12 Best Italian Restaurants in Mechanicsville

“Great spot and can't believe we haven't been here before. Service was old school- polite and attentive. Food was authentic Italian, red sauce, pasta, bread, salads- you name it. Also the bar has a ton of beers and ciders on tap that you can run your card and help yourself. Convenient location too with ton of parking!“

“Brunettis is the best pizza place in Hanover county by far. I've had their pizza multiple times and it isn't super greasy like its competitors and it is way more authentic compared to fast food. This time I tried the Chicken Parm Sub and it was so so good. They fill this sandwich up to the brim with chicken, marinara, and mozzarella. The chicken is breaded nicely and the roll it is served on is almost like a baguette but softer. It actually adds a nice bite and crunch to the sub. This sub was filling, but if you are super hungry I would recommend the French fries as a side. They are to die for and surprisingly really good for a pizza shop. We also ordered the garlic knots (not pictured) and those are phenomenal too. They are pretty decent in size and drenched in the famous garlic sauce. They are airy and pillowy which add to it. The service is amazing at brunettis. The front desk worker was able to answer any questions and the staff constantly asked if we needed anything and refilled waters nicely. Lastly, although they are known for their takeout, the small dining room can still be enough for a small group of friends to enjoy a meal. The price is very affordable for the quality and quantity that you get. I highly recommend brunettis to all my friends that want an authentic and reasonably priced Italian meal!“

“1st time visiting so I didn't know what to expect. Dined in, but the restaurant is more of a pick up / delivery spot with only a couple of high top tables inside. The pizza menu is creative with quite a selection of specialty pizzas, subs, and other items. Took a few minutes to decide because of the number of choices. Everything we had was fresh tasting and the pizza crust was a really good thin crust. The staff was very knowledgeable about the menu and very helpful with suggestions. Will definitely be stopping by again when I'm in a pizza mood!Parking: Drive through pickup window available.“

“Imagine succulent salmon fillets grilled to perfection, infused with the tangy zest of lemon butter that tantalizes your taste buds with each bite. The richness of the buttery sauce complements the delicate salmon, creating a symphony of flavors that dance on your palate. As you savor each morsel, the burst of briny capers adds a delightful contrast, enhancing the overall depth of the dish.Accompanying the salmon are plump, tender mussels bathed in a luxurious garlic butter sauce. With every spoonful, the aroma of garlic fills the air, inviting you to indulge in its savory essence. The velvety texture of the butter coats each mussel, amplifying their natural sweetness and creating a harmonious blend of flavors.Together, the lemon butter grilled salmon and butter garlic mussels create a culinary masterpiece that is both comforting and exquisite, leaving you craving for more with every unforgettable bite.That is my experience though ?“

“Deliciousssssssssssssssssssssss Italian cuisine! I stopped in for a to go order of chicken parmesan, side salad and dessert and when I say it was absolutely excellent. Everything was hot and ready to eat with amazing quick courteous service. I truly enjoyed my meal and would definitely recommend this place. Very reasonably priced and I can't wait to return to try some more great items on the menu!“

“Been going here since we were little. John has treated our family with the upmost respect. (Gentilini) This will always be my home Italian restaurant. Thank you for everything you've done and continue to do for us! I wish more food was made this way.“

“Their food is fresh and delicious. My wife always gets the Caprese salad and the Sicilian Lasagna, and I get the Lidia's Special or the Chicken Marsala, which are both amazing. They do a lot of takeout business, but the restaurant is also very warm and inviting for a sit-down meal as well. The staff are all pleasant and hard working.“

“Absolutely love their Pizza.... I haven't had anything else there yet!... if it's as good as their Pizza!! This would be the place to go. They are friendly the prices are reasonable... I love the fact that they deliver also when I need it“

“We found Pastahouse after realizing traffic was pretty bad after the Richmond marathon expo at the raceway. This was a pre race meal so we were hoping for fresh and clean food. This place is a gem! Absolutely amazing! Chicken parm, eggplant parm and chicken Marsala were excellent! So fresh and good. Website multiple times that we wish we had a place like this back home. Highly recommend!“

“Incredibly noisy little restaurant. The place was packed but they still had the 80s blasting over the stereo. Made it hard to think.Waitress forgot our apps, but we weren't charged so no biggie. Portion size is tremendous. They're unfortunately giving customers two meals for the price of one. Food flavors and everything we're downright excellent. Would go again, just ask them to turn the background noise down a notch.“

“I LOVE this restaurant! Great value for what you get - large portions! I always take at least half of my food home and make more meals with it. The owners are amazing people, and the employees are very nice. Most know us well and our frequent orders. Some days are better than others with the food and service, but I'm understanding. No one is perfect and having worked retail myself, I understand what it's like to be busy.Vegetarian options: Penne with marinara, tomato, or garlic sauce.“

“I do not live in town and called on a Friday to see if the restaurant could accommodate a group of 45 the next evening. They said they were able to do so. On Saturday morning, the owner called to verify all of the details and tell us they would be ready. We showed up a little early and they were ready for us. They were so great in getting everyone's orders in a timely manner and keeping up with all the food that the group of teenagers kept ordering! We highly recommend Mimmo's and will come back the next time we are in town.“