5 Best Italian Restaurants near Mattaponi

“***update to my previous review. Be aware they double fry their fries! I asked for new fries that were not doubled cooked. They basically refused the waitress. Poor girl had to come out and tell me they just look like that. I'm sorry but this is the sign of a lazy cook.“

“I absolutely loved my visit here! Service is too notch. Clean restaurant! TV's with sports on! Food is cheap(a family of four eat for under $100!). Lastly this place just felt super welcoming! This is a gem you will not want to pass up! Enjoy!“

“We were on the way to downtown West Point when we passed Nick's. The parking lot was full and it was Thursday. Turned around and so glad we did. Both of us ordered the medium Delmonico. Cooked perfect. But the baked potato was most perfect and the fries the same. I think that we made a great choice to stop in here. The salad was fresh and plenty. Service was excellent and as we sat there it was obvious that everyone knew everyone. What a place. When you read it is a locals favorite I am always sceptical but in this case it is true. Can't wait to return to try some more of the menu. Oh and the deserts I saw go by were huge. This is a must try if you haven't been“

“Everything I ordered was hot and fresh tasting. I had the Catfish, Hush Puppies, Baked Potato, and Coleslaw. The New England Clam Chowder was good and not too over- seasoned. Our waitress was very quick to fill our drinks, we never asked for refills. Reasonable prices too. There were quite a few people in the restaurant, but it was not noisy. I could talk across the table in a normal voice. Nice atmosphere.“

“My husband stopped and picked up pizza, wings, and cheesecake for my family for dinner because I used to eat here when I was a kid and it was always good…Oh my goodness it was even better than I remember! Everything was 10/10. Absolutely delicious. Best pizza, wings, AND cheesecake I’ve had in a long time. And on top of that the woman on the phone was really sweet when I called back to add to my order. We will definitely be returning.“