are always kind and courteous. This location seems to have a crew that gets along and banters together which I find refreshing. My wait times are always reasonable. Sometimes they have cookies for kids which my littles really enjoy. For a small building, there’s adequate outside seating but the lobby just has a couple of chairs to wait for your order to be made. The building looks new and fresh outside and the inside lobby and viewable kitchen are always super clean and inviting. We ordered last night and waited for it to be made which took less than 20 minutes. We were treating one of my children as the other is away and it was one of our best experiences so far with staff and the quality of products.

Kid-friendliness: Sometimes this location has complementary short bread cookies in a pack for kids!“

“We just moved here and stopped in to check the restaurant out and the food was amazing. They were very polite and attentive! We definitely recommend giving them a try!!“

“Best Ruben I’ve ever ate!!!“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Always excellent food, staff is friendly and they take cafe off their customers. They always seem to have plenty of people working. Great beer selection and bourbon selections“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..“

“some good stuff and convenient at most stores I love it“

“last time we placed the order they didn’t let us know there was no cookie pizza available. I had ordered online. So we were a bit disappointed. But I gave it another go tonight and everything was perfect. They were pleasant on the phone confirming my online order, the order was prepared in a good amount of time, and everyone at the store was nice to talk to. I got a three cheese small pizza, garlic Parmesan wings, and of course the cookie pizza which is my son’s favorite. Everything was delicious.“

“Love everything about this place! If you have any overstimulation issues with sensitive ears, bring headphones but otherwise everything is amazing. :) love the workers, pizza is best tasting to me, and the price is good for the amount!

Vegetarian options: Cheese Pizza“

“Love Sal’s, and the food is always on point, but our service experience today was extremely disappointing. We asked for patio seating. There were only two other tables (both had 4 people), one group was at the end of their meal, the others halfway through theirs. We sat there with no service for 15 mins and finally had to go in and get someone. Food came quickly…I’m guessing because the waitress could tell we were ticked off. Anyway, it was at least another 15-20 mins before we were checked on again, and took another 7 mins for my drink refill. We normally tip 25%, but today it was about 9%, and that was because I didn’t want to be a total jerk. Again, very disappointed.“

“I cannot say enough good things about this Dominos location- several years back the quality of the pizza leveled way up, it always arrives hot, the drivers are super quick and timely, not to mention friendly. I have not been disappointed once. Whatever changes the company implemented, it's definitely working out big time :)“

“Maddie was such a pleasant young lady so polite and attentive We drove 12 hr from Canada hungry and tired we left with happy full stomachs returned the next night without disappointment“

“I ordered unsauced wings and a sausage and mushroom Papadilla. The delivery person, Paige, is wonderful and professional. The wings tasted delicious without any dipping sauce. Whoever put my order together didn’t read the stickers and gave me a meatball, pepperoni Papadilla instead of what I wanted.When I tried calling the store, all I got was a busy signal. When I called Paige, she promptly said she would make sure it would be remade.If all went right, I would have given 5 stars. Because of Paige, I gave 4, otherwise it would have been a lot less.“

“Great food, great people. We eat here at least 3 times a week. Highly recommend!“

“Any time we’ve delivered through Highlander Pizza the staff has been phenomenally kind. My fiancé and I have been sick this week and the delivery was quick, and the driver was very friendly. Always appreciate the service and great food from this place.“

“Food was delicious, made quickly and our server was on point.“

“We tried this Papa Johns twice recently on different occasions a couple of weeks apart. We were just traveling through and it's a good stop over for the night. A major deciding factor was that this Papa Johns would deliver, even if it was through something like DoorDash or such. But they do it all through the Papa johns, so you do not have to have a door dash account or such. This is why I gave them four stars instead of three.
The food was OK. It was edible, but by far not the best pizza I've ever had. But to be fair to Papa Johns, it wasn't the worst either. It was good enough to order it a second time. More so for the convenience than quality and taste. So it provided us with a meal. Maybe not the best meal ever, but by far not the worst meal ever either. But a 12 inch pizza delivered is over $20. So the convenience of delivery is not the cheapest option. But most folks wanting this convenience understand.
But I will point out that the main and only reason we ordered from this Papa Johns the first time and again the second, was totally because they delivered without having to go through a third party. If I had to pick it up, without a doubt, we would have chose other options.
Bur I also will point out that we did order from them a second time, again for the convenience . So they could not have been all that bad.“

“Awesome food, service & prices!“

“love Domino's pizza in Dublin,VA. they are so very nice and sweet to my husband and myself. Food always delivered on time.Still nice and hot. Food is so good. Thanks Domino's. until next time.“